Buffer zones to keep data centres at least 150 metres from homes have arrived too late to stop three so-called hyper-scale projects in Melbourne’s west, exempting developers who lodged plans before Labor tightened the rules.
asserted
Labor → keep → rules
Premier Ben Carroll revealed on Tuesday Labor’s policy to ban data centres near homes, while also introducing new power, water and community investment standards for developers.
asserted
Carroll → reveal → developers
Projects already under way or which have lodged planning applications will be unaffected by them – including a data centre about 60 metres from homes.
asserted
which → lodge → homes
Projects yet to be approved must still be approved under existing planning rules.
asserted
Projects → approve → rules
At least three proposed data centre projects will breach the government’s 150-metre buffer, in communities which have protested against the AI infrastructure and raised concerns about noise, pollution and other impacts.
asserted
which → propose → noise
The Department of Planning and Transport is accepting public submissions over an application by Australian data centre giant NextDC to expand its West Footscray facility, with more computing infrastructure to be built adjacent to homes.
asserted
Department → accept → homes
The land the data centre sits on, zoned industrial and adjacent to a residential zone, once had small factories and warehouses on it.
asserted
centre → sit → it
Developer GreenSquare has also lodged an application to build a data centre in Spotswood which would breach the government’s 150-metre buffer – even though it is proposed for badly contaminated land that once housed Mobil’s fuel storage tanks.
asserted
that → lodge → tanks
A planning report for the project notes that houses are “more than 60 metres away and separated by the [Werribee] railway corridor, ensuring that the development will not result in unacceptable amenity impacts”.
asserted
development → note → impacts
Resident Jacqui Glover’s property boundary in West Footscray is just 15 metres from the edge of the sprawling NextDC data centre, which began construction in 2021 after initial approval by Maribyrnong City Council.
asserted
which → sprawl → Council
The data centre will eventually fill almost the entire 10-hectare block.
asserted
centre → fill → block
Glover said while she welcomed the new rules, “it’s too little, too late for us in Tottenham and West Footscray”.
asserted
it → say → Tottenham
Another planned data centre, on land owned by the Scalzo family that sits just 200 metres to the east of the NextDC campus, was approved by the state government last year.
asserted
that → own → government
It too faces onto housing in the same street as Glover, but will also be unaffected by the new rules.
asserted
It → face → rules
“If Labor genuinely believes in these proposed guidelines they should be applied to every data centre development,” Glover said.
asserted
Glover → believe → development
She said the 150-metre rule would not help when data centres ran their back-up generators, which generally run off diesel fuel stored on site.
asserted
which → say → site
“Diesel emissions aren’t going to just stop 150 metres away from homes.”
asserted
emissions → go → homes
The premier said the changes would prevent suburban streets being transformed by multi-level data centres, while also allowing Victoria to capitalise on the economic benefits brought by AI’s rapid expansion.
asserted
Victoria → say → expansion
Asked if the changes were coming too late to protect neighbourhood character, Carroll said no.
asserted
Carroll → ask → character
“I am a premier that gives certainty to industry.
asserted
that → give → industry
So applications that were made under the old rules will proceed.”
asserted
that → make → rules
The government intends to strengthen the regulations before it enters caretaker mode from November 3 in the lead-up to the state election, but Carroll could not offer certainty that the changes would be locked in by then.
uncertain
changes → intend → certainty
The new requirements, outlined in Labor’s Sustainable Data Centre Action Plan, will also enforce guidelines for water and energy use and air and noise pollution.
asserted
requirements → outline → use
They come as global tensions over AI increase.
asserted
tensions → come → AI
Industry chiefs and world leaders have warned that the technology’s growth may outpace governments’ ability to regulate it, and that it could cause human extinction.
uncertain
it → warn → extinction
At the United Nations this week, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese signed a joint declaration calling for international oversight of AI models.
asserted
Albanese → sign → models
On Wednesday, a federal inquiry into the technology will hold its first public hearings in Melbourne.
asserted
inquiry → hold → Melbourne
CDC Data Centres welcomed on Tuesday the state government’s plan, and chief executive Greg Boorer said clear guidelines would help comfort investors considering making funding decisions.
asserted
guidelines → welcome → decisions
He said discussions about data centres were no longer just about planning but were “fundamentally a conversation about Australia’s digital future and the infrastructure required to support it”.
asserted
discussions → say → it
“As one of Australia’s most important data centre regions, the policy settings adopted by Victoria have an important role to play in supporting investment, innovation and Australia’s long-term digital capability,” Boorer said.
asserted
Boorer → adopt → investment
“Communities want confidence that the organisations developing and operating critical infrastructure are responsible contributors to the places where they invest.”
But Data Centres Australia, an advocacy group representing developers, technology companies and other related businesses, criticised the decision to include 150-metre buffer zones.
asserted
Australia → want → zones
Chief executive Belinda Dennett said operators already supported most aspects of the government’s rules, but the setback requirements would hurt projects where investments had already been committed.
asserted
investments → say → projects
“It is disappointing to see Victoria, the state that recognised the economic opportunity to attract data centre investment and proudly declared its ambition to be a global data centre leader, now move to impose requirements on data centres that apply to no comparable industrial use,” she said.
asserted
she → see → use
Dennett said data centres were already restricted to industrial land, and individual projects had to go through environment and planning approvals.
asserted
projects → say → approvals
She said the 150-metre setback added a restriction that warehouses and logistics hubs did not have to meet, and that industrial land was already scarce.
“It can render an otherwise suitable site unviable,” Dennett said.
asserted
Dennett → say → that
She also said the government’s faster approval process, the Development Facilitation Program, had recently not been making decisions on applications under the government’s old rules, leading to a “de facto freeze” that would force developers to spend elsewhere.
asserted
that → say → developers
Artificial Intelligence Minister Anthony Carbines said setting clear regulations would give businesses certainty and Victoria a competitive edge over other states.
asserted
setting → say → states
But Liberal frontbencher James Newbury said Carroll could not be trusted to regulate data centres, pointing to the suburban projects which ignited community protest.
“
uncertain
which → say → protest
Every Victorian can look on and see the track record of what they’ve allowed and the places they’ve allowed it to be built, and feel unfortunately certain that that would continue under a Labor government,” he said.
asserted
he → look → government
The Greens said the government’s policy was a major retreat that had come after pressure from communities.
asserted
that → say → communities
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
