Elon Musk and Palmer Luckey's new Pentagon roles raise ethics worries
asserted
roles → raise → worries
A new Pentagon study focusing on the future of warfare is raising ethical concerns about its authors' potential conflicts of interest.
asserted
study → focus → interest
Last week, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth announced "Project Meridian: The Future of Warfare," a study of automated and AI-powered weaponry.
asserted
Hegseth → announce → weaponry
The study is expected to take 120 days.
asserted
study → expect → days
"We are witnessing rapid advances in artificial intelligence, autonomy, directed energy, robotics, biotechnology, among other critical high-tech areas.
asserted
We → witness → areas
Combined, these new domains, new ways of fighting, and technological developments will profoundly alter the character of warfare," Hegseth's September 30 announcement said.
asserted
announcement → combine → warfare
"To maintain global dominance, the United States must anticipate future operational environments and act decisively to develop the tools to dominate in them."
The study's announcement came
asserted
announcement → maintain → them
Anduril Industries builds military drones that are used on land, sea and in the air and other related defense technologies.
asserted
that → build → air
The company received its initial funding from tech billionaire and conservative political activist Peter Thiel.
asserted
company → receive → Thiel
SpaceX has secured over $8 billion in U.S. defense contracts in 2026 alone, according to government contract announcements.
uncertain
SpaceX → secure → announcements
One of its flagship products is Starshield, a military-grade, low-Earth-orbit satellite network designed to provide secure communications for the government.
asserted
One → design → government
The company's AI chatbot, Grok, is also being used by the Pentagon.
asserted
chatbot → use → Pentagon
There is a concern that Musk and Luckey's study would be guided by their own financial interests, said Richard Painter, a professor of corporate law at the University of Minnesota and former chief White House ethics lawyer in the George W. Bush administration.
asserted
Painter → be → administration
"They all want to sell stuff," Painter said.
asserted
Painter → want → stuff
"So if we go into it understanding that [Musk], like all the other contractors, he wants to make a lot of money selling AI to the Defense Department.
asserted
he → go → Department
Whatever he proposes, but it's not like he's doing it as a neutral public service.
asserted
he → propose → service
"
"It's a massive conflict of interest," said a former senior Defense Department official who requested anonymity out of fear of reprisal from the Trump administration.
asserted
who → say → administration
The official said that not only do both Luckey and Musk have billions of dollars in current defense contracts, but the study could also shape the types of munitions the U.S. buys in the future.
uncertain
U.S. → say → future
For example, it could recommend more drones or space-based assets — which both Luckey and Musk build — and fewer tanks, which they don't build.
uncertain
they → recommend → which
Hegseth said he has directed Emil Michael, the Defense Department's chief technology officer, to commission Project Meridian through the MITRE Corporation, a nonprofit company that manages federally-funded research across the country.
asserted
that → say → country
Few details were released about the scope of the project in Hegseth's one-page memo.
asserted
details → release → memo
"MITRE is responsible for the analysis and recommendations, and will evaluate all inputs with technical rigor while applying appropriate conflict-of-interest and information safeguards," said a spokesperson for the Department of Defense.
asserted
spokesperson → evaluate → Defense
"The Project Meridian effort will examine the technologies and operational concepts required to sustain U.S. military advantage across the full spectrum of future warfighting domains across a 10-20 year time horizon.
asserted
effort → examine → horizon
The Department of Defense did not disclose whether Musk and Luckey have been hired as special government employees — as Musk was when he led the Department of Government Efficiency cost-cutting effort — or as contractors.
asserted
he → disclose → contractors
The nature of their employment on the project would dictate the rules they would need to follow, Painter said.
asserted
Painter → dictate → rules
Executive branch employees are bound by federal criminal law that bans them from taking part in government decisions that affect their own money or the financial interests of their family and business.
asserted
that → bind → family
The Department of Defense did not respond to questions about the potential conflicts of interests of hiring Musk and Luckey to lead the Project Meridian study.
asserted
Department → respond → study
SpaceXAI and Anduril did not respond to requests for comment about their CEOs' potential conflicts of interest.
asserted
SpaceXAI → respond → interest
While it is common for the federal government to assemble task forces with industry leaders, the findings and recommendations of the Project Meridian study will need to be scrutinized, said a senior official at the Government Accountability Office, speaking on the condition of anonymity because they are not authorized to speak to the press on issues they have not published reports on.
asserted
they → assemble → reports
"There are safeguards that they're supposed to sign to keep them away from procurement activities and whatnot," the GAO official said.
asserted
official → be → activities
"That doesn't mean that we shouldn't be paying attention to what the project comes out with.
asserted
project → mean → what
"
Additionally, the motivations for creating this task force are unclear, the official said.
uncertain
official → create → force
"I don't know why we would need a new task force to talk about something since we've had many folks thinking about this issue for a while," the official said.
asserted
official → know → while
Another former Pentagon official who requested anonymity fearing retribution from the administration was less concerned.
asserted
who → request → administration
The official said there are always numerous efforts underway in the Pentagon and in the military services to ponder the future of war, and all those will likely feed into Project Meridian.
asserted
those → say → Meridian
The former official said it's one thing to be on such a panel and make recommendations, and for Congress to accept or reject them, and another for a panel member to write a requirement for a defense system and then bid on it.
asserted
member → say → it
The second Trump administration has employed different ethical standards than the administrations that preceded it, including holding stocks in companies that could stand to profit from contracts awarded by the government, Painter said.
uncertain
Painter → employ → government
"I do not know why they held on to defense stocks.
asserted
they → know → stocks
In the Bush administration, we made everybody sell their defense stocks who went into the Defense Department," Painter said.
asserted
Painter → make → Department
"I never saw anywhere near as many financial conflicts of interest in any other administration.
asserted
I → see → administration
The Aporia
