Trump, Putin and Xi meet in an unprecedented summit with few tangible gains
asserted
Trump → meet → gains
-
- Trump told reporters he had a ‘special responsibility’ to maintain dialogue with adversarial world powers.
-
asserted
he → tell → powers
If any substantive understandings were reached behind closed doors, they weren’t released to the public.
asserted
they → reach → public
Donald Trump met Thursday with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin at a villa in southern China, an unprecedented gathering of a U.S. president with Washington’s chief geopolitical rivals bent on undermining American power.
asserted
rivals → meet → power
The meeting, conceived not by policymakers but by Trump and Putin themselves, had a fractured agenda, with each leader coming to the table with divergent interests and different stakes.
asserted
leader → conceive → interests
As they dispersed to their capitals, the presidents had few tangible gains to show for a summit hastily assembled in a matter of weeks, bypassing the months of groundwork that typically underpin diplomatic breakthroughs.
But the image of Trump standing alongside Putin and Xi — then sitting alone with the two of them, at a great round table in a cacophonous hall — was itself the culmination of a decade of his foreign policy thinking, a great-man theory of diplomacy that has broken with American tradition, elevating authoritarian leaders over democratic allies.
The U.S. president appeared subdued, thanking Xi and Putin before turning to the press.
asserted
president → disperse → press
“No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement and speech,” he said, arguing he had a “special responsibility” to maintain dialogue with adversarial world powers.
asserted
he → forge → powers
“We are really making history.”
asserted
We → make → history
Unlike at Yalta, in 1945, when President Franklin D. Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet Premier Josef Stalin famously gathered to shape the postwar order, the American leader was not at the center of these photographs.
asserted
leader → gather → photographs
That place of honor belonged to Xi, the host, who presided over the gathering at a remote retreat outside the city.
asserted
who → belong → city
It was a portrait of a nation asserting its place among the world’s superpowers — the very image Beijing had sought in agreeing to host the extraordinary gathering.
asserted
Beijing → assert → gathering
“History tells us that when great powers are at peace, the world is secure,” Xi said.
asserted
Xi → tell → peace
“When great powers clash, the world is in chaos.”
asserted
world → clash → chaos
The competing agendas could make the summit little more than a spectacle, yet still produce images that harken back to the famous Yalta conference of 1945.
But if any substantive understandings were reached behind closed doors, none of them were released to the public.
The summit’s pageantry fit a familiar pattern for Trump, who has repeatedly staged headline-grabbing encounters with controversial leaders only to walk away empty-handed.
uncertain
who → compete → leaders
Three high-stakes meetings with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un during his first term failed to meaningfully shift relations between Washington and Pyongyang, and a meeting with Putin in Anchorage last year likewise failed to generate progress toward ending Russia’s war in Ukraine.
asserted
meeting → fail → Ukraine
This time, the spectacular gathering lasted just an hour and a half, and produced only a readout of four points of agreement, broadly committing to work to uphold international security, minimize nuclear risks, increase petroleum output and, most specifically, overhaul the United Nations and the International Criminal Court, which it said “must not abuse their jurisdiction.”
asserted
it → last → jurisdiction
The court has a warrant outstanding for Putin’s arrest.
asserted
court → have → arrest
A ‘giant gift’ for Putin
Putin framed the trilateral meeting as one of equals, elevating a Russian Federation that has been economically and militarily devastated, and ostracized from the international community, over its war against Ukraine.
asserted
that → frame → Ukraine
Russian state media highlighted Xi’s decision to place Putin to his right throughout the summit as a gesture of honor.
asserted
media → highlight → honor
“I am convinced that Russia, China and the United States, our peoples, are capable of making a significant contribution to strengthening security and stability in the world,” Putin said, “if they cooperate constructively as partners on the basis of mutual respect, equality and a balance of interests.
asserted
they → make → interests
The Russian leader appeared almost giddy throughout the day’s meetings, and upon departing Shenzhen for the airport, escorted personally by Xi to his car, was heard saying, “I don’t think anyone ever expected everything to go so well.”
asserted
everything → appear → car
It put him on a stage where he does not belong,” Michael McFaul, a former U.S. ambassador to Russia now at the Hoover Institution at Stanford, told The Times.
asserted
McFaul → put → Times
“The photo of that meeting will be seen throughout the world, making it look like Putin is a respected leader of a great power.
asserted
Putin → see → power
What did Americans get in return?
asserted
Americans → get → return
The unusual summit comes just weeks after Trump suffered a generational rebuke in the midterm elections and as he remains bogged down in a war with Iran, which threatened to erupt in a new round of hostilities in the coming days.
asserted
which → come → days
Publicly, Trump framed the gathering as an effort to curb nuclear proliferation.
asserted
Trump → frame → proliferation
Yet instead of advancing a trilateral nonproliferation agreement among the world’s three largest nuclear powers, Putin offered a message of defiance, sending nuclear-capable bombers to nearby Vietnam a day before the summit in a rare deployment.
asserted
Putin → advance → deployment
China, meanwhile, rebuffed calls to slow down its breakneck nuclear buildup currently dwarfed by America’s arsenal.
asserted
China → rebuff → arsenal
The Trump administration let the last remaining U.S. arms control agreement with Russia expire earlier this year.
asserted
agreement → let → Russia
“Despite the talk of denuclearization by the Trump administration, no staff members prepped the president to meaningfully discuss this topic with Putin or Xi, who are unwilling partners for restraints and guardrails,” said Jennifer Hong, senior director of the Institute for Indo-Pacific Security.
asserted
Hong → preppe → Security
Instead, Trump’s focus seems to have turned to ensuring nonproliferation not among world powers, but in the Middle East — the main justification he has given for launching war against Tehran earlier this year.
asserted
he → seem → Tehran
“We’re not going to let Iran have a nuclear weapon,” he said at the top of the meeting.
asserted
he → go → meeting
Putin had hoped the summit would secure space and time to continue executing his war against Ukraine — a prospect that Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelensky, took seriously as the meeting was about to begin.
asserted
meeting → hop → that
“Big countries always think that they can make decisions about the future of all the world,” Zelensky told NBC News.
asserted
Zelensky → think → News
“It’s a huge mistake.”
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Sitting alongside Xi, Trump said the two of them were looking to “help with respect to the war with Russia and Ukraine” and “would like to see it ended.”
asserted
it → sit → Russia
Few independent analysts believe Putin is interested in ending the war in its current state.
asserted
Putin → believe → state
But at the trilateral engagement, Trump suggested Zelensky was responsible for Moscow’s continued attempts at conquest.
uncertain
Zelensky → suggest → conquest
“Things are happening,” Trump said.
asserted
Trump → happen → ?
“I think that he, and I hope the other side, would like to see an end to that war.”
asserted
side → think → war
…and 32 more, not listed.