- Published
A backlash over the handling of a US woman's sexual assault complaint against Cornell University fraternity members has highlighted what experts believe are issues with the current laws in many states regarding sexual assault and drinking.
asserted
experts → publish → assault
The woman, known as Jane Doe in legal documents, last month filed a lawsuit alleging she was drugged and raped by several men in 2024 at the university in the state of New York.
asserted
she → know → York
Doe said she had been drinking earlier in the evening of the alleged incident and then went to a fraternity house, where several men pressured her to snort the drug ketamine and plied her with alcohol before advertising a "free" sexual encounter with her in a group message.
asserted
men → say → message
She said she was intoxicated during the alleged incident and could not provide consent.
uncertain
she → say → consent
Under current New York law, a person who voluntarily consumes drugs or alcohol - rather than becoming intoxicated without their consent - is not automatically considered unable to consent to sex.
asserted
who → consume → sex
US media has been widely reporting it as the "voluntary intoxication loophole".
asserted
media → report → loophole
New York Governor Kathy Hochul last week said: "Voluntary intoxication is not a license for sexual assault or gang rape" and that she would work with the state legislature to close the "loophole".
asserted
she → say → loophole
But some experts say the law has been misinterpreted and that it does not stop people who choose to consume alcohol or drugs from reporting sexual assault.
asserted
who → say → assault
It does, however, require them to prove they were so incapacitated they could not physically consent - a higher bar than being intoxicated.
uncertain
they → require → bar
The distinction reflects an ongoing debate in the US about what counts as consent when someone has been drinking.
asserted
someone → reflect → consent
Dan Schorr, a former sex crimes prosecutor, told the BBC that New York law still protects victims of assaults who have chosen to drink or take drugs.
"
asserted
who → tell → drugs
If a person cannot express consent or lack of consent due to the consumption of alcohol or drugs, any sexual activity with them is always non-consensual, whether the ingestion of alcohol or drugs was voluntary or involuntary," said Schorr, who also helps universities review sexual assault cases.
asserted
universities → express → cases
"I prosecuted many people who sexually assaulted someone who was voluntarily intoxicated," he said, adding: "I got convictions.
asserted
I → prosecute → convictions
They went to prison."
What counts as incapacitated?
asserted
What → go → prison
Some believe issue with the current law is that the bar is set too high with regards to what counts as being too intoxicated to give consent.
asserted
what → believe → consent
At least 19 states, including New York, have a higher bar for the level of intoxication required to deem someone incapacitated and unable to consent.
asserted
someone → include → intoxication
The New York law includes a provision that someone cannot consent to sex if they are "unconscious or for any other reason physically unable to communicate an unwillingness to an act".
asserted
they → include → act
This applies to people who are too incapacitated from drinking to consent, Schorr said.
asserted
Schorr → apply → people
But another legal expert the BBC spoke to says that can be difficult to prove.
asserted
that → speak → ?
Some prosecutors "may not bring charges or defendants may be acquitted because someone 'gave consent' while intoxicated, but not completely incapacitated", according to Mitchell Epner, a former prosecutor who has handled sex trafficking cases.
uncertain
who → bring → cases
He said that in other states that have lower legal bars for incapacitation, someone who is "impaired" or "significantly impaired" cannot consent, and that being too drunk to drive a car could be considered as being at this level.
uncertain
being → say → level
College campuses have different standards for consent than criminal law, including Cornell, which uses a standard of affirmative consent, defined as "a knowing, voluntary, and mutual decision among all participants to engage in sexual activity".
asserted
which → have → activity
Cornell says silence or lack of resistance does not constitute consent.
asserted
silence → say → consent
A push for change
Epner supports a proposed change to New York's law to widen the scope of when someone is too intoxicated to consent.
asserted
someone → support → scope
The New York Senate has passed a bill multiple times, but the state Assembly failed to bring it up for a vote.
asserted
Assembly → pass → vote
That bill states that people cannot give consent if they are under the influence of substances that have rendered them "temporarily incapable of appraising or controlling" their conduct, and "such conduct was known or reasonably should have been known" to the other person.
asserted
conduct → state → person
Pennsylvania has also made efforts to try and change the law to make it easier for victims who were intoxicated to prove they were assaulted.
asserted
they → make → law
"If somebody's too drunk to drive, they're too drunk to - fill in your verb of choice," Epner said.
asserted
Epner → drive → choice
Representative Lea Webb, whose district includes Cornell University, told the BBC News Channel she and her fellow lawmakers were working to push through legislation on the issue, which has gone through several amendments.
asserted
which → include → amendments
New York's current laws, she said, "puts the onus of proof on the victim".
asserted
she → say → victim
Schorr and criminal defence attorneys, meanwhile, criticised the proposed changes to New York's sexual assault laws.
asserted
Schorr → criticise → laws
New York's State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers said in a statement to the BBC New York's current laws were sufficient, and that "people have been convicted of rape in cases involving voluntarily intoxicated victims".
asserted
people → say → victims
The group said using language that a victim was "incapable of appraising or controlling their conduct" was "simply too vague to be fairly enforced", adding that the legislation does not give clear details on what constitutes someone being too intoxicated to engage in sexual conduct.
Schorr said it was not easy to answer this question of what exact point someone is too intoxicated to consent.
asserted
someone → say → question
He added: "How should the law address that?
asserted
law → add → that
It is very challenging to find a clear standard that will be evenly applied.
asserted
that → find → standard
"It's a conversation we should have as a society, as a state".
asserted
we → have → state
The Aporia
