An inheritance dispute over nearly $3.2 million in US assets left by an Iranian shipping businessman has returned to court after a Maryland appeals court overturned a jury's decision in favour of his eldest daughter.
asserted
court → leave → daughter
The case centres on whether Seyedkazem Amini-Nejad, who died in 2023 at the age of 95, understood the estate documents that left his American assets exclusively to one of his three daughters.
asserted
that → centre → daughters
In a ruling dated October 28, 2026, the Appellate Court of Maryland said the jury had been given an incorrect legal standard when considering the younger daughters' claim that their sister deliberately interfered with their expected inheritance.
uncertain
sister → date → inheritance
Amini-Nejad had spent most of his life in Iran, where he co-owned a shipping company with two business partners.
asserted
he → spend → partners
He travelled to the United States to visit his family and receive medical treatment.
asserted
He → travel → treatment
All three of his daughters lived in the US, and the eldest, Ellahe Amini-Nejad, had been involved in managing his finances and accompanying him to medical and legal appointments during his visits.
asserted
eldest → live → visits
The dispute arose from estate-planning documents signed during a visit to the US in March 2019.
asserted
dispute → arise → March
On March 22 that year, Amini-Nejad signed a will stating that his cash, liquid assets, stocks, shares, bank accounts, life insurance policies and retirement benefits should go to Ellahe.
asserted
cash → sign → Ellahe
She was also named the executor and personal representative of the will.
asserted
She → name → will
A trust was established soon afterwards, with Ellahe named as its sole trustee and beneficiary.
asserted
Ellahe → establish → trustee
Court records show that $3,199,794 was transferred into the trust.
asserted
3,199,794 → show → trust
The documents did not name his younger daughters, Elham and Eman, as beneficiaries.
asserted
documents → name → beneficiaries
The arrangements became contentious after Amini-Nejad died on May 23, 2023.
uncertain
Nejad → become → May
The younger sisters said they had not been informed about the will or trust and discovered the documents only after travelling to Iran for their father's funeral.
asserted
they → say → funeral
While searching through his belongings at the family home in Tehran, they found a folder containing estate papers, bank documents and handwritten notes in Farsi.
asserted
they → search → Farsi
The notes became an important part of their challenge.
asserted
notes → become → challenge
Elham testified that she was certain the handwriting on a note attached to the will belonged to her eldest sister.
asserted
handwriting → testify → sister
The younger daughters argued that their father spoke limited English and could not have adequately understood the English-language legal documents he had signed.
uncertain
he → argue → documents
They also maintained that he had wanted his three daughters to remain united and share his estate.
asserted
daughters → maintain → estate
The sisters filed a lawsuit in Maryland in January 2024, alleging fraud, undue influence, intentional interference with their expected inheritance and financial exploitation.
asserted
sisters → file → inheritance
They sought to have the trust invalidated and compensation for the assets they believed had been wrongfully diverted.
asserted
they → seek → assets
During the trial, the eldest daughter disputed the allegations and maintained that her father had independently chosen how to distribute his American assets.
asserted
father → dispute → assets
The attorney who prepared the estate documents testified that he communicated with Amini-Nejad in both Farsi and English and believed his client understood the arrangements and was acting voluntarily.
asserted
client → prepare → arrangements
The court also heard that all three daughters had accompanied their father to appointments during his visits to the US.
asserted
daughters → hear → US
The younger sisters pointed to another decision their father had made: in August 2021, he transferred the deed of the family home in Tehran to all three daughters.
asserted
he → point → daughters
They argued that this was consistent with his wish to treat them equally.
asserted
this → argue → them
They also questioned why the will and trust had not been disclosed to them while their father was alive.
asserted
father → question → them
After a four-day trial in Howard County Circuit Court, the jury found that Elham and Eman had a reasonable expectation of receiving an inheritance.
asserted
Elham → find → inheritance
However, it ruled in favour of Ellahe on their claim of intentional interference, finding that they had not established that she had engaged in wrongful conduct with the purpose of preventing them from receiving the inheritance.
uncertain
she → rule → inheritance
The crucial issue was the standard of proof the jury had been instructed to apply.
asserted
jury → instruct → proof
The trial judge had told jurors that the younger sisters needed to establish their claim through "clear and convincing evidence", a relatively demanding standard used in certain civil cases, including fraud claims.
uncertain
sisters → tell → claims
The sisters challenged that instruction on appeal, arguing that the court should instead have applied the lower standard of "preponderance of the evidence".
asserted
court → challenge → evidence
Under this standard, a claim is established when the evidence makes it more likely than not that the alleged conduct occurred.
uncertain
conduct → establish → standard
The Appellate Court of Maryland agreed.
asserted
Court → agree → Maryland
In its October 28 opinion, written by Judge Kathryn Graeff, the court said the correct standard for intentional interference with an expected inheritance was preponderance of the evidence.
asserted
standard → write → evidence
It reasoned that the claim was closely related to other civil claims involving interference with economic interests, for which the lower standard applies.
uncertain
standard → reason → which
The court also referred to the legal framework adopted when Maryland first recognised intentional interference with an inheritance as a civil claim in 2020.
uncertain
Maryland → refer → 2020
That earlier decision had not specified the burden of proof.
asserted
decision → specify → proof
The appeals court said the standard should be consistent with the principles governing interference with economic expectations.
asserted
standard → say → expectations
It further explained that the incorrect instruction could have affected the jury's decision.
uncertain
instruction → explain → decision
…and 9 more, not listed.