Planning Minister Sonya Kilkenny has used her sweeping fast-track powers to green-light a string of controversial developments in the past fortnight, before the state government enters pre-election caretaker mode.
asserted
government → use → mode
Developers now have permission to convert a former orphanage into apartments in Surrey Hills that will rise above local height rules and to build a 15-storey apartment tower in Oakleigh three levels higher than the government’s own limit.
asserted
that → have → limit
Kilkenny has also approved planning scheme changes so work can progress on a seven-storey hotel in St Kilda, 1100 new homes at the site of the old Talbot Quarry in Oakleigh South, and more than 200 homes in Nagambie.
asserted
work → approve → Nagambie
The projects have faced intense pushback from local councils and some residents, including those who say the developments will tarnish neighbourhood character or that their concerns were not considered appropriately by the government.
asserted
concerns → face → government
The government will enter caretaker mode at 6pm on November 3, and conventions dictate ministers do not make significant policy decisions until after the November 28 election.
asserted
ministers → enter → election
Kilkenny approved the Surrey Hills, Oakleigh and St Kilda planning applications via the government’s Development Facilitation Program, a scheme that enables developers to bypass council processes and gives the planning minster ultimate say over whether eligible major projects should be allowed.
asserted
projects → approve → say
The scheme has been criticised by councils and residents who are powerless to overturn the minister’s ruling, and the opposition, which claimed the minister was forcing through the developments.
asserted
minister → criticise → developments
But Kilkenny said every proposal was considered on its merits, and the facilitation program had approved more than 15,000 homes to help tackle the housing affordability crisis.
asserted
program → say → crisis
Plans for the 76-apartment orphanage redevelopment in Surrey Hills include demolishing a 1941 school building subject to council heritage protections.
asserted
Plans → include → protections
The redevelopment will be two levels above existing height limits for the area, which is not located within an activity centre the government earmarked for development but is about 500 metres from a train station.
asserted
government → exist → station
Boroondara Mayor Wes Gault said the council wanted new housing in the area to be respectful to “irreplaceable heritage properties” like St Joseph’s Home for Boys.
asserted
housing → say → Boys
“The community made their views clear to the minister for planning on this development, but it is obvious local views on heritage and local character are not important to the minister, who has a long track record of approving inappropriate developments over community views,” he said.
asserted
he → make → views
A spokesperson from Tract Consultants, which worked with developer Antipodean Land Developments, said the approval provided an opportunity to reinvigorate a significant site that has been dormant for years.
asserted
that → work → years
“The design response carefully integrates heritage restoration and adaptation with new housing, set within generous landscaping and amenities,” the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → integrate → landscaping
In St Kilda, Kilkenny approved plans for a seven-storey hotel, enraging residents and the council.
asserted
Kilkenny → approve → residents
St Kilda locals Kylie Morrigan and Mal Webb are among neighbours with concerns, including the project’s scale being out of proportion with nearby properties.
asserted
scale → include → properties
They are disappointed there is no option to appeal the planning permit at VCAT.
asserted
They → disappoint → VCAT
“It’s a little tiny wedge in the midst of an old, old suburb that’s very established, and there’s no wiggle room really,” Morrigan said.
asserted
Morrigan → ’ → suburb
“We don’t object to the site being done up, we don’t object to development per se.
asserted
we → object → development
It needs to be in context.”
asserted
It → need → context
Port Philip Mayor Alex Makin said local government had been undercut by the minister.
asserted
government → say → minister
“All it does is disempower the community and disconnect these planning applications from a broader vision,” he said.
asserted
he → do → vision
The Oakleigh building includes 122 apartments, shops and four levels of basement parking around the corner from the suburb’s Eaton Mall.
asserted
building → include → Mall
In planning documents issued on the project’s approval, the Department of Transport and Planning noted the state’s own 12-storey height limit under activity centre plans was discretionary, and the site could handle more intense development to meet housing needs.
uncertain
site → issue → needs
Monash Mayor Stuart James said he was disappointed concerns about “excessive height”, impact on surrounding streets, overshadowing of public places and environmental issues were not reflected in the approval decision.
“This development is substantially taller than what had been anticipated for the area and does not reflect the carefully planned vision for future growth in Oakleigh,” he said.
asserted
he → say → Oakleigh
Kilkenny also modified the planning scheme on Monday to enable work to progress on 1100 new homes at the former site of the Talbot Quarry in Oakleigh South.
asserted
work → modify → South
Locals previously spoke out over “slimes” deep beneath the surface, and approval bids from the developer failed to progress with Monash council twice.
asserted
bids → speak → council
James said last week’s zoning change did not address long-term arrangements needed to manage contamination, landfill gas and ground conditions.
asserted
change → say → contamination
Neil Li, CEO of the developer, Sterling Global, said a 2020 environmental audit found the site was suitable for sensitive residential use, and all works would be monitored and carried out under site management requirements.
asserted
works → say → requirements
“As approved by the EPA, no site remediation is required; it is only subject to site management measures and conditions,” he said.
asserted
he → approve → measures
Kilkenny also made similar changes enabling a developer to clear native trees and build a lifestyle village in Nagambie, about 130 kilometres north of Melbourne.
asserted
Kilkenny → make → Melbourne
The council and local nature-lovers fought the decision for more than six years, before the minister approved it directly last week.
asserted
minister → fight → it
Developer Hallmarc’s proposal includes more than 200 homes, and chief executive Michael Loccisano said the application had been through an exhaustive process.
asserted
application → include → process
“We’ve minimised the amount of vegetation to be removed and will now enable much-needed affordable housing to proceed … which will serve mostly the ageing population within both Nagambie and people looking to relocate to a regional area to live.”
asserted
which → minimise → area
Opposition planning spokesman David Southwick said the slew of approvals was a “pathetic last-ditch” attempt to force through controversial developments.
asserted
slew → say → developments
“Labor has turned the planning system against locals,” he said.
asserted
he → turn → locals
“Labor is forcing these developments through from Spring Street because it knows local communities would never support them.”
asserted
communities → force → them
But the planning minister said councils and community members were able to voice their concerns, and every project was approved on its merits.
asserted
project → say → merits
“This is a simple change to help young Victorians and it is working – Victoria is building thousands more homes than any other state but we know there is more to do,” Kilkenny said.
asserted
Kilkenny → help → state
Jonathan O’Brien, chief executive of pro-higher density housing group YIMBY said it was positive that Kilkenny was making sweeping approvals of housing developments before the government enters caretaker mode.
asserted
government → say → mode
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
