VIENNA/BRUSSELS, Nov 17 - Five European Union countries — Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands — have said they want to send rejected asylum seekers to a deportation hub in Rwanda and are in talks with Kigali to make that happen next year.
asserted
that → say → Kigali
Here is what we know so far about the plan.
asserted
know → know → plan
Adult migrants who have exhausted all legal avenues to remain in the EU would be sent to the hub, where they would spend a few weeks receiving language and other, as yet unspecified, skills training before integrating into Rwandan society.
asserted
they → exhaust → society
Alternatively they could return to their home country.
uncertain
they → return → country
The plan differs from a scheme planned but later abandoned by Britain, which would have involved sending asylum seekers to Rwanda while their claims were processed.
uncertain
claims → differ → Rwanda
The new proposal especially targets those whose asylum claims have been rejected but who cannot be returned to their home country.
uncertain
who → target → country
That can happen if, for example, the EU deems it unsafe or the country will not take them back.
asserted
country → happen → them
The hub would be the first of its kind for the EU and would run as a pilot scheme before being introduced elsewhere, officials say.
asserted
officials → run → scheme
Initially it would have a limited capacity of about 100 people at a time, likely meaning only a few hundred a year.
asserted
it → have → hundred
While that is a tiny number for the EU, which received 669,365 asylum applications last year, the countries involved say it would send an important signal to would-be migrants, deterring them from making the often perilous journey in the first place.
asserted
it → receive → place
That would, in turn, help undermine people-smuggling networks, they argue.
asserted
they → help → networks
Domestic politics also plays an important role, since the countries involved are led by centrist parties struggling not to lose more ground to far-right parties campaigning against illegal immigration.
asserted
countries → play → immigration
The plan has faced criticism on legal, humanitarian and practical grounds.
asserted
plan → face → grounds
Since there has been no return hub before, it is unclear whether the concept will survive review by the European courts.
uncertain
concept → survive → courts
Particularly contentious is the notion that the EU's legal responsibility would end once a migrant is transferred to Rwanda and that thereafter only Rwandan law would apply.
asserted
law → end → Rwanda
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights says EU nations remain bound by their obligations when cooperating with third countries and remain accountable for rights violations after a person is transferred.
asserted
person → say → violations
The five countries say they are utilising a newly created EU framework that makes it possible to send rejected asylum seekers to third countries.
asserted
it → say → countries
The Council of Europe, a non-EU body that promotes democracy and the rule of law across the continent, said in July that return hubs pose considerable risks for human rights.
asserted
hubs → promote → rights
The UN rights chief, Volker Turk, also expressed concern on Tuesday over the implications of the scheme for human rights.
asserted
chief → express → rights
Rights groups point to Rwanda's much poorer rights record and say sending already vulnerable migrants there only increases the risk of harm.
asserted
sending → point → harm
They also question whether such hubs would succeed in deterring future migrants.
asserted
hubs → question → migrants
Rwanda, which has positioned itself as a destination for migrants, has rejected criticism of its rights record.
asserted
which → position → record
The plan, especially its limited capacity, has drawn criticism from some within the five participating EU countries.
asserted
plan → draw → countries
"As long as thousands of illegal migrants continue to pour into Europe unhindered every day... any external centre is worthless from day one," the far-right Freedom Party, the biggest party in Austria's parliament, said in a statement.
asserted
Party → continue → statement
Much about the Rwanda plan remains unknown, such as where deportees would be housed and under what conditions.
asserted
deportees → remain → conditions
European officials say such centres would be "open", meaning people would not be locked inside.
asserted
people → say → ?
But what that means exactly is unclear.
uncertain
means → mean → what
The cost to the five countries and what Rwanda will receive in exchange have also yet to be negotiated or disclosed.
asserted
Rwanda → receive → exchange
"We are not looking at really getting money or being paid for us to participate in this partnership.
asserted
us → look → partnership
We are looking for a sustainable solution to a global challenge, which is migration, illegal migration," Rwandan Interior Minister Vincent Biruta told a press conference on Monday.
asserted
Biruta → look → Monday
European officials say it will be cheaper than keeping the deportees in Europe.
asserted
it → say → Europe
Asked on Monday what Rwanda would receive in exchange, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said: "When I'm entering a partnership with another country... I'm always working for (it to be) a good deal for both countries."
asserted
it → ask → countries