Of all the epithets hurled at Donald Trump since he became US president, perhaps the most unusual was delivered last week – that he is, in fact, some sort of environmentalist.
asserted
he → hurl → environmentalist
Trump is the “greatest gift” to the environmental movement, argued Gavin Newsom, California’s governor, due to the fallout from the US-Israel war on Iran.
asserted
Newsom → argue → Iran
“He’s woken the world up to how vulnerable we are to petro-dictatorships, how vulnerable we are to disruptions in the Middle East,” Newsom told the Guardian during Climate Week in New York.
asserted
Newsom → wake → York
“This war has completely gutted any sort of romantic notions of energy security and it’s compelled folks to think differently.
asserted
it → gutte → folks
It’s accelerating investments and clean energy and renewables.
asserted
It → accelerate → investments
The strait of Hormuz, where a fifth of the world’s oil and gas exports usually flow, is now starting to open up but has been routinely snarled since the Iran war began in February, causing the cost of these fossil fuels to soar around the world.
asserted
cost → flow → world
Countries reacted by scrambling to cut their oil and gas use while turning to cleaner forms of energy such as solar and wind (although there’s also been a small uptick in coal, the dirtiest of fossil fuels).
asserted
Countries → react → fuels
The overall consequence has been a positive one for our shared climate, with global fossil fuel emissions set to drop by 0.5% this year due to the crisis, Carbon Brief has estimated.
asserted
Brief → set → crisis
The peak in oil consumption may have been sped up enough to arrive this year, rather than the previous estimate of 2029, according to the International Energy Agency.
uncertain
peak → speed → Agency
By launching the war, Trump is set to achieve something only dreamed about by climate advocates and not seen outside global economic crashes or the Covid-19 pandemic – an annual reduction in the emissions that are overheating our planet.
asserted
that → launch → planet
The president’s imposition of tariffs and importation of foreign ground beef, meanwhile, may also end up hurting the US cattle industry, another major source of greenhouse gas emissions.
uncertain
imposition → end → emissions
“It’s a curious thing to say, but I believe it,” Newsom, a potential contender for the Democratic presidential nomination, said of Trump as a sort of unintentional biophile.
asserted
Newsom → ’ → biophile
“This moment will mark how we can’t go back to our original form.”
asserted
we → mark → form
Yet the idea of Trump as an environmentalist, even an accidental one, can still appear faintly absurd.
asserted
idea → appear → environmentalist
His administration has eviscerated pollution limits on cars, trucks and power plants, funnelled taxpayer cash and favors to the fossil fuel industry and set about unilaterally cancelling renewable energy projects.
asserted
administration → eviscerate → projects
Trump, who has never by available evidence ever set a Florsheimed foot in any of the US’s national parks, has called environmentalists “terrorists”, the climate crisis “a hoax” and has slashed conservation rules to the extent you can now kill a protected species as long as it wasn’t provably intentional.
asserted
it → set → species
Perhaps tellingly, when asked during the 2024 election campaign about his environmental credentials, Trump cited his Florida golf course getting awards for “the way I built it, for the water, the way I use the water, the sand, the mixing of the sand and the water.”
asserted
I → ask → sand
Critics say this record overshadows any embrace of clean energy by other countries spooked by an oil price that has hovered about $100 a barrel for months but should, at some point in the interminable Iran conflict, drop well below this.
asserted
that → say → this
The impetus for quitting fossil fuels could wither when it does so.
uncertain
it → quit → fuels
“Trump’s illegal attack on Iran may hasten clean energy in some countries, but he has gutted green tech in the United States and set us back decades,” said Rob Jackson, a climate scientist at Stanford University who said Newsom was guilty of “tunnel vision” in his framing of Trump.
uncertain
Newsom → hasten → Trump
The conflict may have rocked the oil and gas industry but it has also enriched it, netting eight of the largest companies more than $90bn in just the first three months of the war, with even pro-oil Trump complaining that the major fossil fuel firms are “making too much money”.
uncertain
firms → rock → money
There is little sign big oil fears a looming obsolescence when this bonanza ends.
asserted
bonanza → be → obsolescence
Last month, Exxon forecast that while the world will reduce its emissions, it will still use 105m barrels of oil a day in 2050, up from 100m barrels last year.
asserted
it → forecast → barrels
Two-thirds of the global energy mix will stubbornly remain comprised of oil, gas and coal at the midpoint of the century, the oil company estimated.
asserted
company → remain → century
“All of the oil that is produced will be burned – if they produce more, more will be used,” said Juan Carlos Navarro, environment minister of Panama.
asserted
Navarro → produce → Panama
“The people who predict that there will be a reduction in the emission of greenhouse gases are simply lying or blind.
asserted
who → predict → gases
The only hope is that the world “can cap consumption and production at levels similar to the ones we have right now”, Navarro added, citing the enormous energy demand of artificial intelligence datacenters, which are largely being run on gas-fired power.
asserted
which → cap → power
However, climate advocates maintain the Iran conflict will accelerate trends that are already swinging behind clean energy.
asserted
that → maintain → energy
Investment in renewables globally is now double that of fossil fuels, almost all new power being added to grids comes from clean sources and last year one in four cars sold was electric.
asserted
cars → add → sources
Unlike previous oil shocks, the world now has a viable alternative to fossil fuels, even if it’s unclear how lasting an impact Trump’s military and trade actions will have in pushing countries towards them.
uncertain
actions → have → them
“There is one thing that all these events are making clear,” Ursula von der Leyen, president of the European Commission said in April.
asserted
Leyen → be → April
“We are paying a very high price for our over-dependency on fossil fuels.”
asserted
We → pay → fuels
Countries from the UK to India to Thailand have sought to speed up the transition to renewables as the price of fossil fuel dependency has spiraled, saving billions.
asserted
price → seek → billions
Electric vehicle sales have surged, although not in the US.
asserted
sales → surge → US
Trump has urged other countries to reject the “scam” of clean energy but the market is increasingly favoring cheap wind, solar and batteries that have plummeted in cost in recent years, including in the US.
asserted
that → urge → US
“Demand has massively spiked for solar and for battery storage,” said Sonia Dunlop, chief executive of the Global Solar Council.
asserted
Dunlop → spike → Council
“We’re seeing that all over the world – the Philippines, across Europe, across Southeast Asia, Australia and beyond.”
asserted
We → see → Asia
“This Iran crisis, which was, in effect, started by president Trump, has led to a massive surge in demand for our technology … but actually it’s just building on a trend that was already there,” she added.
asserted
that → start → trend
Political and business leaders can mull the fact that the wind does not funnel through the strait of Hormuz and the sun doesn’t only shine on a foreign autocrat’s lands.
asserted
sun → mull → lands
The Iran war may not prove a fatal blow to fossil fuels, but it has starkly highlighted their inherent volatility.
uncertain
it → prove → volatility
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
