- Published
When Israel's far-right National Security Minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, reached voting age, he was rejected from Israel's army for being too politically extreme.
asserted
he → publish → army
His views have not changed much in the 30 years since then - but Israel has.
asserted
Israel → change → years
Once shunned by the political establishment, he is now part of the government's inner sanctum of ministers.
asserted
he → shun → ministers
On the campaign trail ahead of Israel's general elections next week, Ben Gvir is often surrounded by a jubilant pack of fresh-faced young fans, waving huge party flags over the heads of his numerous security guards.
asserted
Gvir → surround → guards
At the covered market in Ramle - a mixed city of Jewish and Arab Israelis - he told us his message to young voters was to get out and vote.
"We see the support, we see the love [and] we want to win!" he said.
asserted
he → tell → love
More than half a million first-time voters will cast their ballots in this election, which many Israelis see as existential for Israel's future security and identity.
asserted
Israelis → cast → security
Polls suggest it will be a tight race, and the new young voters could help decide the result.
More than 16% are planning to support far-right parties - either Ben Gvir's Jewish Power or the Religious Zionism party of his far-right ally Bezalel Smotrich - according to a poll for one of Israel's most popular newspapers, Yedioth Ahronoth.
uncertain
% → suggest → newspapers
And almost three-quarters see themselves as "right or centre-right", according to another survey for Israel's leading Channel 12 television network.
uncertain
quarters → see → network
"Itamar Ben Gvir gives me a sense of security," said 20-year-old Mordechai, one of the young fans accompanying the politician to Ramle.
asserted
Mordechai → give → Ramle
"Like everyone in history, from Trump to Moses, there are slips of the tongue that are a bit less good.
asserted
that → be → tongue
"
"Itamar will give us safety, and when we go to the army, someone will have our backs and be behind us," said 18-year-old Nadav.
asserted
Nadav → give → us
"I think he's trying to show that we're a strong country.
asserted
we → think → ?
For many years, we couldn't show we're strong in our beliefs.
asserted
we → show → beliefs
We couldn't express our ideology."
asserted
We → express → ideology
Meir Schreiber, an ultra-Orthodox 23-year-old who grew up in London, said the Hamas-led 7 October 2023 attacks on Israel, which triggered the Gaza war, also convinced him that Ben Gvir was the right choice.
asserted
Gvir → grow → him
"Young people understand that peace isn't something we can do," he told me, "because what happens to you when you're young shapes your personality - we saw October 7."
asserted
we → understand → personality
Ben Gvir is a divisive candidate in a divided nation: his political positions include annexation of the occupied West Bank, Jewish settlement of Gaza, and the "voluntary emigration" of Palestinians - positions and rhetoric that are widely condemned by liberal Israelis.
asserted
that → divide → Israelis
Several Western countries have imposed sanctions or travel bans on Ben Gvir and Smotrich for incitement against Palestinians.
asserted
countries → impose → Palestinians
Both men are powerful ministers in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's governing coalition.
asserted
men → govern → coalition
As he and his entourage pushed their way between the stalls, some shopkeepers threw sweets; others, dark looks.
asserted
others → push → sweets
"I don't like him, he sows discord," one stallholder said.
asserted
stallholder → like → discord
There's no problem here, even after 7 October, but his message preys on young uneducated people.
asserted
message → be → people
"
The fact that he appears more popular with 18 to 22-year-olds than with their parents' generation is often put down, at least partly, to the impact of the 7 October attacks.
But political analyst Dahlia Scheindlin, who previously ran many Israeli political campaigns, said it was more than that.
asserted
it → appear → that
"For about the last 20 years, we've seen young Israeli Jews are more right wing than average, and significantly more right-wing on many measures than the 55+ group," she told me.
asserted
she → see → me
"They have grown up under a series of wars with no personal experience of efforts to achieve peace.
asserted
They → grow → peace
But for the most part, they have been socialised into the most extreme terms of the debate [as] legitimate to discuss: annexation, settlement expansion and - after 7 October - annexation of Gaza.
asserted
they → socialise → Gaza
And now they're voting for the first time."
asserted
they → vote → time
A series of classroom debates filmed by Israeli satirist Lior Schleien recently highlighted the extreme views of some young Israelis.
asserted
series → film → Israelis
The debates, in which he challenges racist or extreme views, drew a lot of attention in Israel, and included one exchange in which a student advocates killing all Arab citizens of Israel.
asserted
student → challenge → Israel
That particular video has since been removed from Schleien's website.
asserted
video → remove → website
Surveys suggest that first-time voters here are highly motivated to cast their ballots, with more than 80% saying they are likely to do so.
asserted
they → suggest → ballots
But the same research suggests they are also more sceptical about democratic institutions and less engaged by political protests or petitions.
uncertain
they → suggest → protests
In a race that is largely deadlocked between two stable blocs of pro-government and anti-government supporters, getting new voters to the polling stations could make all the difference.
uncertain
getting → deadlocke → difference
Opposition parties have been engaging younger voters with warnings about threats to democracy, new social media videos and younger candidates.
asserted
parties → engage → democracy
"In 2022 [in the last election], only 59% of the citizens living in Tel Aviv voted - in the most liberal city in the whole Middle East!
asserted
% → live → East
In places where they voted for Ben Gvir, they voted at around 90%," said Yonatan Shalev, a 24-year-old candidate with the centre-right opposition party, Beyachad ("Together"), led by former prime minister Naftali Bennett.
asserted
Shalev → vote → Bennett
He told me that Ben Gvir had understood the power of social media faster than other politicians.
asserted
Gvir → tell → politicians
"The liberal politicians didn't believe in TikTok, didn't believe in Instagram, and he took advantage of that arena."
asserted
he → believe → arena
Shalev said he had pushed his own party to reach young voters through social media.
asserted
he → say → media
"Three months ago, Ben Gvir was still the politician with the most amount of views on TikToks, the most amount of likes on TikTok, and Instagram as well," he explained.
asserted
he → explain → TikTok
…and 15 more, not listed.
The Aporia
