THE HAGUE - South African judge Navanethem “Navi” Pillay, who was awarded the Nobel peace prize on Oct 9, has been a judge on several international courts, including the International Criminal Court (ICC).
asserted
who → award → Court
Here are some facts about this court:
When was the ICC set up and why?
asserted
ICC → set → court
The court was established in 2002 to prosecute individuals for war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide and the crime of aggression when member states are unwilling or unable to do so themselves.
asserted
states → establish → aggression
It can prosecute crimes committed by nationals of member states or on the territory of member states by other actors.
asserted
It → prosecute → actors
It has 125 member states.
asserted
It → have → states
The court's budget for 2026 is about €196 million (S$280 million)
What is the ICC investigating?
The ICC is conducting investigations in the Palestinian territories, Ukraine, African states such as Sudan, Uganda and Democratic Republic of Congo, Venezuela, Myanmar and the Philippines.
asserted
ICC → investigate → Congo
It says there have been 34 cases before the court, some with more than one defendant.
asserted
It → say → defendant
ICC judges have issued 68 arrest warrants.
asserted
judges → issue → warrants
Notable ICC suspects are Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, accused of being criminally responsible for acts including murder, persecution and using starvation as a weapon of war in the Gaza conflict, and Russian President Vladimir Putin, accused of the war crime of illegally deporting hundreds of children from Ukraine.
asserted
suspects → accuse → Ukraine
Israel and Russia, neither a member of the court, have repeatedly denied committing atrocities in Gaza and Ukraine respectively and have argued that the ICC has no jurisdiction over them.
asserted
ICC → deny → them
When it issued the warrant for Netanyahu, the ICC also issued a warrant for Hamas military commander Mohammed Deif, whose death was confirmed after the warrant was issued.
asserted
warrant → issue → Deif
The court has also issued arrest warrants for two senior Afghan Taliban leaders, accusing them of persecuting women, an allegation that the Taliban reject.
asserted
Taliban → issue → that
Prosecutors have requested warrants for Myanmar’s military leader Min Aung Hlaing for crimes against humanity in the alleged persecution of the Rohingya, a mainly Muslim minority.
asserted
Prosecutors → request → Rohingya
The outcome of that request has not been made public.
asserted
outcome → make → request
What trials are pending?
asserted
trials → pende → ?
Former Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte is due to go on trial on Nov 30 to face charges of murder and attempted murder as crimes against humanity related to his war on drugs, accusations he denies.
asserted
he → go → drugs
A Libyan accused of overseeing a notorious prison is also awaiting trial.
asserted
Libyan → accuse → trial
Why does the US oppose the court?
asserted
US → oppose → court
While a US delegation was present for the negotiations that produced the court’s founding Rome Statute in 1998, it never became a member and always opposed ICC jurisdiction over US nationals.
asserted
it → produce → nationals
In 2002, Washington even adopted a Bill nicknamed the Hague Invasion Act, which authorises the president to use “all means necessary” to ensure the release of any US citizen or US ally held by the ICC.
asserted
president → adopt → ICC
In the years that followed, the US supported some ICC investigations, notably into atrocities in Darfur and Uganda, but remained firmly opposed to the court looking into alleged crimes by US troops on the territory of ICC member states.
asserted
court → follow → states
During the first Trump administration, in 2020, Washington imposed sanctions on the court’s then-chief prosecutor and another official over an investigation into whether American forces had committed war crimes in Afghanistan.
asserted
forces → impose → Afghanistan
That ban was lifted by the Biden administration a year later.
asserted
ban → lift → administration
In early 2025, after the ICC announced arrest warrants for US ally Netanyahu and his former defence minister Yoav Gallant, Trump authorised economic and travel sanctions against ICC officials targeting the US and its allies who are not members of the court.
asserted
who → announce → court
Washington has since imposed sanctions on 13 ICC officials including nine judges.
asserted
Washington → impose → judges
At the UN General Assembly in September, Trump called the ICC a “rogue institution” and “an evil group of people” and urged its members to resign.
asserted
Trump → call → members
Why does the ICC claim jurisdiction over some nationals of non-member states?
uncertain
ICC → claim → states
Although the court is supported by many United Nations members and the European Union, other countries such as the United States, China and Russia are not members, arguing the ICC could be used for politically motivated prosecutions.
uncertain
ICC → support → prosecutions
Israel is not a member and does not recognise its jurisdiction, but the Palestinian territories were admitted as an ICC member state in 2015.
asserted
territories → recognise → 2015
This, together with a ruling by judges, means the court can look at potential war crimes carried out by Hamas fighters in Israel and by Israelis in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.
asserted
court → mean → Strip
The reasoning for the warrants for Israeli officials is the same as for warrants against Russian officials for crimes allegedly committed in Ukraine: they concern alleged criminal acts that took place on the territory of an ICC member state.
uncertain
that → commit → state
Myanmar is not a member of the ICC but, in 2018 and 2019, judges ruled that the court had jurisdiction over alleged cross-border crimes that partially took place in neighbouring ICC member Bangladesh, such as deportation and persecution, and said prosecutors could open a formal investigation.
uncertain
prosecutors → rule → investigation
The Philippines is not currently a member but was between 2011 and 2019, when the unilateral withdrawal by Duterte became final.
asserted
withdrawal → become → Duterte
Under the Rome Statute, if a state withdraws, the ICC retains jurisdiction there for crimes committed during the membership period.
asserted
ICC → withdraw → period
How many people has the court convicted?
asserted
court → convict → people
ICC judges have issued 15 convictions and four acquittals.
asserted
judges → issue → convictions
Twenty-three people have been held in the ICC detention centre in The Hague and appeared before the court, and 34 wanted suspects remain at large.
asserted
suspects → hold → court
Warrants have been withdrawn for nine suspects who died.
asserted
who → withdraw → suspects
Terms ranged from nine to 30 years in prison.
asserted
Terms → range → prison
The Aporia
