- Published
Warning: This story contains distressing details and discussion of sexual assault.
asserted
story → publish → assault
When Mary was a first-year college student, she woke up after a fraternity party with bruises and bite marks all over her body.
asserted
she → wake → body
She says it took her a few days to piece together that she had been sexually assaulted while "blacked out", and to find the strength - and the right avenue - to report the assault.
asserted
she → say → assault
The man she accused was eventually expelled, but police declined to bring charges because they said there was a lack of physical evidence.
asserted
they → accuse → evidence
Mary - whose name has been changed to protect her identity - says the process of finding some measure of justice was oftentimes confusing and disappointing.
"Even though it was a positive outcome, it was still so emotionally exhausting and draining, because I had to do all of this in tandem with getting used to being a college student for the first time," said Mary.
asserted
Mary → change → time
"In many ways, I had to be my own advocate, gathering all my evidence."
asserted
I → have → evidence
The experience with local police, she added, "left me with a deep sense of disappointment in the system".
asserted
she → add → system
How both universities and the criminal justice system respond to these types of assaults on college campuses is once again under the spotlight, after a former student at Cornell University filed a civil lawsuit alleging she was raped by several members of a fraternity two years ago, with prosecutors declining at the time to pursue a case.
asserted
prosecutors → respond → case
Mary did not attend Cornell, and her case is not connected with the university.
asserted
case → attend → university
But advocates for survivors of sexual assault say her case, and the Cornell allegations, are emblematic of the larger challenges in responding to sexual assault claims on college campuses specifically.
uncertain
case → say → campuses
The confusing web of systems and policies - which varies greatly by college - is one of several reasons why the vast majority of sexual assaults on college campuses, research suggests, go unreported.
uncertain
research → vary → campuses
"These processes are hard to navigate if you aren't in trauma," said Nancy Chi Cantalupo, an associate professor of law at Wayne State University who has represented victims on college campuses.
asserted
who → navigate → campuses
"If you are in trauma, they're virtually impossible to navigate."
asserted
they → navigate → trauma
Earlier this month, the former Cornell student known only as Jane Doe filed a lawsuit against the Ivy League university, alleging she was drugged and raped by several men at a fraternity house at the university in 2024.
asserted
she → know → 2024
She also alleged that Cornell failed to protect her or adequately punish the men involved.
asserted
Cornell → allege → men
Jane Doe said she had reported the alleged assault to campus police, who interviewed her, and provided information to the district attorney's office.
asserted
who → say → office
The prosecutor declined to bring charges at the time, but this week, Tompkins County District Attorney Matthew Van Houten re-
asserted
Houten → decline → time
Both Cornell and Van Houten have defended their handling of the 2024 case.
asserted
Cornell → defend → case
In a statement, external, the university said it had "conducted an extensive investigation and adjudication over several months and imposed different sanctions based on the findings and circumstances involving each student" in addition to creating a new framework for addressing sexual assault on campus.
asserted
it → say → campus
Cornell has said it followed the procedures outlined in a federal civil rights law called Title IX.
asserted
it → say → law
The law mandates that universities follow certain rules about investigating sexual assaults.
asserted
universities → mandate → assaults
Cornell said its investigation resulted in the fraternity involved being barred from campus, and that students involved were suspended or expelled.
asserted
students → say → campus
Typically, after a student reports an assault on campus, the university's Title IX office determines whether the alleged behaviour could constitute a violation of policy.
uncertain
behaviour → report → policy
Eventually, both parties attend a hearing with a panel of faculty members or other mediators to present evidence and testimony in the case before a decision by the school is reached.
asserted
decision → attend → school
One of the biggest challenges sexual assault survivors face is simultaneously navigating the university and the criminal justice system, which "serve different purposes, operate under different rules and timelines, and lead to different outcomes"
asserted
which → face → outcomes
, said Zoey Scheinblum-Brewer, a policy coordinator at the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network, a nonprofit anti-sexual assault organisation.
asserted
Brewer → say → Network
"Unclear guidance about the options available through these parallel processes can create so much confusion and uncertainty that some students ultimately decide not to report," she said.
uncertain
she → create → confusion
Mary said this process at her college was not clear to her when she made the decision to report the assault.
asserted
she → say → assault
"For me, it would've been nice to know what I was getting into before it all happened.
asserted
it → know → what
It felt like they were learning the process alongside me," she said of university officials.
asserted
she → feel → officials
While some colleges, like Cornell, have information sharing agreements with local police, Mary was told she had to go to police separately to file a report - a process she found physically exhausting.
asserted
she → have → process
Mary's lawyer says there was surveillance footage from the night showing her alleged rapist carrying her "slumped" over, and she had pictures of her bruises and bite marks.
asserted
she → say → bruises
But police told Mary they did not have probable cause for an arrest, and that the district attorney wanted to leave it to university administration.
asserted
attorney → tell → administration
"I was left with this taste that because they knew that the college was 'handling' my investigation, that they could wipe their hands clean of it," she said.
uncertain
she → leave → it
The local police department told the BBC it did not have the details of this particular case.
asserted
it → tell → case
The local district attorney's office did not respond to a request for comment.
asserted
office → respond → comment
Secrecy and protection
University investigations are done behind closed doors, said Helene Weiss, a lawyer who has represented several victims of sexual assault on college campuses.
asserted
who → do → campuses
She believes that part of the reason for the secrecy is to protect institutions' reputations.
asserted
part → believe → reputations
"The secrecy of the process, it prevents other students from knowing about it.
asserted
it → prevent → it
It prevents witnesses from coming forward," she said.
asserted
she → prevent → witnesses
…and 14 more, not listed.
The Aporia
