In the 1976 Hollywood classic Taxi Driver, Robert De Niro stars as a disturbed military veteran who works gruelling shifts as a cab driver through the decaying, sleazy backdrop of New York City.
asserted
who → star → City
Plagued by chronic insomnia and living alone in a cramped apartment, he spends his nights ferrying passengers who seem to mirror the city’s moral collapse.
asserted
who → plague → collapse
He is a man of few words, and the film gradually lays bare his fragile state of mind through his internal monologues.
asserted
film → lay → monologues
In these voiceovers, he rails against the social ‘filth’ he encounters on the streets, culminating in a lament: ”All the animals come out at night… whores, buggers, queens, fairies, dopers, junkies, sick, venal.
asserted
animals → rail → night
Someday a real rain will come and wash all this scum off the streets.”
asserted
rain → come → streets
The lament can be interpreted as a fascist fantasy.
asserted
lament → interpret → fantasy
Early in the film, the cabdriver attempts to court a campaign worker for a liberal presidential candidate, only to alienate her completely by taking her on a date to a pornographic cinema.
asserted
cabdriver → attempt → cinema
Seemingly unable to comprehend why she is offended, he moves his obsession toward assassinating the candidate.
asserted
he → comprehend → candidate
The attempt fails.
asserted
attempt → fail → ?
His focus then shifts to a young teenage sex worker.
asserted
focus → shift → worker
When he urges her to leave the trade, she asserts that she is entirely free to make her own choices.
asserted
she → urge → choices
Undeterred, he returns later with lethal intent, launching a brutal armed assault that leaves her pimp and his associates dead.
asserted
that → return → pimp
By the following morning, the media has reframed his violent spree as an act of ‘heroism’.
asserted
media → reframe → heroism
In the chilling final scene, he is approached once more by the same woman who was once repulsed and offended by him, only this time she greets him with a smile.
asserted
she → approach → smile
From Hollywood’s murderous anti-heroes to extrajudicial killings in Pakistan, ideological convictions and public frustration can make violence seem like an acceptable instrument of justice for both the left and right
So, a disturbed man harbouring ‘fascist’ fantasies, who originally plotted to assassinate a politician, shifted his violent impulses.
asserted
who → make → impulses
Eager to project his own idea of morality, he attempted to ‘rescue’ a young sex worker who had explicitly chosen her own path.
asserted
who → project → path
Shoot her pimp and associates to death, thereby transforming himself into a ‘saviour’ and a ‘hero’, finally becoming the ‘rain’ he dreamed would wash the ‘scum’ off the streets.
asserted
he → shoot → streets
Director Martin Scorsese leaves the final moral judgment to the audience, framing an unsettling question: did the viewers feel a sense of satisfaction or outrage?
asserted
viewers → leave → satisfaction
How could a man evolve from a failed assassin into a murderous vigilante, only to be embraced as a media darling and societal hero?
uncertain
man → evolve → darling
Nevertheless, one can suggest that the film is clearly conscious of the answer.
asserted
film → suggest → answer
Most viewers would justify the cabby’s actions.
asserted
viewers → justify → actions
In troubled societies, where law and order is crumbling and whose moral compass seems to be going haywire, paranoia, anxiety and anger breed a dangerous appetite for vigilante action.
asserted
paranoia → crumble → action
When institutions fail and public safety feels like an illusion, audiences are dangerously primed to root for a violent reckoning.
asserted
audiences → fail → reckoning
Therefore, an unstable, murderous anti-hero is perversely embraced because he steps in to do what an impotent system fails to do.
asserted
system → embrace → what
So, what do you think is the actual reaction of most people when they read or hear about the extrajudicial killings of individuals accused of hideous crimes in Pakistan?
asserted
they → think → Pakistan
Of course, ‘liberals’ are outraged, and rightly so, recognising that such actions and reactions are symptoms of a society teetering on the edge of a cliff, on the verge of tumbling straight into the lap of fascism.
asserted
actions → recognise → fascism
But those who have been crushed by the debris of a crumbling order are not the only ones who end up conjuring fascist fantasies or begin hailing actions that gradually nudge polities down fascism’s throat.
asserted
that → crush → throat
The embrace of fascism can come from the left and the liberals as well, especially when public frustration with the ‘system’ runs deep.
asserted
frustration → come → system
A striking real-world echo of this phenomenon unfolded following the December 2024 murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in Manhattan.
asserted
echo → unfold → Manhattan
When the shooter was arrested, social media, and parts of the public, erupted in an unexpected wave of outright sympathy for him.
asserted
media → arrest → him
Even individuals who would typically align with progressive or liberal values found themselves romanticising the murder of an ‘exploiter’.
asserted
themselves → align → exploiter
In January 2011, when the former Governor of Punjab, Salman Taseer, was gunned down by his police bodyguard for criticising Pakistan’s blasphemy laws, I was working at a European outlet operating in Karachi.
asserted
I → gun → Karachi
At the office, I was rattled to witness a number of ‘liberals’ (both lifestyle and political), openly hailing the assassination.
asserted
number → rattle → assassination
Some even went to extraordinary lengths to justify the murder, simply because they opposed Taseer’s political party.
asserted
they → go → party
Troubled societies frequently create curious left-right trajectories and demonstrations of confused morality.
asserted
societies → create → morality
These often converge on the same dangerous destination: a fascist order in the making, nourished by both the left and the right.
asserted
These → converge → left
In the 1995 film The Last Supper, five liberal graduate students accidentally kill a white racist and hatch a chilling plan: invite prominent right-wing figures to dinner, debate them and poison any guest who refuses to recant.
asserted
who → kill → guest
They proceed to execute a rotating cast of bigots and extremists, burying them in their garden.
asserted
They → proceed → garden
The plot twists when they host a famous right-wing television talking head.
asserted
they → twist → head
Expecting a radical zealot, they are disarmed by his calm and rational demeanour and his admission that he does not actually believe his own rhetoric, but merely performs it for ratings.
asserted
he → expect → ratings
…and 12 more, not listed.