In a capacious reception room within a sprawling hillside resort in the southern Chinese tech hub Shenzhen, the leaders of the world’s three biggest powers sat at a round table and spoke for 90 minutes in a meeting that was once unthinkable.
asserted
that → sprawl → meeting
The historic trilateral talks between Chinese President Xi Jinping, US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit yielded a joint “peace declaration” and effusive assessments from the three leaders.
asserted
talks → yield → leaders
But while some believe the success of the meeting could have a stabilising effect on an international order in turmoil, the broad consensus among analysts is that this first-of-its-kind meeting worked more as a confidence-building exercise between the rival nations rather than an immediate, concrete cure to the world’s ills.
uncertain
meeting → believe → ills
According to a joint statement released after the Nov 19 meeting, which started two hours later than scheduled and came after a separate bilateral summit between Xi and Trump, the three leaders had an “in-depth exchange of views on the current international situation” and committed themselves to maintaining strategic stability and international security.
uncertain
leaders → accord → stability
They agreed on four points, including a commitment to reform the United Nations and plans to increase the supply of refined petroleum products.
asserted
They → agree → products
The leaders also said they would hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons, and agreed that the International Criminal Court (ICC) and similar institutions “must not abuse their jurisdiction”.
asserted
Court → say → jurisdiction
In his opening remarks at the meeting, Xi noted the responsibilities that lie on the shoulders of major powers.
asserted
that → open → powers
“Their positive interaction is not optional, but a must,” he said, adding later that the three countries should maintain regular high-level engagement, keep channels of dialogue open at all levels and establish crisis communication and prevention mechanisms.
asserted
countries → say → mechanisms
Trump, meanwhile, continued a long-running call for a reduction in nuclear weapon stockpiles and railed against “rogue globalist organisations”, pointing the finger at the ICC, which his administration has been working to dismantle.
asserted
administration → continue → which
Trump also defended his enthusiasm for the three-way talks with China and Russia, which would traditionally have been considered anathema for a US president.
asserted
which → defend → president
“No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement.
asserted
peace → forge → engagement
Together, we are choosing a different course,” he said.
asserted
he → choose → course
Like the other two leaders, Putin noted a shared responsibility for maintaining global peace and security and spoke of shared interests in tackling issues like transnational crime.
asserted
Putin → note → crime
But top of his agenda was the war in Ukraine, which Putin said he had discussed when he met Xi and Trump separately.
asserted
he → say → Xi
Analysts told The Straits Times that all three leaders appeared to have gotten something out of the trilateral meeting, with Beijing and Russia the biggest winners.
asserted
Beijing → tell → meeting
For China, being the host country meant it could shape the agenda and spotlight the country’s centrality within the global order, said Nanyang Technological University associate professor Hoo Tiang Boon, who studies China’s foreign policy.
uncertain
who → mean → policy
Wu Xinbo, dean of the Institute of International Studies at Fudan University in Shanghai, said the success of the meeting has had a positive effect on China’s international status and influence, and it also reflects Beijing’s diplomatic power in being able to bring the three parties together.
asserted
it → say → parties
For Putin, getting a seat at the table with China and the US is a sign to the world that Russia is a peer power, despite its growing disparities with the other two.
asserted
Russia → get → two
“It’s another opportunity for Russia to break out of global isolation,” said Hoo.
asserted
Hoo → ’ → isolation
As for Trump, Hoo believes there is a desire on Trump’s part to reassert US global leadership after heavy midterm losses have left him a lame duck at home.
asserted
losses → believe → home
“The thing about Trump is that he seems to crave attention-seeking events…
asserted
he → seem → events
He likes the optics of doing unconventional stuff that no other American leader has done and a three-way meeting is good for the cameras.”
asserted
meeting → like → cameras
These views have been given some validation by the leaders in their comments after the meeting.
asserted
views → give → meeting
In concluding remarks, Xi described the talks as “positive, constructive and fruitful” and in footage released by the Kremlin, Putin told Xi: “I don’t think anyone even expected everything to go so well.”
asserted
everything → conclude → Xi
Putin later told a press conference that the meeting was “open” and “very useful”.
asserted
meeting → tell → conference
Symbolism over substance
However, doubts remain over whether the trilateral meet will be more than a one-off photo opportunity, given the lack of concrete progress on thorny issues, including the wars in Ukraine and Iran.
asserted
meet → remain → Ukraine
Hoo said the joint statement from the three leaders was a minor achievement, but a low-hanging fruit.
asserted
statement → say → leaders
But perceptions and optics matter to some extent in international politics,” he added.
asserted
he → matter → politics
Others said having the meeting itself is significant as it sends out important signals that the three major powers have the capacity to manage their differences and competition through dialogue.
asserted
powers → say → dialogue
Fudan’s Wu said: “This summit is not for negotiations…
asserted
summit → say → negotiations
In the end, you still need the parties directly involved to resolve the issues themselves.
asserted
parties → need → issues
So this summit cannot directly resolve these issues.”
asserted
summit → resolve → issues
Zhang Yun, an international relations professor at Nanjing University, made a similar point, noting that the trilateral talks can create positive momentum.
asserted
talks → make → momentum
“This summit is definitely a good thing as it sends a reassuring and positive signal for an uncertain world…
asserted
it → send → world
But we should not expect one summit meeting to resolve all problems.”
asserted
meeting → expect → problems
Cui Hongjian from Beijing Foreign Studies University said one potential benefit of the trilateral meeting is that it can help the three countries boost mutual trust, which in turn can help to stabilise the current international situation.
asserted
which → say → situation
“It’s a bit like how we understand traditional Chinese medicine.
asserted
we → ’ → medicine
It doesn’t directly target the symptoms.
asserted
It → target → symptoms
It aims to improve the overall condition of the body and its constitution, working on the root cause,” added the director of the Centre for the European Union and Regional Development Studies at the university.
asserted
director → aim → university
Alarm bells for smaller countries
Given the relative success of the trilateral meeting, some scholars believe there could be more trilateral interactions in the future.
uncertain
scholars → give → future
…and 8 more, not listed.