Democrats swept Republicans on Nov. 3, but some of their party’s progressive ideas didn’t make it with them, as a host of liberal ballot initiatives failed and conservative proposals passed across the country.
asserted
proposals → sweep → country
In California, where Republicans lost every major race by landslides, voters rejected a billionaire wealth tax, made it harder to create one, and likely killed a measure that would have piloted public financing of elections.
asserted
that → lose → elections
In Colorado, a deep blue electorate voted to ban gender surgeries on minors by 4 points and to bar trans athletes’ participation in female sports by 5 points.
asserted
electorate → vote → points
A similar sports proposal prevailed by 12 points in Washington, even as Democrats padded their state legislative majorities.
asserted
Democrats → prevail → majorities
And in Iowa, where Gov.-elect Rob Sand led a Democratic comeback, voters endorsed a two-thirds legislative supermajority for any income tax increase.
asserted
voters → lead → increase
The success of some conservative ideas down the ballot — largely focused on taxes and social issues — gave some hope to Republicans after a hopeless election night.
asserted
success → focus → night
Voters rejected their party, but took multiple opportunities to oppose tax increases and roll back progressive social policies.
asserted
Voters → reject → policies
Democrats were not taking that as advice to their party.
asserted
Democrats → take → party
Instead, they believe that opposition money and muddled messaging overwhelmed them, and they could win if they made another run at the ballot.
uncertain
they → believe → ballot
“The margin was narrow enough that if we do more education with voters, we could significantly narrow it and win this,” said Suzanne Jimenez, the chief of staff at the union SEIU-UHW and a proponent of the California wealth tax.
uncertain
proponent → do → tax
Saikat Chakrabarti, an unsuccessful House candidate who was a top contributor to the wealth tax campaign, agreed.
asserted
who → agree → campaign
“When you have nearly half a billion dollars against you, and they spend it to spread straight-up lies about an issue, it’s hard to win unless you can get your own message out,” Chakrabarti said.
asserted
Chakrabarti → have → message
“The campaign had a winning issue,” he said, “but failed to get its own message out.”
Different ways to lose
The Proposition 40 campaign was heavily outspent, with some of California’s wealthiest residents funding its opposition.
asserted
some → have → opposition
According to state campaign finance records, $152 million went into the “no” effort, compared to a bit more than $33 million for “yes.”
uncertain
million → accord → yes
Spending for and against Proposition 42, which bars new wealth taxes, was similarly lopsided —nearly $128 million for, and nearly $35 million against.
asserted
which → spend → taxes
Some of the funding to kill the wealth tax also came from members of the Democratic Party’s coalition, like Planned Parenthood, which advocated for a long-term funding source over the proposed one-time levy.
asserted
which → kill → levy
Outgoing Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom opposed it, as did Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra, giving voters permission to support their ticket while voting against an idea backed by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt.
asserted
Becerra → oppose → Sanders
“Since it failed, I look forward to Gov. Newsom leading the fight by championing a national wealth tax, which he claimed he heavily supports,” said Chakrabati.
asserted
Chakrabati → fail → tax
Supporters of Washington’s ban on transgender girls playing in girls sports out-spent opponents by a 3-1 margin.
asserted
Supporters → play → margin
One of the coalition’s other priorities, which would have required schools to notify parents if their children identified as a different gender at school than at home, failed by 5 points.
asserted
children → require → points
In Colorado, where transgender sports and medicine bans for minors passed narrowly, the “yes” side was heavily outspent by its opponents, the Families Not Politics coalition.
asserted
side → pass → opponents
“It’s unfortunate that this is an issue that’s been politicized,” said Erin Lee, the Democrat-turned-Independent whose Protect Kids Colorado coalition got the measures on the ballot.
asserted
coalition → ’ → ballot
“Democrats have chosen this as a hill to die on, and Republicans have grabbed this as a political tool to wield.
asserted
Republicans → choose → tool
But when we started putting the team together, it became clear that this issue transcends the parties.”
asserted
issue → start → parties
The Democratic Party in both blue states opposed the measures.
asserted
Party → oppose → measures
Shasti Conrad, the chair of the Washington state Democratic Party, said that the sports measure “was very confusingly written,” while Republicans brought out their base to support it.
asserted
Republicans → say → it
Sources who worked to beat the measure told Semafor that their campaign was beset by bad planning and bad luck.
asserted
campaign → work → planning
The Gender Justice League, an LGBTQ+ rights group that was working against the measure, claimed to have “lost 80% of our foundation support and 35% of our government funding” as the Trump administration enforced its executive order on gender.
asserted
administration → work → gender
The “no” campaign also resisted help from Third Way, the centrist Democratic think tank not beloved by progressives.
asserted
campaign → resist → progressives
Lanae Erickson, a Third Way vice president, shared research with campaigners in every state where a sports ban could appear on the ballot.
uncertain
ban → share → ballot
“We found that most persuasive messages were around the gender checks component of the measure,” said Erickson, referring to language in the Washington initiative that required female athletes to prove their biological sex .
asserted
that → find → sex
Colorado campaigners used Third Way’s research; Washington campaigners opted not to until the campaign’s final weeks, when they ran some digital ads based on the information.
asserted
they → use → information
Democrats in both states believed that their eventual messaging was not effective enough.
asserted
messaging → believe → states
“We had an extremely long ballot, and I think it was confusing to folks,” said Rep. Jason Crow, D-Colo.
asserted
Crow → have → folks
“I think a lot of people didn’t know exactly what those provisions stood for.
asserted
provisions → think → what
We have to make sure we’re protecting folks, and that we’re doing so clearly and specifically.”
asserted
we → have → folks
In no state where conservatives passed their preferred tax or social issue measures did Democrats say that their party’s position might change.
uncertain
position → pass → measures
Erickson, pointing to the margins in both Washington and Colorado, said that Third Way had been trying to find a winning path for trans rights for years, and that the results showed progress.
asserted
results → point → progress
“Funders kept telling us it’s an 80-20 issue, so they didn’t help us,” she said, referring to polling on trans participation in girls sports.
asserted
she → tell → sports
“It’s not an 80-20 issue.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
…and 14 more, not listed.