The biggest coal project before authorities in New South Wales, the HVO mine, will emit the equivalent of about 809m tonnes of climate-warming carbon dioxide if it wins approval.
asserted
it → emit → approval
That number, for most people, will carry little meaning, as might the calculation that adding that amount of greenhouse gas to the atmosphere will cause an extra 0.00036C of global heating.
But what if the public was instead told that that amount of carbon dioxide would expose almost half a million people to unprecedented heat, or kill nearly 15 million coral colonies on the Great Barrier Reef every time it bleaches?
uncertain
it → carry → Reef
All those statistics come from a new tool that translates the emissions from burning fossil fuels into estimated real-world climate effects taken from peer-reviewed climate studies.
“Small numbers in global warming can mean catastrophic impacts,” says prof Sarah Perkins-Kirkpatrick, a climate scientist at the Australian National University who is part of a team launching the Carbon Impacts Tracer.
asserted
who → come → Tracer
The NSW Independent Planning Commission is expected to make a decision this week about the future of the HVO mine, with the joint owners Yancoal and Glencore hoping to keep digging at the Hunter Valley site until 2045.
asserted
owners → expect → 2045
Plugging the project’s expected emissions into the tracer suggests, for example, the extra heat trapped in the atmosphere by its emissions will reduce crop production every year by an amount that is the equivalent to the minimum dietary requirements of 276,129 people.
uncertain
that → plug → people
The tool can be used to estimate the impact of carbon dioxide emissions from any project, company or state – or for any known amount of emissions – across eight different factors including the loss of labour hours due to excess heat, the loss of glaciers, the death of corals or lost food production.
asserted
tool → use → corals
Central to the tool is a metric known as Transient Climate Response to CO₂ Emissions (TCRE) – an established calculation that every billion tonnes of CO2 causes about 0.45C of global heating.
asserted
tonnes → know → heating
Once an amount of CO2 is known – such as from a major fossil project – it’s contribution to global heating can be calculated and, from there, says Perkins-Kirkpatrick, measured against already published studies.
asserted
Kirkpatrick → know → studies
“Every tonne of CO2 maters and we’ve known this for decades,” she said.
asserted
she → know → decades
“To pinpoint what this means with a high degree of confidence has taken us a long time.
asserted
this → pinpoint → time
This [tool] is to hold big fossil fuel emitters accountable.
asserted
emitters → hold → ?
It is not meant to be a blame game.
asserted
It → mean → ?
It just shows that all emissions have impacts and now we can prove it.”
asserted
we → show → it
All the results are presented as the best estimate within a likely range of uncertainty, with links back to the original scientific studies used for the calculations.
asserted
results → present → calculations
Perkins-Kirkpatrick accepts some may be sceptical of the results, but counters “we are not making these numbers up for shits and giggles.”
uncertain
we → accept → shits
“This is based on the best analysis published in the peer-reviewed literature,” she said.
asserted
she → base → literature
“
And this is only the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the impacts [of fossil fuel burning].”
asserted
it → come → burning
The Carbon Impacts Tracer was developed by scientists at the Australian National University, the Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for the Weather of the 21st Century and the Lethal Humidity Global Council, and was funded by the Minderoo Foundation.
asserted
Tracer → develop → Foundation
Maria Nawaz leads the Australian Climate Accountability Project at the Australian Human Rights Institute at the University of New South Wales – a partner in the tracer project.
asserted
Nawaz → lead → project
“One of the major challenges in climate litigation has been establishing a direct link between a government or a corporation’s actions and climate harms and suffering,” she said.
asserted
she → establish → actions
“Governments and corporations have argued their emissions are ‘just a drop in the ocean’ and too small to measure.
asserted
emissions → argue → ocean
“But we can now refute this defence and show the emissions of any state or corporation can be tied to a global warming figure and then human and ecological harms.
asserted
emissions → refute → figure
Elaine Johnson, an experienced climate lawyer and director of Johnson Legal but not involved in the work, said there will be governments and corporations that will not welcome the development of the tool.
asserted
that → say → tool
“Fossil fuel companies do not want people to be able to make that connection between their products and, say, deaths from heatwaves.
asserted
people → want → heatwaves
“But now the science is at the point where we can make those connections clearly.
asserted
we → make → connections
That is a story the industry does not want told.”
asserted
industry → want → ?
The Guardian approached Glencore, a partner in the HVO mine, for comment, but received no response.
asserted
Guardian → approach → response
The Aporia
