On the morning federal immigration agents shot Alex Pretti in the back, Emmanuel Mauleón, a law professor at the University of Minnesota, was standing on a ladder outside his house, pulling down holiday decorations.
asserted
Mauleón → shoot → decorations
That's when his phone started buzzing.
asserted
phone → start → ?
Pretti's death would quickly become a national news story.
asserted
death → become → ?
Coming soon after the killing of Renée Good, this was the second time in less than a month that the federal agents swarming Minneapolis had gunned down an American citizen in the street.
asserted
agents → come → street
The outcry forced the Trump administration to reassess its aggressive deportation tactics, prompted a reshuffling of officials overseeing those efforts, and led to congressional hearings and investigations that are ongoing.
asserted
that → force → hearings
Before footage of Pretti's death spread across social media and news outlets around the world, many residents of the Twin Cities learned what happened the same way Mauleón did: via urgent pings on their phones.
asserted
Mauleón → spread → phones
For weeks, a sprawling, informal network of group chats—largely using the encrypted messaging app Signal—had been a vital part of the public response to what the Trump administration called "Operation Metro Surge."
asserted
administration → sprawl → what
The operation deployed thousands of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials and other federal law enforcement personnel, tasked with apprehending and deporting undocumented immigrants.
asserted
operation → deploy → immigrants
Their tactics were blunt and aggressive, as they disregarded warrant requirements and drew allegations of racial profiling and unlawful arrests.
asserted
they → disregard → profiling
In response, those decentralized Signal chats turned ordinary Minnesotans into modern-day Paul Reveres.
asserted
chats → turn → Reveres
Participants shared information about ICE activity, warned businesses of potential raids, helped track agents and vehicles across the city, and organized legal assistance for detainees.
asserted
Participants → share → detainees
On January 24, those networks lit up with footage of federal agents pepper spraying, tackling, and shooting Pretti multiple times.
asserted
agents → light → Pretti
"My phone started blowing up with videos from Signal and then finally the news," says Mauleón.
asserted
Mauleón → start → Signal
"I remember being stunned and standing on the top [of the ladder] for too long, worried about my footing."
asserted
I → remember → footing
It's been more than seven months since Pretti was killed and nearly that long since Operation Metro Surge came to an end.
asserted
Surge → kill → end
Across Minneapolis, however, it can feel as though little time has passed.
asserted
time → feel → Minneapolis
Many bars, restaurants, and coffee shops have signs on the door telling ICE agents they are unwelcome.
asserted
they → have → agents
Some signs explicitly tell the feds to come back with a warrant.
asserted
signs → tell → warrant
Anti-ICE messages adorn front lawns and sidewalks.
asserted
messages → adorn → lawns
Mauleón calls it "the residue of resistance."
asserted
Mauleón → call → resistance
A friend flips open Signal and scrolls through several still-active chats while we watch a soccer game at a bar on Nicollet Mall in late June.
asserted
we → flip → June
The federal occupation is still discussed in the present tense.
asserted
occupation → discuss → tense
Those same chats now sit at the center of another story.
asserted
chats → sit → story
In a 94-page indictment filed in June, the Department of Justice (DOJ) accused 15 protesters of participating in a conspiracy to interrupt federal immigration enforcement and law enforcement operations.
asserted
Department → file → operations
That alleged conspiracy was coordinated via "social media, text messaging, and encrypted messaging applications, such as Signal," the indictment explains, "with the goal of preventing, hindering, delaying, and impeding the enforcement of federal immigration law."
asserted
indictment → allege → law
The defendants have pleaded not guilty.
asserted
defendants → plead → ?
Has the Trump administration finally brought antifa to justice?
asserted
administration → bring → justice
In a statement, the White House called the indictment "a crushing blow" to the "domestic terrorist organization."
asserted
House → call → organization
Those who participated in or cheered on the protests against immigration enforcement during Operation Metro Surge are calling it something else: a worrying crackdown on Americans' First Amendment rights to talk and organize with their neighbors, friends, and co-workers against the federal government's violent behavior.
More Than a Few 'Far-Left Agitators'
The week before Pretti was killed, Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino was asked about the response he'd seen to ICE's operations in the Twin Cities.
asserted
he → participate → Cities
Operation Metro Surge was the latest in a series of similar efforts that had played out across various American cities during President Donald Trump's first year back in office.
asserted
that → play → office
Bovino had played a major role in planning and executing them.
asserted
Bovino → play → them
He'd clearly relished his role as the public face of the operations.
asserted
He → relish → operations
Bovino strutted through snowy Minneapolis in a leather trench coat and clashed with protesters—in one video that made the rounds on social media, he lobs a canister of tear gas into a jeering crowd.
asserted
he → strut → crowd
"We've been in many cities, as you know.
asserted
you → know → cities
We've been in Los Angeles and Chicago, Charlotte, New Orleans, and now, obviously, Minneapolis," Bovino told reporters.
asserted
Bovino → tell → reporters
"What we've seen that's a bit different here is the organization of some of the groups.
asserted
that → see → groups
The groups are a bit better organized."
asserted
groups → organize → ?
Months later, Luis Argueta, communications director for Unidos MN, a nonprofit that played a critical role in organizing the protests and resistance efforts in Minnesota, remembers feeling proud when he heard that line.
"It was the height of compliments," he says.
asserted
he → play → compliments
Starting last year, Unidos MN and a sister organization, Monarca, began offering what they call "legal observer trainings."
asserted
they → start → what
The trainings focused on informing people of their rights and the rights of anyone targeted by immigration enforcement, as well as what law enforcement is and isn't allowed to do.
asserted
enforcement → focus → what
…and 128 more, not listed.
The Aporia
