A JUDGMENT is a public document, written in the name of the Constitution and delivered in open court.
asserted
JUDGMENT → write → court
The people may read it, praise it and criticise it, and the academy, bar, press and civil society should do so freely.
uncertain
academy → read → it
A judiciary whose judgments are never read critically will never grow.
asserted
judgments → read → ?
One voice is largely missing from that conversation: the judge who wrote the judgment.
asserted
who → miss → judgment
In Pakistan, judges mostly retire into silence.
asserted
judges → retire → silence
That must change.
asserted
That → change → ?
Retired judges must come out among the people, above all into the law schools, and explain their reasoning, or say, with hindsight: “I think I got that one wrong.”
asserted
one → retire → hindsight
Such candour teaches the profession and builds public trust and confidence in the institution.
asserted
candour → teach → institution
A sitting judge who knows retirement means facing the public will brush nothing under the carpet.
asserted
retirement → sit → carpet
A judgment open to criticism falls into one of three kinds.
asserted
judgment → fall → kinds
The first plainly violates the Constitution and the law.
asserted
first → violate → Constitution
The second was legally permissible when given, but its consequences proved damaging.
asserted
consequences → give → ?
The third is the judgment in which the judge was complicit, bending the law to reach an outcome decided elsewhere.
asserted
judge → bend → outcome
To assess one, read it whole and in context: the moment, the circumstances, the law as it then stood.
asserted
it → assess → moment
Then ask whether it was permissible, plainly wrong, or the judge simply listening to power.
asserted
judge → ask → power
Let me test three of my own.
asserted
me → let → own
In Pakistan, judges mostly retire into silence.
asserted
judges → retire → silence
That must change.
asserted
That → change → ?
In the 2023 case on Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa elections, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail and I wanted the high courts to decide first: Lahore had already ordered elections, with appeals pending, and Peshawar was seized of the petitions.
asserted
Peshawar → want → petitions
Law and practice both counselled that restraint.
asserted
Law → counsel → restraint
We read the outcome as four to three, because two colleagues who had already voted to dismiss could not, in our view, be dropped from the count; Justice Athar Minallah, one of them, recorded as much.
uncertain
Minallah → read → much
In hindsight, the mistake, I believe, was the chief justice’s hurried leap in; hearing the matter in appeal, the court could have spoken with one voice.
uncertain
court → believe → voice
Had we set the count aside and presented a united court, whether that would have produced elections is anyone’s guess.
asserted
produced → set → elections
Later, the chief justice’s own bench rejected the four-three objection and fixed May 14 for Punjab polls, yet could not enforce it.
uncertain
bench → reject → it
The date passed, contempt was never pursued, and the court fell silent.
asserted
court → pass → ?
The larger lesson is that a court must stand united, and the chief justice’s strength is the real spine that holds it together.
asserted
it → stand → ?
The Supreme Court as it stands today shows how much rests on that spine.
asserted
much → stand → spine
In the Justice Qazi Faez Isa case, the court unanimously quashed the reference, the majority for malice in law; I held it malicious in fact as well.
asserted
it → quash → fact
The majority directed the FBR to examine the family’s properties and report to the council; three of us held that no direction was needed, the FBR being free to act under the tax law.
asserted
FBR → direct → law
On review, that view prevailed.
asserted
view → prevail → review
No one is above the law, and no one below its protection: a judge’s spouse answers under the tax law, a judge under the Code of Conduct, only in accordance with law.
asserted
spouse → answer → law
I am often asked whether we saved the wrong man.
asserted
we → ask → man
We saved due process and the independence of the judiciary, and in doing so we saved a man.
asserted
we → save → man
What people thought of him later was not our concern then.
asserted
thought → think → him
In the Practice and Procedure case, I believed, and still believe, that the court had to become collegial rather than be run by one man.
asserted
court → believe → man
Opening the door was not itself the mistake; so long as the court stood united, no one could have walked through it.
uncertain
one → open → it
What we failed to see was that the court was weak within, and weakness inside invites those outside.
asserted
weakness → fail → outside
And it did: a 2024 ordinance gave the chief justice’s nominee a seat on the bench-forming committee.
asserted
ordinance → do → committee
Had earlier chief justices brought in the collegial model through the full court, that door need never have opened from outside.
asserted
door → bring → court
Each choice was made in good faith, within the law.
asserted
choice → make → law
…and 17 more, not listed.