Lawyers' Responsibility for Hallucinations in Briefs That They Sign

Read the original at Reason ↗
Cite

Volokh, E. (2026, September 4). Lawyers' Responsibility for Hallucinations in Briefs That They Sign. Reason. https://reason.com/volokh/2026/09/04/lawyers-responsibility-for-hallucinations-in-briefs-that-they-sign/

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Reason · collected 2026-09-04 · by Eugene Volokh

Quick Summary

Judge Stephen Glickman agrees with a principle that lawyers who sign briefs are responsible for fake citations, but clarifies that this responsibility should not be understood to mean every lawyer must personally verify every citation. A recent opinion from the Ninth Circuit states that competent attorneys cannot decline to "vet" citations in signed briefs, but Judge Glickman argues that this does not necessarily apply to all signatories on a brief with multiple contributors. In some cases, fulfilling this duty can be a group effort and may not require individual lawyers to personally check every citation. The issue is relevant to the use of artificial intelligence-generated citations, which may lead to hallucinations or inaccuracies in legal documents.
Written by AI on 2026-09-05, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).

AI analysis

Story summary

In Douglas v. Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co, decided by the D.C. Court of Appeals on June 22, the court discovered that the bank's brief contained multiple citations to cases that could not be located or confirmed as legitimate. The court issued an order requiring the bank to explain why its brief should not be stricken for citing non-existent cases that might have been generated by artificial intelligence (AI) hallucinations. On June 23, Loishirl W. Hall, one of the attorneys at the firm representing Deutsche Bank, acknowledged in a response that four citations were "not legitimate legal authority" and pledged to verify the remaining citations. She assured the court that she would not rely on AI for future briefs without independently verifying each citation's legitimacy, emphasizing that her firm prohibits using AI in drafting any legal documents and has strict policies against submitting inaccurate citations.

Written for “AI Hallucinations in Legal Briefs” on 2026-11-20, grounded in this article and the 1 other(s) covering the same event.

Compared with similar articles

This article reads leans right and hedges 22% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.

Story

AI Hallucinations in Legal Briefs
Technology · 2 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
32
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
22%
7 of 32 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
67/100
Reason's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Technology
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-05 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Reason · 1437 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 4 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Eugene Volokh
218 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Under Maryland law, an individual may not carry a firearm in public demonstrations, mass transit, places of amusement, healthcare facilities, locations that sell alcohol for onsite consumption, and tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land.
I would have granted certiorari to clarify the government-speech doctrine.
"In the limited circumstance where a business requires nudity as a central purpose of the business," the addition reads, "such business may maintain a rule that entry to spaces where nudity is required be based on genital characteristics."
"In the limited circumstance where a business requires nudity as a central purpose of the business," the addition reads, "such business may maintain a rule that entry to spaces where nudity is required be based on genital characteristics."
As the Church grew, Gioia began to look for a new space that could accommodate a larger group.
From Judge W. Scott Hardy in Doe v. Blank Rome LLP, the opinion was issued under seal in May, but just unsealed last week (at my behest): Plaintiff is an attorney who filed a detailed, 197-paragraph Complaint under the pseudonym "Jane Doe" against Defendant Blank Rome LLP …, her former employer, alleging claims for sex discrimination, hostile work environment, and retaliation pursuant to Title VII ….
{The Government was clear that any search of the contents of the phone would utilize a taint team to protect privileged information.}
Like it would not have had the legs it had if he hadn't posted about it.
From the Stanford site; "degradation" indeed: Degradation (started 9:53 AM Nov 12, 2026) Vendor is reporting a service issue that may prevent users from accessing their Office 365 E-mail via Outlook and/or webmail.
2026-11-12 · speculative framing · Living Today Without Email—Like Animals!
Some of these performance issues may have been due to the lack of oversight and direction supplied by [Marketing Manager] Cattelan, but Cattelan was not Plaintiff's supervisor.
Also by Eugene Volokh
Open Thread
2026-11-18 · Reason
Open Thread
2026-11-17 · Reason
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 218 articles by Eugene Volokh →

Topics

D.C. Court of Appeals Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co. Rule 11 the Ninth Circuit the Ninth Circuit's

Subjects

Bumatay PERSON · 1× D.C. Court of Appeals ORG · 1× Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co. ORG · 1× Douglas PERSON · 1× Gates PERSON · 1× Lake PERSON · 1× Stephen Glickman PERSON · 1× the Ninth Circuit ORG · 1× the Ninth Circuit's ORG · 1× the United States Attorney's Office ORG · 1×

Narrative

{See Lake v. Gates, 130 F.4th 1054, 1062 (9th Cir. 2025) (Bumatay, J., concurring in the judgment only) (Disagreeing with the majority's conclusion that federal Rule 11 allowed the trial court to sanction an attorney who participated on a brief as "of counsel" and only contributed a discrete portion to the offending brief, because "[a]s a textual matter…, Rule 11 permits different levels of accountability for different attorneys in a case….
framing: mixed · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-05
Such a requirement would be impractical, unduly burdensome, and unnecessarily duplicative given the availability of reasonable alternative procedures to guard against erroneous citations.

Claims (32 extracted, 7 hedged)

An interesting perspective from D.C. Court of Appeals Judge Stephen Glickman concurring in Douglas v. Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co. (more on that case here): The panel opinion, which I join, states that "every attorney who signed the brief bears some responsibility" for inclusion of fake citations. asserted
who → concur → citations
I agree with that general principle, subject to a clarification as to what I think it must entail. asserted
it → agree → what
The opinion also quotes, with evident approval, the Ninth Circuit's declaration that "[a] competent and diligent attorney cannot decline to 'vet' citations, in a brief he signs, for substantive validity—in other words, to read the cited authorities and ensure that they are on point." asserted
they → quote → point
In the appeal that the Ninth Circuit had before it, there was only one signatory on the brief in question. asserted
Circuit → have → question
If the quoted statement is understood to mean that every signatory on any brief with multiple signatories must personally check every citation in the brief for accuracy, I demur…. asserted
I → quote → accuracy
Appellate briefs commonly list the names of multiple attorneys for the party on whose behalf the briefs are submitted. asserted
briefs → list → party
Ordinarily, only one of those attorneys actually signs the brief. asserted
one → sign → brief
For present purposes, though, all the named attorneys are deemed to be "signatories" who stand behind and who (usually, but not always) contributed to the brief. asserted
who → name → brief
(It is not unreasonable for a brief to list the attorneys who represent the party in the appeal even if they did not personally contribute to the brief or were not its principal drafter(s).) asserted
they → list → brief
This does not mean, however, that all these "signatories" necessarily have exactly the same responsibilities for ensuring that the brief comports with ethical and other requirements. asserted
brief → mean → requirements
Fulfilling the duty to guard against AI-hallucinated (or otherwise invalid) citations can be a group effort that does not require every signatory to personally cite check every brief. asserted
that → fulfil → brief
Such a requirement would be impractical, unduly burdensome, and unnecessarily duplicative given the availability of reasonable alternative procedures to guard against erroneous citations. asserted
requirement → give → citations
{See Lake v. Gates, 130 F.4th 1054, 1062 (9th Cir. 2025) (Bumatay, J., concurring in the judgment only) (Disagreeing with the majority's conclusion that federal Rule 11 allowed the trial court to sanction an attorney who participated on a brief as "of counsel" and only contributed a discrete portion to the offending brief, because "[a]s a textual matter…, Rule 11 permits different levels of accountability for different attorneys in a case…. asserted
Rule → see → case
To encourage the participation of specialized attorneys and to improve the quality of advocacy in our courts, we should have adopted a rule that recognizes the circumscribed role that some attorneys with subject-matter expertise may play in litigation.").} uncertain
attorneys → encourage → litigation
. Suppose, for example, that a law firm assigns different sections of a complex brief to different associates for initial drafting. asserted
firm → suppose → drafting
Each associate is certainly responsible for the accuracy of the citations in his own assigned section; in general, this cite checking is a task that the principal drafter (or drafters) of a brief must perform. asserted
drafter → assign → brief
But that hardly means each associate must also be charged with double-checking a section assigned to and drafted by another associate. asserted
associate → mean → associate
Or consider the typical brief this court receives from the United States Attorney's Office in criminal appeals. asserted
court → consider → appeals
Every one of those many briefs lists not only the author (who is also the designated counsel for oral argument) but also the Assistant United States Attorneys who represented the government at trial (who may have been consulted by appellate counsel but who have nothing to do with the drafting of the legal arguments in the brief); the Chief of the Criminal Appellate Section (who oversees the production of a multitude of briefs and can hardly be expected to spend all her time checking all the citations in that multitude); and the United States Attorney herself (ditto). uncertain
who → list → multitude
It surely would be unrealistic, as well as unnecessary overkill, to require each of those attorneys to cite check any given brief. asserted
It → require → brief
Other, far more practical procedures can be followed to ensure that AI-generated hallucinations do not result in the inclusion of fake citations in briefs and other filings. asserted
hallucinations → follow → briefs
I suspect that the problem of fake citations (along with other AI-generated errors that I describe below) arises primarily when lawyers unwisely ask AI to draft a brief from scratch for them, a practice that supervisors can (and, I think, should) ban outright. asserted
I → suspect → that
(I will say more about this below. asserted
I → say → this
That said, law firms and law departments may institute supplemental measures to guard against AI-hallucinated citations and other AI-generated errors in their briefs. uncertain
firms → say → briefs
Such measures include training (and retraining) attorneys in the proper use of AI; adopting clear policies governing such use and providing for discipline when appropriate; and requiring attorneys to confirm that they have complied with those policies. asserted
they → include → policies
The likelihood that any fake citations will eventually come to light, and that the consequences for the offender will be drastic, should be made very clear. asserted
consequences → come → offender
In addition, to the extent it is desirable to double check the citations and case descriptions in all briefs before they are filed, such "vetting" may be done cost-effectively by a trained paralegal. uncertain
vetting → check → paralegal
{I should not be understood as suggesting that only a lawyer who did the actual drafting of a brief containing fake citations (or other AI-generated errors, see infra) may be subject to sanction. uncertain
who → understand → sanction
For example, if training and oversight have been neglected, I think supervisory lawyers may be accountable as well.} uncertain
lawyers → neglect → example
As the opinion itself suggests, other judges may disagree (see, e.g., this post), and lawyers certainly shouldn't feel comfortable that they'll get off the hook for hallucinations so long as they weren't the person drafting that part of the brief. uncertain
they → suggest → brief
And of course, regardless of whether there are any formal sanctions on the lawyer, such hallucinations risk losing the case for the client, risk damaging the firm's reputation, risk a malpractice lawsuit for the firm, are likely to undermine the client's relationship with all the lawyers at the firm, and more. asserted
hallucinations → be → firm
Still, the judge's point that it's not reasonable to expect every signing lawyer to personally check each citation seems sound to me. asserted
lawyer → expect → me
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support