With the power of the purse, Congress can pressure the president to stand down in Iran by doing what it usually does best: nothing.
asserted
it → pressure → nothing
The U.S. war with Iran passed the seven-month mark this week, and the people in charge of it aren't exactly inspiring confidence.
asserted
people → pass → confidence
Trust the plan, President Donald Trump urged Tuesday: "I don't know if they are going to give up yet, but they'll give up."
asserted
they → trust → plan
Meanwhile, U.S. Central Command has taken to cold emailing military experts "looking for new creative and unconventional ways to pressure and punish Iran."
asserted
experts → take → Iran
Congressional opponents of the war seem equally bereft of ideas on how to stop it.
asserted
opponents → seem → it
Their preferred tool, the 1973 War Powers Resolution (WPR), isn't doing the job—yet they invoke it again and again, expecting different results.
asserted
they → prefer → results
The Senate took another shot last week, missing 49–50.
asserted
Senate → take → shot
Overall, the House and the Senate have taken 20 such votes since Trump launched the war in February.
asserted
Trump → take → February
When Congress passed the WPR over President Richard Nixon's veto in 1973, it meant to provide two independent brakes on presidential warmaking.
asserted
it → pass → warmaking
If either of them actually worked, "Operation Epic Fury" would have been over in May—after the war passed the 60-day mark—or in June, when both houses of Congress passed resolutions ordering Trump to withdraw.
uncertain
houses → work → Trump
The WPR's first brake was supposed to operate automatically: Section 5(b) commands the president to "terminate" military operations after 60 days absent congressional authorization.
asserted
president → suppose → authorization
Trump has alternately ignored the deadline or tried to game the system by claiming that each pause in the fighting constitutes a new war and resets the clock.
asserted
pause → ignore → clock
The second brake, the basis of last week's Senate vote, was supposed to give Congress a means of voting an illegal war to a close.
asserted
brake → suppose → close
WPR section 5(c) stipulates that U.S. forces "shall be removed by the President if the Congress so directs by concurrent resolution."
asserted
Congress → stipulate → resolution
Three months into the Iran War, Congress so directed.
asserted
Congress → direct → War
First the House, on June 3, then the Senate, on June 23, passed the same concurrent resolution directing "the President to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities against the Islamic Republic of Iran."
asserted
Senate → pass → Iran
Leave aside the old-fashioned notion that, in a constitutional democracy, the legislature is supposed to get a vote before we go to war; under the original plan, a congressional majority would have been enough.
asserted
majority → leave → plan
It's not enough anymore: The Supreme Court broke that mechanism when it struck down the legislative veto in 1983.
asserted
it → break → 1983
Now any attempt to halt an illegal war has to be presented to the president who started it, for his signature or veto.
asserted
who → halt → signature
Getting past Trump's veto takes a supermajority of both houses: a higher bar than it would take to impeach and remove him from office.
asserted
it → get → office
Still, there's a much easier way Congress can pressure the president to stand down.
asserted
Congress → be → president
It doesn't take a supermajority to defund a war.
asserted
It → take → war
It just takes inaction.
asserted
It → take → inaction
To date, we've spent over $40 billion on the president's Iran adventure, yet Congress has never passed specific appropriations for any of it.
asserted
Congress → spend → it
The administration has been paying the bills by tapping into Pentagon funds authorized for other purposes, such as military training and readiness.
asserted
administration → pay → training
In 2011, President Barack Obama found enough loose change in the Pentagon budget to bomb Libya for seven months, despite Congress's refusal to authorize the war.
asserted
Obama → find → war
But that illegal war cost less than $2 billion all included.
asserted
war → cost → billion
The tab for Trump's war of choice is currently running $2 billion to $3 billion a month.
asserted
tab → run → billion
The problem with off-budget warmaking is, sooner or later, you run out of other programs' money.
asserted
you → run → money
Facing "an urgent budget shortfall," the Trump administration requested Epic Fury funds in June.
asserted
administration → face → June
In July, the House passed a budget resolution incorporating the ask.
asserted
House → pass → ask
The supplemental request now sits with the Senate, which seems in no particular hurry to comply—they'll likely take it up after the midterms.
asserted
they'll → sit → midterms
Historically, using the power of the purse has proved "the most effective way to compel a President to take actions regarding use of U.S. military force overseas that he otherwise might not agree to," the Congressional Research Service has noted.
uncertain
Service → use → that
In the past, Congress has wielded that weapon most effectively by attaching strings to funding the president needs and forcing him to wind down unauthorized wars.
asserted
president → wield → wars
But here, doing nothing—simply refusing to pass the supplemental—would be a good start.
asserted
doing → do → supplemental
Already, Republicans on the campaign trail have been desperately distancing themselves from Trump's folly, echoing the strong voter sentiment that the war needs to end.
asserted
war → distance → sentiment
If there's a midterm bloodbath, those who return to Capitol Hill may find themselves wondering just how far they should stretch to help Trump prolong a disastrous war he launched without consultation with Congress, let alone a vote.
uncertain
he → be → Congress
The Aporia
