Democrats took the House of Representatives and Senate Tuesday night in large part thanks to voter backlash against President Donald Trump's disastrous war of choice against Iran.
asserted
Democrats → take → Iran
When the House returns for the lame-duck session, one of the first items of business—whether outgoing Speaker Mike Johnson (R–La.) likes it or not—will be revisiting the articles of impeachment lodged against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth for "high crimes and misdemeanors" related to that war.
asserted
Johnson → return → war
Johnson rushed the House to early recess in mid-September to avoid a vote on Hegseth's impeachment.
asserted
Johnson → rush → impeachment
But the articles, drawn up by outgoing Rep. Thomas Massie (R–Ky.), are coming back when the House returns.
asserted
House → draw → Massie
The GOP gadfly recently announced he intends to force a vote on "week one."
asserted
he → announce → week
Massie's effort has a real shot even under lame duck math, before the new Democratic majority comes in.
asserted
majority → have → math
Passing it will require only a handful of GOP votes.
asserted
Passing → pass → votes
In September, seven Republicans split from their party to vote for withdrawal from Iran.
asserted
Republicans → split → Iran
After Tuesday's electoral shellacking, GOP members should be looking for clear opportunities to distance themselves from Trump's disastrous and unnecessary war.
asserted
members → look → war
Here's their chance to do that—and reinvigorate a valuable constitutional weapon at the same time.
asserted
chance → reinvigorate → time
Massie Wants To Impeach Hegseth for War Crimes and Misdemeanors
Four of the eight articles in Massie's bill of particulars center on Iran, including trampling "Congress' exclusive constitutional authority to declare war;" ignoring congressional strictures designed to protect innocent civilians; and multiple violations of the 1973 War Powers Resolution, such as going past its time limits and blowing off a vote by a majority of both houses directing the removal of U.S. forces from hostilities against Iran.
asserted
of → want → Iran
Others involve war crimes closer to home.
asserted
Others → involve → home
Massie's fifth article charges Hegseth with ordering "extrajudicial killings" in counternarcotics operations off the coast of Venezuela, through which Hegseth "asserted a unilateral power to determine who may live and who may die."
uncertain
who → charge → power
Last month, public distaste over Hegseth's plan to livestream the public execution of the Fort Hood shooter, Nidal Hasan, prompted Trump to call a halt to the spectacle.
asserted
distaste → livestream → spectacle
Grotesque as the plan was, it was hardly novel: Hegseth had already made state-sponsored killing something of a spectator sport by proudly tweeting out footage of U.S. missile strikes on suspected drug traffickers in the Caribbean.
asserted
killing → make → Caribbean
Hasan at least got a trial.
asserted
Hasan → get → trial
In 1797, the House impeached Tennessee Sen. William Blount for conspiring to raise a private army for "a military hostile expedition" against Spanish-held Louisiana and Florida "against the laws of the United States."
asserted
House → impeach → States
Our Constitution's Framers thought presidential ministers were fair targets for the ultimate remedy.
asserted
ministers → think → remedy
As James Madison explained in the first Congress: "If an unworthy man be continued in office by an unworthy president, the House of Representatives can at any time impeach him.
asserted
House → explain → him
Yet Cabinet-level impeachments never took off in the United States.
asserted
impeachments → take → States
In our entire constitutional history, we've managed the feat only twice.
asserted
we → manage → feat
Most recently, President Joe Biden's Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas was narrowly impeached by a GOP House, and the charges were dismissed by a Democrat-led Senate.
asserted
charges → impeach → Senate
The other, a century and a half ago, was Gilded Age War Secretary William Belknap, impeached due to kickbacks in connection with a military trading post.
asserted
other → impeach → post
The House charged Belknap with "basely prostituting his high office to his lust for private gain."
asserted
House → charge → gain
(Apparently, a lot of that's still going around.)
asserted
lot → go → that
The Senate acquitted him, in part because he'd already resigned.
asserted
he → acquit → part
'You're Fired'?
asserted
You → fire → ?
Why have so few department heads been impeached?
asserted
heads → impeach → ?
"The issue has almost invariably proven moot," the legal scholar Frank Bowman explains in his 2019 book, High Crimes and Misdemeanors: A History of Impeachment for the Age of Trump.
asserted
scholar → prove → Trump
Whenever a Cabinet chief becomes "politically toxic" enough to court impeachment, the president typically shoves him off the stage.
asserted
president → become → stage
Trump could certainly follow that playbook here.
uncertain
Trump → follow → playbook
Hegseth got his job as Pentagon chief in part because the president liked his look—a buff veteran straight out of "central casting," he's said repeatedly—but lately, with the former Fox & Friends host under heavy fire on Capitol Hill, the bloom is off the rose.
asserted
bloom → get → rose
This year alone, Trump sacked two department heads, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem and Attorney General Pam Bondi, who caused him political grief.
asserted
who → sack → grief
Or maybe he'll dig in his heels and fight.
asserted
he → dig → heels
After beating two impeachments, will Trump want to look like he's been cowed by a third effort, aimed at a subordinate?
asserted
he → beat → subordinate
With a president this mercurial, who can tell?
asserted
who → tell → president
Either way, the goal shouldn't be simply getting Hegseth's scalp.
asserted
goal → get → scalp
At its most effective, formal indictment by the House—even without removal by the Senate—has served as a form of constitutional censure.
asserted
indictment → serve → censure
Amid a deeply unpopular war, putting Hegseth in the dock—livestreamed—could leave a lasting mark.
uncertain
putting → put → mark
The Aporia
