A family dispute over a £1.1 million inheritance has ended with a UK judge upholding the will of a London mother who excluded her daughter and younger son from her estate, saying they had failed to show her enough “love and respect”.
asserted
they → end → love
According to a report by The Independent, Dervishe Halil, who died aged 94 in 2021, left her entire estate to her eldest son, Dogan Halil, in her final will, drawn up in 2018.
uncertain
who → accord → 2018
Her daughter, Aysel Gencay, challenged the document, alleging that her brother had manipulated their mother into changing her inheritance plans.
asserted
brother → challenge → plans
The court rejected her claims and ruled that the will was valid.
uncertain
will → reject → claims
Dervishe, who was originally from Cyprus, moved to London with her husband in 1952.
asserted
who → move → 1952
She had three children and, in earlier versions of her will, intended to divide her wealth among them.
asserted
She → have → them
However, relations within the family deteriorated following a dispute between Dogan and his younger sister Aysel.
asserted
relations → deteriorate → Dogan
The disagreement centred partly on a valuable family property in Packington Street, Islington, with Aysel accusing her brother of taking part of the property for his own benefit.
asserted
Aysel → centre → benefit
The family tensions eventually affected Dervishe's estate plans.
asserted
tensions → affect → plans
Between 2013 and 2018, she made four wills, changing how her assets would be distributed.
asserted
assets → make → wills
In 2015, she sent a handwritten letter to Aysel and her younger son, Attila, warning that they risked being excluded from her will unless they reconciled with Dogan and treated him and their mother with greater respect.
asserted
they → send → respect
In the letter, Dervishe criticised their behaviour towards their eldest brother, writing: “Your actions have destroyed my life and home, your actions towards your brother Dogan are very bad and shameful, we saw nothing but goodness from Dogan to all of us”.
asserted
we → criticise → us
Three years later, she acted on the warning.
asserted
she → act → warning
Her 2018 will left the entire estate to Dogan, excluding Aysel and Attila.
asserted
will → leave → Aysel
A separate handwritten note explained the decision, saying the conditions set out in her earlier letter had not been fulfilled.
asserted
conditions → explain → letter
“You still do not talk to your brother Dogan, and you still do not show me love and respect.
asserted
you → talk → love
You destroyed my home and I deleted you from my will,” she wrote, according to the court reporting.
uncertain
she → destroy → reporting
Dervishe died in 2021, leaving an estate valued at approximately £1.1 million.
asserted
Dervishe → die → million
Aysel subsequently brought a legal challenge against Dogan, who was administering the estate, arguing that their mother would not have independently decided to disinherit her.
asserted
mother → bring → her
Daughter alleged brother influenced mother's decision
asserted
brother → allege → decision
Aysel argued that Dogan had exerted undue influence over their mother and turned her against the younger siblings.
asserted
Dogan → argue → siblings
Her legal team questioned whether Dervishe had understood and approved the contents of her final will, or whether she had been pressured into signing it.
asserted
she → question → it
Her barrister, Peter John, argued that the decision was inconsistent with what Aysel understood to be her mother's longstanding approach to inheritance: treating her children equally.
asserted
Aysel → argue → children
He also questioned the authenticity and authorship of the handwritten letters, arguing that Dervishe could not have composed them without significant assistance.
uncertain
Dervishe → question → assistance
The language used in the letters, he suggested, bore similarities to Dogan's correspondence.
uncertain
he → use → correspondence
Aysel, who lived in Turkey, told the court that she had remained close to her mother and regularly travelled from Istanbul to visit her during her later years.
asserted
she → live → years
“I remained extremely close to my mother all my life,” she said.
asserted
she → remain → mother
She also maintained that her brother had influenced Dervishe's views and that the final will did not reflect their mother's genuine wishes.
asserted
will → maintain → wishes
Her case included allegations of fraudulent calumny, a legal claim involving false statements that allegedly cause someone to change their will.
uncertain
someone → include → will
Dogan denied the allegations.
asserted
Dogan → deny → allegations
His position was that his mother had made her own decision and that he had not been involved in preparing the will or the accompanying letters.
asserted
he → make → will
His wife, Susan, was also involved in the proceedings as a co-executor.
asserted
wife → involve → executor
Attila was a co-defendant, although Dogan and Susan had subsequently arranged for him to receive a one-third share of the estate through a deed of variation.
asserted
him → arrange → variation
Judge finds no evidence of undue influence
asserted
Judge → find → influence
Judge Mark Raeside KC, hearing the dispute at Central London County Court, rejected Aysel's allegations and upheld the 2018 will.
asserted
KC → hear → will
He found that Dogan had not helped prepare the document or the handwritten letters explaining his mother's decision.
asserted
Dogan → find → decision
“I reject the assertion that the deceased had any assistance from Dogan with her will.
asserted
deceased → reject → will
The evidence makes clear he was simply a dutiful son,” the judge said.
asserted
judge → make → ?
He added that both side letters had been written in Turkish in Dervishe's own handwriting and that Dogan had nothing to do with them.
asserted
Dogan → add → them
The court also considered evidence from the solicitor who prepared the will.
asserted
who → consider → will
…and 6 more, not listed.