As gangs gain influence, Brazil seeks to shield election from candidates with criminal ties
RIO DE JANEIRO, Sept 22 - Brazil has opened a new front against organized crime to keep candidates suspected of criminal ties off the ballot at October's general election in what experts say is an unprecedented effort in Latin American politics.
asserted
experts → gain → politics
But, by targeting politicians who have not been convicted of any crime, the campaign is raising questions from some experts and targeted candidates over whether electoral authorities are stretching the limits of existing law and risking violations of due process.
asserted
authorities → target → process
"Interference in the election, in the people's democratic vote, whether political or judicial, leads to a dictatorship," said center-right congressional candidate Clebio Lopes Jacare, whose candidacy was barred over allegations that he is part of a criminal organization.
asserted
he → lead → organization
Brazil's courts have long played a decisive role in determining who can run for office, banning even the most consequential candidates because they had convictions, including President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who was barred from the 2018 election, and rival ex-President Jair Bolsonaro, who is blocked from this year's race.
asserted
who → play → race
Both claimed the cases against them were politically motivated.
asserted
cases → claim → them
But prosecutors are now advancing an interpretation of Brazil's law which they say allows them to protect the ballot from even suspected criminals, pitting growing concern over organized crime's influence in politics against democratic protections.
asserted
them → advance → protections
Brazilian legislation typically requires a conviction by an appellate court to bar candidates from running.
asserted
legislation → require → candidates
Yet a Reuters review of 20 rulings barring candidates under the push against organized crime shows that none have been convicted at that level.
asserted
none → bar → level
Criminal gangs' influence in politics is "a big and growing problem in Latin America," said Marcela Rios Tobar, regional director for Latin America and the Caribbean at the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, a non-profit.
asserted
Tobar → grow → Democracy
However, she stressed the need to balance those concerns with legal due process and avoid a situation where "accusations of wrongdoing are used as a political weapon."
asserted
accusations → stress → weapon
GANGS EXPAND THEIR REACH
asserted
GANGS → expand → REACH
As Jacare's campaign team distributed leaflets in Nova Iguacu, a city of 800,000 people where he unsuccessfully ran for mayor, he stressed that authorities have yet to find him guilty of any crime.
asserted
him → distribute → crime
Prosecutors should seek to bar candidates linked to organized crime, Jacare said.
asserted
Jacare → seek → crime
But "they need to have facts, proof.
asserted
they → need → facts
It can't just be based on guesswork."
asserted
It → base → guesswork
But a 2024 ruling by Brazil's Superior Electoral Court, which oversees elections in the country, opened a precedent for authorities to challenge candidacies based on evidence rather than waiting for a criminal conviction.
asserted
authorities → oversee → conviction
The basis for the ruling is an article in Brazil's Constitution that says political parties cannot make use of paramilitary groups.
asserted
parties → say → groups
"Organized crime cannot find in the ballot box a path to institutionalize the power it conquered through weapons," said the head of the electoral court's office in the state of Rio de Janeiro, Claudio de Mello Tavares.
asserted
head → find → Janeiro
Nowhere is the criminal reach into politics in Brazil more evident than in the state of Rio de Janeiro, where the then head of the state assembly, Rodrigo Bacellar, was jailed last year accused of links to the Red Command, one of Brazil's biggest crime syndicates, which was designated as a terrorist group by the US.
asserted
which → jail → US
Officials are also investigating whether campaigns used money from organized crime, and have moved a small share of voting locations in Rio because they were in areas dominated by gangs.
asserted
they → investigate → gangs
Having polling stations "where the voting machine will be transported in an armored vehicle," Tavares said, raises obvious safety concerns for voters.
asserted
Tavares → have → voters
Among the candidates barred this year are two close relatives of Red Command leaders, a candidate charged in three murder cases, and a man convicted and given a 36-year sentence for illegal firearms possession who can still appeal.
asserted
who → bar → possession
But at least five people who prosecutors are seeking to keep off the ballot had no known links to armed groups.
asserted
prosecutors → seek → groups
Jacare, the candidate from Rio, was charged with embezzlement and other crimes.
asserted
Jacare → charge → embezzlement
Prosecutors argued, in Jacare's case, that "the democratic process cannot be hijacked by organized crime, whether armed or not."
The challenge of separating necessary measures from overreach is not lost on candidates being barred now.
"
asserted
challenge → argue → candidates
If everyone facing any type of legal proceeding or investigation were barred from running for office, Lula wouldn't be president, and Flavio Bolsonaro wouldn't be a candidate," Ney Santos, a congressional candidate whose bid has been challenged by prosecutors citing alleged ties to the First Capital Command crime syndicate, said in a video posted on Instagram.
asserted
bid → face → Instagram
Sao Paulo's electoral courts ruled in Santos' favor, but prosecutors said they'll appeal.
asserted
they → rule → favor
Santos did not reply to a request for comment.
asserted
Santos → reply → comment
Senator Flavio Bolsonaro, Lula's main competitor in this year's race, is being investigated for corruption, according to newly unsealed court files.
uncertain
Bolsonaro → investigate → files
He denies any wrongdoing.
asserted
He → deny → wrongdoing
Still, the courts' efforts against organized crime have found support among three legal experts consulted by Reuters.
asserted
efforts → find → Reuters
Electoral law professor Clever Vasconcelos said courts are responding to a real threat by adopting a broader interpretation of existing rules.
asserted
courts → say → rules
However, he added, Congress should amend the law to expand grounds for ineligibility to give efforts against organized crime a firmer legal basis.
asserted
Congress → add → basis
Yet Brazil has faced challenges even when the law is clearer.
asserted
law → face → challenges
Lula was barred from the 2018 election under a law that bars convicted felons from running for office.
asserted
that → bar → office
But the conviction was later annulled, paving the way for his victory in the 2022 presidential race.
asserted
conviction → annul → race
Efforts to bar malicious actors cannot come at the expense of due process, said Priscila Pamela Santos, president of the Institute for Defense of the Right to Defense, a Brazilian non-profit.
asserted
Santos → bar → Defense
"One cannot resort to unconstitutional measures that, in an attempt to protect democracy, end up undermining it," she said.
asserted
she → resort → it
Candidates barred by local courts can still appeal, and hope Brazil's highest electoral court does not confirm the 2024 precedent, said Rafael Soares, a law professor at Brazil's PUC-PR University.
asserted
Soares → bar → University
"No one would be naive enough to imagine that there isn't already an infiltration of organized crime into the elections," he said.
asserted
he → imagine → elections
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
