In Shenzhen, Trump treats deference to adversaries as peace
asserted
Trump → treat → peace
-
- The president could have accomplished more, experts said, had he come with a team prepared.
-
uncertain
he → accomplish → team
A discussion among the three leaders that resulted in a denunciation of nuclear war could be a mark of progress.
uncertain
that → result → progress
In August of last year, President Trump hosted Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska for a summit labeled at the time as a historic event.
asserted
Trump → host → event
This would mark the beginning of the end of the war in Ukraine, Trump vowed, the deadliest conflict of our time.
asserted
Trump → mark → time
But as Trump greeted Putin with an outstretched hand this week in Shenzhen, over a year later, Moscow’s assault on Ukraine had only intensified.
asserted
assault → greet → Ukraine
Russian ballistic missile attacks have surged sharply since the Anchorage summit, by over 60%, increasingly targeting civilians in urban areas, according to independent analysts.
uncertain
attacks → surge → analysts
In a similarly choreographed gathering in Beijing earlier this year, Trump huddled with Chinese President Xi Jinping, repeatedly calling him a friend and pledging to work through their most contentious differences.
asserted
Trump → choreograph → differences
Yet behind the scenes, Beijing was orchestrating an elaborate effort to circumvent U.S. export controls, acquiring more than 1.5 million American chips through back channels to fuel its ambitions to beat the United States for artificial intelligence supremacy.
asserted
Beijing → orchestrate → supremacy
China’s covert effort came to a head days before the summit, when an alleged espionage campaign by Beijing targeting America’s largest chip maker erupted into public scandal.
asserted
campaign → come → scandal
Trump’s meeting with Washington’s chief geopolitical rivals was the culmination of a decade of his foreign policy thinking, elevating authoritarian leaders over democratic allies.
asserted
meeting → elevate → allies
A hastily arranged gathering with all three men, held here Thursday in southern China, produced iconic images of cooperation and peace.
asserted
gathering → arrange → cooperation
But the meeting ultimately continued Trump’s practice of summitry without substance, deferring to powerful adversaries over vital American interests, placating historic rivals to the consternation of longstanding allies.
asserted
meeting → continue → allies
“The meeting was a terrible signal to real U.S. friends around the world, but there was no lasting substantive outcome to the meeting,” John Bolton, who served as national security advisor to Trump in his first term, told The Times.
asserted
who → be → Times
“I suspect that the bilateral meetings Trump had with Xi and Putin respectively might have had more substance, but details on those meetings are still too sketchy to evaluate.”
uncertain
details → suspect → meetings
Rather than promoting peace, the summit served to generate further angst and distrust across Asia and Europe, with several leaders publicly recoiling at Trump’s overtures of affection.
asserted
leaders → promote → affection
“God, protect us from such friends,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said, reacting to Trump’s embrace of Putin.
asserted
Tusk → protect → Putin
“It was an interesting moment for the president to hold a trilateral with America’s two strategic rivals,” said Kyle Balzer, a national security fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
asserted
Balzer → hold → Institute
“Given the nature of Chinese and Russian behavior in their respective neighborhoods, a trilateral summit focused on strategic stability sends a confusing message to allies, who don’t see much ‘stability’ coming from Putin and Xi.
asserted
stability → give → Putin
Still, despite his professed friendship with Putin and Xi, Trump stopped short of explicitly abandoning U.S. support for Ukraine, Taiwan, and other regional partners considered by China and Russia to be within their spheres of influence.
asserted
Trump → profess → influence
A discussion among the three leaders that resulted in a denunciation of nuclear war may sound obvious, but could be a mark of progress, experts said, after Putin has repeatedly kept open the door to using tactical nuclear weapons on the Ukrainian battlefield.
uncertain
Putin → result → battlefield
“The one positive thing I can identify from the meeting is the reiteration of the position that ‘a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought,’” said Brian Taylor, a professor of public policy at Syracuse University.
asserted
Taylor → identify → University
“It’s good that they are at least willing to sign on to this condemnation of nuclear weapons use.
asserted
they → ’ → use
Trump’s focus on non-proliferation in the end seemed to be not on the world’s three largest nuclear arsenals, but on Iran’s potential pursuit of the bomb, the primary justification he has given for starting a war with Tehran earlier this year.
asserted
he → seem → Tehran
Support from Russia and China was essential in securing an international agreement with Iran in 2015 governing its nuclear program.
asserted
Support → secure → program
In the past, he has dismissed the untoward behavior of U.S. adversaries as the type of activity that the United States, too, engages in with its foes.
asserted
States → dismiss → foes
“They’re talking about the spying,” Trump said of the Chinese during a visit to Beijing, in the spring, before the spy scandal erupted around chip maker Nvidia.
asserted
scandal → talk → Nvidia
“Well, we do it too.
asserted
we → do → it
We spy like hell on them too.”
asserted
We → spy → them
President Vladimir Putin, meanwhile, vowed to retaliate against Ukraine for the “serious damage” it caused with three aerial attacks this week on the vital Kerch Bridge, which links occupied Crimea with the Russian mainland.
asserted
which → vow → mainland
Famously asked about Putin’s targeted assassinations, Trump replied in a Fox News interview in 2017: “There are a lot of killers.
asserted
Trump → ask → killers
We’ve got a lot of killers.
asserted
We → get → killers
What, do you think our country’s so innocent?”
asserted
country → think → ?
Trump has said he finds it unproductive to “insult” powerful leaders with confrontations around such activities.
asserted
it → say → activities
But he has continued to support counterintelligence operations against both Moscow and Beijing, maintaining a flow of signals support to Kyiv despite consistent tensions with its government, and refusing to give Xi clarity on whether he would come to the defense of Taiwan if China attacked.
asserted
China → continue → Taiwan
The president could have accomplished more, experts said, had he come with a team prepared.
uncertain
he → accomplish → team
“Unlike Yalta, which some folks see as a sort of precedent, this is not a victory lap for geopolitical winners,” said Chester Crocker, who served as an assistant secretary of State in the Reagan administration, referring to a famous trilateral conference at the end of World War II between President Franklin Delano Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet Premier Josef Stalin.
asserted
who → see → Roosevelt
“Shenzhen could have been a seminal moment if the three had scripted a well-prepared agenda focused on strategic nuclear issues, and if the U.S. had reflected on its responsibilities as the leader of the world’s most politically and economically successful country,” Crocker added.
uncertain
Crocker → script → country
“It could be an important moment if they agree to meet again.”
uncertain
they → agree → ?