THE new setup in KP is taking shape rapidly and quietly.
asserted
setup → take → shape
While everyone seems focused on the collective meltdown in the PTI, the province the party ruled until recently is busy setting up a new structure.
asserted
party → seem → structure
The governor announced his new advisory council within days, while the emergency-stricken districts have been provided with their own administrative machinery.
asserted
districts → announce → machinery
A special emergency has been declared in the former Fata regions as well as Bannu, Lakki Marwat, Tank, and Dera Ismail Khan.
asserted
emergency → declare → regions
, these regions will now be managed by a new Area Development Secretariat (ADS), which is to be headed by a bureaucrat, Yahya Akhundzada, an additional chief secretary (ACS).
asserted
which → manage → bureaucrat
It is being reported that he has been given extensive powers akin to those of a cabinet or a provincial government.
asserted
he → report → cabinet
Along with this, a new council has been formed, consisting of four people from each district to assist him.
asserted
council → form → him
Most of these members have been selected, with a few refusals; not bad for a week’s worth of work.
asserted
Most → select → work
At the federal level, a committee headed by Ishaq Dar has been formed to supervise the province.
asserted
committee → head → province
Besides Dar, the committee includes several PML-N stalwarts, mostly from Punjab, such as Rana Sanaullah, Azam Nazeer Tarar, and Attaullah Tarar.
asserted
committee → include → Sanaullah
However, other members include Amir Muqam from KP and Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui from Karachi.
asserted
members → include → Karachi
At times, the plan appears more ambitious than merely addressing terrorism and governance in KP.
asserted
plan → appear → KP
In the past week, whispers have been heard around Islamabad; well-informed journalists have also appeared on television and suggested that this setup might decide the future of the other provinces as well.
uncertain
setup → hear → provinces
If the technocratic cabinets are able to perform well, there is a chance similar setups may be introduced elsewhere.
uncertain
setups → perform → ?
Faisal Vawda, who, too, has much inside news to share, has suggested or hinted at something similar.
uncertain
who → have → something
This is lent credence by the manner in which the new administration has been installed in KP, where governor’s rule is accompanied by a special setup for the 12 districts; if there were ever to be smaller provinces in the country, these districts could easily take the form of a ‘South Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’ province.
uncertain
districts → lend → province
At times, the plan appears more ambitious than merely addressing terrorism and governance in KP.
asserted
plan → appear → KP
Be that as it may, all these ambitious plans — if there are any — will have to wait until the wrinkles are ironed out in KP.
uncertain
wrinkles → be → KP
I say this because, from the outside, there seems to be a lack of clarity at the moment.
asserted
I → say → moment
There is some confusion about how this new setup will work.
asserted
setup → be → ?
So, will the ADS report to the governor or directly to the federal government?
asserted
ADS → report → government
This also raises the question of what the ADS’s relationship will be with the provincial bureaucracy.
asserted
relationship → raise → bureaucracy
If the ACS and AIG report directly to Islamabad, will this eliminate the need to work with Peshawar entirely?
asserted
this → report → Peshawar
Journalists from the province say the ADS and the federal government will handle development and security directly.
asserted
ADS → say → development
This is why the ADS, according to one colleague, is even being given its own set of finance and planning officials.
uncertain
ADS → accord → officials
But what will happen in matters that do not fall under development and security, such as education and health?
asserted
that → happen → education
That is why some feel that, for the moment, there may still be a need to coordinate with the provincial bureaucracy and thrash out other issues.
uncertain
some → feel → issues
And if that is the case, it can cause delays and hurdles.
asserted
it → cause → delays
After all, red tape and bureaucratic hurdles are routine in the country, but if, in this case, rules need to be figured out or made anew, the delays might be more severe.
uncertain
delays → need → case
In addition, as mentioned earlier, there is confusion over how many issues in this special region will go directly to the prime minister or the provincial setup/governor before being routed to the prime minister.
asserted
issues → mention → minister
While journalists from KP feel the prime minister and Islamabad will deal with all matters directly, the ADR spokesman said in a television interview that the prime minister would handle issues in which the governor and his team could not address the needs of the 12 districts.
uncertain
governor → feel → districts
If the prime minister, or rather the federal government, is to look after every issue, will decision-making power go to the Dar-led committee?
asserted
power → look → committee
It is hard to imagine that Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif will have the time to look into every matter individually.
asserted
Sharif → imagine → matter
The prime minister also prefers to manage matters through committees.
asserted
minister → prefer → committees
But how efficient will this prove to be?
asserted
this → prove → efficient
Of course, the assumption is that decision-making will be quick and efficient because it will take place elsewhere, and the committees we see exist in name only.
asserted
we → take → name
No doubt, this is always a possibility, but how many governance issues can be managed this way?
asserted
issues → manage → ?
Development and security decisions can perhaps be handled in this manner, but will there be no other issues?
asserted
decisions → handle → manner
Though one should remain optimistic, I suppose.
asserted
I → remain → ?
However, let me venture to say that if this new technocratic setup proves to be successful and efficient, it might just end up increasing centralisation of decision-making, which is far removed from the idea of local government and service delivery at the people’s doorstep.
uncertain
which → let → doorstep
The Aporia
