Californians have voted down Proposition 40, a first-of-its-kind levy on billionaire wealth, after a bitter and expensive campaign in which some of the country's best-known technology figures spent heavily to keep their taxes from rising.
asserted
some → vote → taxes
The result is a victory for the Democratic politicians who lined up against the measure, among them Gov. Gavin Newsom, who is weighing a presidential run in 2028.
asserted
who → line → 2028
Opponents of the tax argued it would drive the state's richest residents to move away.
asserted
it → argue → residents
The campaign against the proposition raised about 10 times what supporters did.
asserted
supporters → raise → what
Sergey Brin, who co-founded Google, put more than $100 million of his own money into a political action committee fighting the measure.
asserted
who → co → measure
Most of the revenue was earmarked to replace federal healthcare funding cuts, with 10% set aside for education and food-assistance programs.
asserted
Most → earmark → programs
SEIU United Healthcare Workers West, which supported the proposition, said it was needed to cover an estimated $100 billion in federal healthcare money the state is set to lose over five years.
asserted
state → support → years
Proposition 40 was the nation's biggest test yet of an idea progressives have championed for years: taxing the ultra-rich on the main way they build their fortunes, their investments, rather than the wages they earn from working.
asserted
they → champion → fortunes
Liberal figures from outside California backed it, including Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, who spent the campaign's final weeks touring cities across the state to press voters to approve it.
asserted
who → back → it
Billionaires poured millions into Building a Better California, a political action committee working to defeat the measure.
asserted
Billionaires → pour → measure
The committee, which also supported other ballot measures designed to nullify the tax, raised more than $333 million, with nearly a third of that coming from Brin.
asserted
third → support → Brin
Brin and Larry Page, his fellow Google co-founder, were among the billionaires who began cutting ties with California in anticipation of the possible tax.
asserted
who → begin → tax
Mark Zuckerberg, another tech mogul, said he would stay in the state for eight years and struck a deal with Meta to help him pay the tax without giving up his ownership stake in the company.
asserted
him → say → company
Some traditional Democratic allies, among them Planned Parenthood and the California Medical Association, joined the coalition opposing the proposition.
asserted
allies → join → proposition
They worried about how the revenue would be divided and about the strain on the state's budget if wealthy taxpayers left en masse.
asserted
taxpayers → worry → masse
California's budget depends heavily on income tax paid by its richest residents.
asserted
budget → depend → residents
“Proposition 40 was a reckless experiment conducted on our state’s economy with little regard for the harms it would cause,” the coalition said in a statement.
asserted
coalition → conduct → statement
Robert Swonger, an auto glass technician living near Sacramento who's politically independent, said before voting concluded Nov. 3 that he planned to vote against it.
asserted
he → live → it
“Obviously, I would like billionaires not to have as much money as they do,” he said.
asserted
he → like → money
“But I don’t believe taxing them out of existence is going to work.”
asserted
taxing → believe → existence
Progressive politicians, among them Sanders and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, have long backed a federal wealth tax.
asserted
politicians → back → tax
Newsom argues a California version would put the state at a disadvantage, though he supports a national minimum tax on anyone whose net worth exceeds $100 million.
asserted
worth → argue → million
Days before Sanders held his California rallies last month, Newsom told reporters that the senator's focus on wealth inequality was “spot-on.”
asserted
focus → hold → inequality
But he said, “On this issue, we fundamentally disagree.”
asserted
we → say → issue
Backers of the California tax have recently begun running ads in New Hampshire, New Mexico and Virginia, states that vote early in the 2028 Democratic presidential primary, attacking Newsom for his opposition to the measure.
asserted
that → begin → measure