Top Democrats battle over California's proposed billionaire tax
Sanders and Khanna take the fight to Newsom's doorstep as early voting opens.
asserted
voting → propose → doorstep
Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna are heading to California to rally Saturday in support of an initiative that would place a one-time, 5% tax on the wealth of billionaires in the state.
asserted
that → head → state
Their efforts to barnstorm the state come as early voting begins, and millions of dollars have been spent to kill the initiative.
asserted
millions → barnstorm → initiative
The measure would affect roughly 200 of California's billionaires, with the money going to cover federal Medi-Cal cuts.
asserted
money → affect → cuts
Gov. Gavin Newsom has become its most prominent opponent, arguing that the tax could be dodged by billionaires who could leave the state for another.
uncertain
who → become → another
Prior to arriving in San Francisco, Khanna told ABC News that he and Newsom are "polar opposites" on the issue.
asserted
he → arrive → issue
Both have openly discussed that they are weighing a presidential bid in 2028.
asserted
they → discuss → 2028
“He [Newsom] doesn't want to offend some of the billionaires who he wants to finance his campaigns, and that's the question: Are we going to be a party for the working class?
asserted
we → want → class
Are we going to be beholden to our donors?”
asserted
we → go → donors
Khanna said.
asserted
Khanna → say → ?
The congressman challenged Newsom to a debate, proposing holding town halls and talking to voters about this issue.
"
asserted
congressman → challenge → issue
I'm happy to debate him on this any time in the state," he said.
asserted
he → debate → state
Asked by reporters earlier this week about Sanders' visit, Newsom said he has "enormous respect" for the senator, but on this specific issue, "we fundamentally disagree."
asserted
we → ask → issue
In a statement to ABC News, a spokesperson for Newsom said, "The Governor supports a national tax on billionaires and is proud to stand with teachers, firefighters, reproductive health clinics, and others in opposing this poorly written state measure that will harm California.”
asserted
that → say → California
Newsom has shared a counterproposal: a national billionaire tax focused on loans taken against assets.
asserted
Newsom → share → assets
Tech investors have pushed back hard on the measure.
asserted
investors → push → measure
Vinod Khosla warned that the state's top wealth creators will leave, and Mark Cuban told Khanna he doesn't understand business.
asserted
he → warn → business
Khanna pointed to Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang.
"Someone more successful than both of them, Jensen, is perfectly fine paying the tax, and he's driving the economy more than either of them are these days," Khanna said.
asserted
Khanna → point → them
Asked about whether he was concerned about the proposed tax by Bloomberg Television, Huang said, "I've got to tell you, I have not even thought about it once.
asserted
I → ask → it
We chose to live in Silicon Valley, and whatever taxes they would like to apply, so be it.
asserted
it → choose → taxes
But billionaires have also been opening their wallets to fight the measure.
asserted
billionaires → open → measure
Building a Better California, the flagship organization fighting the measure, has raised over $252 million, mostly from billionaires, according to public financial records.
uncertain
organization → fight → records
Top contributors include Google co-founder Sergey Brin (who has given $102 million), venture capitalist John Doerr (who has given $30 million) and former Google CEO Eric Schmidt (who has given $27 million).
asserted
who → include → million
Skeptics of Proposition 40, the official name for the billionaire tax ballot measure, say that the measure could ultimately reduce tax revenue by motivating wealthy Californians to relocate and take their wealth with them.
uncertain
measure → say → them
According to an analysis from California’s nonpartisan Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO), the tax could generate revenues in the tens of millions in the short term but cause decreases in income tax revenue in the future.
uncertain
tax → accord → future
No On Prop 40, a group funded by Building a Better California, is running several digital ads.
asserted
No → fund → ads
Some of the ads say that the billionaire tax would lead to a decline in tax revenue, while others claim that the measure will lead to the state legislature approving wealth taxes on non-billionaires.
uncertain
legislature → say → billionaires
No on Prop 40’s website lists dozens of groups that are members of its “coalition” opposed to the tax.
asserted
that → list → tax
Steven Fenaroli, a spokesperson for the group, says he thinks the billionaire tax will end up becoming “just another tax on farmers and ranchers.”
asserted
tax → say → farmers
“When my members are looking at Prop 40, they see this slippery slope that we seem to have in California,” Fenaroli told ABC News.
asserted
Fenaroli → look → News
David Lesperance, a tax lawyer who has helped several billionaires relocate from California, said, "My multi-billionaire clients… said, 'We need to get out of here.
asserted
We → help → California
That's over a trillion dollars that have left.
asserted
that → leave → ?
"
Yes on 40, the main group backing the measure, has received roughly $32.4 million, the vast majority from Service Employees International Union-United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW) and affiliated organizations.
asserted
group → back → West
Suzanne Jimenez, SEIU-UHW chief of staff, said the campaign expected to be heavily outspent.
asserted
campaign → say → staff
"It was part of our plan," Jimenez told ABC News.
asserted
Jimenez → tell → News
"I think the spending is actually counteracting what they're intending to do, and it's actually helping us in our conversations with voters."
asserted
it → think → voters
Several labor organizations, including California Professional Firefighters and California Teachers Association, are against the tax.
asserted
organizations → include → tax
When asked on a press call why labor groups would oppose a tax on billionaires, Sanders pointed to the media pumped out by the billionaire-backed anti-tax campaign.
asserted
Sanders → ask → campaign
“In America today, is it possible for a ballot item to win when it is being opposed by a handful of billionaires who are spending over $200 million?” Sanders asked.
asserted
Sanders → win → million
Do you still have a democracy in this country, or will billionaires rule?”
asserted
billionaires → have → country
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
