Cornell University police spoke to witnesses and received anonymous tips about an alleged gang rape at a fraternity house in the first weeks of its investigation two years ago, but the local prosecutor did not review the additional information before deciding not to bring charges.
asserted
prosecutor → speak → charges
Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten said he based his decision not to pursue charges on the accuser’s initial six-page statement given to police.
asserted
he → say → police
Investigators from the campus police department documented those witness interviews and other steps taken to determine whether Jane Doe, a 20-year-old woman who reported the incident, was the victim of sexual assault during a party at the Chi Phi house from Oct. 19 to 20, 2024, according police records obtained by NBC News.
asserted
who → document → News
Documents reviewed by NBC News offer the most thorough look to date at how police handled the allegations from Jane Doe, who last month filed a lawsuit against Cornell University and seven Chi Phi brothers who she alleges sexually assaulted her over the course of hours while she was under the influence of ketamine, alcohol and marijuana.
asserted
she → review → ketamine
Houten, along with police and university officials, has come under intense fire for their handling of the matter.
asserted
Houten → come → matter
Jane Doe’s attorney has argued that she was failed by authorities who did not conduct a thorough investigation and who prejudged the events based on her earlier statement that she consented to parts of the night.
asserted
she → argue → night
Gov. Kathy Hochul on Thursday announced the appointment of Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor to consider whether charges are appropriate.
asserted
charges → announce → prosecutor
“In what world does the district attorney not even interview her or anyone else involved, or even request the full transcript” of the victim’s interview, Hochul asked Friday at a news conference announcing James’s appointment.
asserted
Hochul → interview → appointment
On Nov. 25, 2024, a police investigator approached Van Houten’s office to tell them about interviews they’d done.
asserted
they → approach → interviews
An investigator in Van Houten’s office, according to the documents, replied that “he and several [attorneys] at the District Attorney’s Office had read [Jane Doe’s] statement … [and] stated that they all agreed that, based on [Jane Doe’s] statement, criminal charges would not be pursued in this case.”
uncertain
charges → accord → case
Van Houten defended his decision Monday and said that Jane Doe’s statement did not allege criminality.
asserted
statement → defend → criminality
He also agreed to reopen his inquiry before that role was assigned to the attorney general.
asserted
role → agree → general
When reached for comment by email Friday, Van Houten argued “there was nothing to review” in that discussion with police because the interviews flagged “were each of the frat members declining to speak on the advice of their attorney.”
asserted
each → reach → attorney
Van Houten did not respond to a follow-up request asking whether he was told about interviews with other fraternity members in addition to tips from callers.
asserted
he → respond → callers
The records also show that police were receiving fragments of a larger Snapchat thread where one member of the group announced there was “free p----” in the alumni room of the house, where Jane Doe engaged in what she said was initially a consensual threesome.
asserted
she → show → house
“Similarly there was no material obtained by CUPD from Snapchat (what was provided came from a witness),” Van Houten added.
asserted
Houten → be → witness
It was unclear whether Van Houten was aware that on Nov. 26, 2024, police made a request to Snapchat for a more complete data history.
uncertain
police → make → history
That request was answered on Dec. 23, when police said they obtained 1,665 pieces of data from five Snapchat accounts.
asserted
they → answer → accounts
“After reviewing all of the data returned from Snapchat, there appeared to be only 3 snapchats that included [Jane Doe] or mentioned this incident,” a CUPD investigator wrote.
asserted
investigator → review → incident
“None of these 3 snapchats show anything that can be construed as being criminal in nature.
asserted
that → show → nature
No further action taken.”
asserted
action → take → ?
Jane Doe was only notified by Cornell police about the district attorney’s Nov. 25 determination not to pursue charges nearly two months later on, Jan. 21, 2025.
asserted
Doe → notify → Jan.
Van Houten added that his office had “no part in the timing” of conveying his decision to Jane Doe, who was never interviewed by his office.
asserted
who → add → office
Thomas Giuffra, the attorney representing Jane Doe, learned about that delay from NBC News’ request for comment Friday.
asserted
Giuffra → represent → comment
He said that his client — during that two-month window — believed “they were still investigating.”
asserted
they → say → window
“I was unaware that they had made the decision to not prosecute in November,” Giuffra said.
asserted
Giuffra → make → November
“If so, that is worse than I thought.”
asserted
I → think → ?
If you or someone you know has been sexually assaulted, call the National Sexual Assault Hotline at 1-800-656-4673.
asserted
you → know → 4673
The hotline, run by the Rape, Abuse, & Incest National Network (RAINN), can put you in contact with your local rape crisis center.
asserted
hotline → run → center
You can also access RAINN’s online chat service at rainn.org/get-help.
asserted
You → access → rainn.org/get-help
The Aporia
