The unfolding court drama over New York City’s pied-à-terre tax isn’t just about billionaires.
asserted
drama → unfold → billionaires
It’s about fundamental rights of all Americans.
asserted
It → ’ → Americans
New York’s Democratic Party is trashing those rights and violating the legal principles that underpin America’s successful economy in order to finance their socialist spending spree.
asserted
that → trash → spree
Between elections, we must go to court in defense of these rights and fight hard.
asserted
we → go → rights
On Tuesday, New York State Supreme Court Judge Wayne Ozzi ruled that Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s rollout of the pied-à-terre tax deprived homeowners of their due process rights.
asserted
rollout → rule → rights
The city had notified some 17,000 house- and apartment-owners that they owed the tax and had a mere 30 days to prove otherwise — or be hit with hefty penalties.
asserted
they → notify → penalties
It was flipping the burden of proof onto homeowners to show their property is their primary residence and exempt from the tax.
asserted
property → flip → tax
Ozzi ordered the city to redo the rollout, this time honoring property owners’ due-process rights.
asserted
Ozzi → order → rights
But City Hall is standing pat, vowing to appeal rather than clean up its act.
asserted
Hall → stand → act
A Mamdani spokesman huffed, “The ultra-wealthy are fighting in court to avoid paying their fair share.
asserted
wealthy → huff → share
They have filed lawsuit after lawsuit to protect their privilege, and we will not back down.”
asserted
we → file → privilege
’
“Privilege” is the wrong word; “rights” is the correct one, and they belong to all of us.
This week, former US Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross and casino magnate Steve Wynn sued, challenging the tax itself, not just the rollout, and a group of real-estate owners filed an almost identical suit.
asserted
group → belong → suit
Full disclosure: I was married to Ross from 1995 to 1998.)
asserted
I → marry → 1998
Both suits argue the tax violates both the US and New York constitutions and must be struck down entirely.
asserted
tax → argue → constitutions
Yet Gov. Kathy Hochul’s spokesperson sneers, “When Steve Wynn and Wilbur Ross try to cast themselves as sympathetic figures in a fight over paying their fair share on multimillion-dollar second homes, they’re making the case for the pied-à-terre tax as well as anyone could.”
uncertain
anyone → sneer → tax
Translation: Only “sympathetic figures” are entitled to due process and other constitutional protections.
asserted
figures → entitle → process
That’s a frightening prospect — the reverse of what this nation has always stood for.
asserted
nation → ’ → what
Ross and Wynn argue the tax violates the US Constitution’s Interstate Commerce Clause and Privileges and Immunities Clause by discriminating against nonresidents who own a home here.
asserted
who → argue → home
The Constitution bars states from imposing penalties on residents of other states.
asserted
Constitution → bar → states
It’s a winning argument: In 2000, the New York State Court of Appeals struck down the NYC “commuter tax” for doing that very thing.
asserted
Court → ’ → thing
The US Supreme Court has voided several state laws that unconstitutionally deprived nonresidents of their rights, including a New Hampshire law that tried to exclude nonresidents from practicing law there, a South Carolina law that tried to charge shrimp fishermen from other states a higher license fee than in-state fishermen and an Alaska law compelling employers to give preferences to in-state job applicants.
asserted
that → void → applicants
In 2015, the court struck down a Maryland law that imposed a tax disadvantage on out-of-state businesses; Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the majority, argued this was the “Balkanization” the framers wanted to prevent.
asserted
framers → strike → majority
Technically, New York’s pied-à-terre law taxes residential properties that are not a primary residence, regardless of where the owner lives, but Hochul, Mamdani and the other pols who pushed the tax to fill the city’s coffers have defended it as a tax on outsiders — just what the Constitution prohibits.
asserted
Constitution → tax → what
Again and again Hochul said about pied-à-terre owners, “They’re part of our skyline, but these people are not part of our city.”
asserted
people → say → city
She defended the tax as affecting “out-of-towners.”
asserted
She → defend → towners
Those words will come back to bite her in court.
asserted
words → come → court
The lawsuits also nail Hochul and Democratic legislators for their sleazy attempt to evade the state Constitution’s 2.5% cap on how much city real estate can be taxed in any one year by calling the pied-à-terre tax a “surcharge” instead.
asserted
estate → nail → tax
Call it what you want, if the government is taking money out of your pocket, it’s a tax.
asserted
it → call → pocket
These lawsuits should succeed on the merits, but sadly the state’s judiciary — including the Court of Appeals — has become a rubber-stamping arm of the far-left Democratic Party.
asserted
judiciary → succeed → Party
That’s why we are plagued with so many “let ’em loose” judges.
asserted
’em → ’ → judges
If the suits fail there, the litigants should head straight into federal court, where they are likely to prevail.
asserted
they → fail → court
The pied-à-terre tax was tacked on to the state budget at the last minute without a thought as to whether it was legal or prudent, and then it was rolled out even more recklessly.
asserted
it → tack → thought
The lesson for all New Yorkers from this pied-à-terre fiasco is that Mandani’s out-of-control spending is fueling an avaricious hunt for money from whoever has it, the law be damned.
asserted
law → fuel → it
The Aporia
