In short:
In an extremely uncommon move, the US government has publicly criticised an Australian government policy proposal.
asserted
government → criticise → proposal
It wants US social media companies excluded from digital duty of care laws, which would give Australians the option to opt out of algorithmic feeds.
asserted
which → want → feeds
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is in New York promoting Australian tech policies at the United Nations.
asserted
Albanese → promote → Nations
The Trump administration has made an extraordinary public intervention into Australia's debate about its proposed digital duty of care, warning the Albanese government that the policy would be "extraterritorial censorship of protected speech".
asserted
policy → make → speech
It called for the Australian government to exclude US social media companies from its plans to give users the option to opt into algorithmic recommendation feeds — a decision that would effectively neuter the law, removing the biggest platforms from its application.
asserted
that → call → application
The rare public rebuke took the form of a response to a consultation on the draft digital duty of care bill, which would force platforms to take actions to mitigate and respond to harms caused by digital platforms.
asserted
which → take → platforms
The submission, published by the US Embassy today, said Washington had "serious concerns" about how Australia would decide what counts as "foreseeable harm".
asserted
what → publish → harm
This comes with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese currently in the middle of a United States trip to promote his government's tech policy agenda at the United Nations General Assembly.
asserted
This → come → Assembly
His support for international AI regulation and his government's teen social media ban have increasingly earned the ire of the Trump administration.
asserted
support → earn → administration
Washington objects to harm rules and feed mandates
asserted
Washington → object → rules
In the submission, the US government said it was concerned by what it described as rigid, one-size-fits-all design requirements.
asserted
size → say → requirements
Such mandates, it argued, would push platforms to demote sensitive or controversial topics to comply, reducing the reach of independent journalists and other voices.
"
asserted
it → argue → journalists
The US government would likely consider such a measure as facilitating censorship," the submission said.
asserted
submission → consider → censorship
It put a number of questions to the Australian government, including how Australia would define "harm" and "risks", how they would be adjudicated, by whom, and whether platforms or users could appeal.
uncertain
platforms → put → whom
It also asked about the role of the eSafety Commissioner and impacts on privacy.
asserted
It → ask → privacy
While it is common for governments to express their views on other countries' policies, those views are usually communicated through private channels.
asserted
views → express → channels
It is exceedingly rare for a foreign government to make a direct, public intervention into a domestic debate like this.
asserted
government → make → this
The US government's hostility toward the digital duty of care was signposted earlier this month in a statement from White House spokesperson Kush Desai to the Guardian Australia.
asserted
hostility → signpost → Australia
He said President Donald Trump had warned other nations against imposing "digital services taxes, fines, and other forms of extortion on America's leading technology sector".
asserted
Trump → say → sector
Warning Australia's tech policies could spread elsewhere
The submission argued forced changes to mitigate Australia-specific risks could change how users everywhere, including Americans, experienced the platforms.
uncertain
users → warn → platforms
If other jurisdictions adopted conflicting duty-of-care mandates, platforms could face incompatible design requirements not technically or commercially scalable in parallel, it said.
uncertain
it → adopt → parallel
Australia's teen social media ban inspired a number of other countries to introduce, or pledge to introduce, similar restrictions.
asserted
ban → inspire → restrictions
Earlier today, it was reported by Politico Australia that the American industry body representing American tech companies had joined in a High Court challenge to Australia's teen social media ban.
asserted
body → report → ban
The group, NetChoice, described it as "the most extensive prohibition on youth access to social media in force in any liberal democracy".
asserted
group → describe → democracy
The digital duty of care draft shows how the government plans to create a legal obligation for online services, including social media, gaming and other platforms, to create a safe experience for users through its design.
asserted
government → show → design
The Albanese government said it would use this law, if passed, to force platforms like Facebook, Instagram and TikTok to send users a pop-up offering a choice between a personalised algorithmic feed and a feed limited to accounts they follow.
asserted
they → say → accounts
Communications Minister Anika Wells last week downplayed the White House's warning as "broad" and said she had not directly received such a warning from a US representative.
asserted
she → downplay → representative
When asked about the US government's intervention, Ms Wells's office and the US Embassy both declined to comment.
asserted
office → ask → intervention
The Aporia
