Almost exactly a year before Toronto’s upcoming municipal election on Oct. 26, a packed town hall in the downtown ward of Toronto Centre served as a preview of the brewing fury constituents had for the city’s embrace of harm reduction as the primary response to the illegal fentanyl crisis.
asserted
constituents → serve → crisis
A young man in the front row stood up when it was his turn to speak and looked at the city councillor for Toronto Centre, Chris Moise.
asserted
it → stand → Centre
“You keep saying ‘harm reduction,’ ” he began.
asserted
he → say → reduction
“Whose harm are you reducing by saying that?”
asserted
you → reduce → that
As fellow residents applauded, the constituent walked over to a nearby window that had been covered with makeshift blinds, which he pulled back to reveal a bustling, drug-fuelled encampment outside.
asserted
he → applaud → encampment
“This is (the) absolute filth and disgusting state of the park and the city,” he said to Moise.
asserted
he → say → Moise
Moise tried explaining that he can’t control who comes to his ward from the suburbs or neighbouring towns.
asserted
who → explain → suburbs
But the questioner wasn’t having it.
asserted
questioner → have → it
“This neighbourhood enables it,” he interjected.
asserted
he → enable → it
“We give them harm supplies — needles, crack pipes, foils and everything else.”
asserted
We → give → supplies
He asked Moise why Toronto’s wealthy Forest Hill neighbourhood doesn’t have this problem.
asserted
neighbourhood → ask → problem
Before Moise could answer, the constituent did so for him: “Because they don’t allow that.
uncertain
they → answer → that
And you are allowing it.
asserted
you → allow → it
And city council’s allowing it and they’re concentrating it into this neighbourhood.
asserted
they → allow → neighbourhood
And that’s what’s happening with George Hislop Park.”
asserted
what → ’ → Park
The person who captured this exchange on his phone was another constituent from Toronto Centre named Daniel Tate.
asserted
who → capture → Centre
About a year earlier, Tate started an advocacy group called IntegrityTO, whose chief purpose is to hold elected city officials to account for what he saw as the decaying state of Toronto.
asserted
he → start → Toronto
IntegrityTO made some waves protesting the renaming Toronto’s famous Yonge-Dundas Square to Sankofa Square, a move that had been spearheaded by Moise as a symbol of “decolonization.”
asserted
that → make → decolonization
But IntegrityTO was also building a considerable following by continually highlighting rampant open drug use, encampments in city parks and garbage-strewn streets.
asserted
IntegrityTO → build → parks
In January, Tate delivered a taxpayers’ land acknowledgement before a City of Toronto budget subcommittee that went viral.
asserted
that → deliver → subcommittee
More recently, he announced that he is running to replace Moise as the city councillor for Toronto Centre.
asserted
he → announce → Centre
One could not find two people more diametrically opposed in their approaches to the illegal fentanyl crisis.
uncertain
people → find → crisis
While Tate is not a fan of harm reduction, Moise is far from the only city councillor getting lambasted for being a devoted cheerleader for it.
asserted
Moise → lambast → it
The councillor for Spadina—Fort York, Deputy Mayor Ausma Malik, has also been taking heat over her elusiveness with constituents when it comes to complaints about drug disorder and homelessness.
asserted
it → take → disorder
When Malik’s constituents asked her to attend a community protest in 2023 over a planned large-scale, low-barrier, 24-hour facility providing meals and other services to the homeless in a residential community next to a school, Malik stayed home.
asserted
Malik → ask → school
This summer, the same community was demanding that Malik do something about the drug-fuelled chaos outside of a city-funded drop-in centre called West Neighbourhood House.
asserted
Malik → demand → centre
The best response Malik seems to have been able to muster is a note on her website promising that, “A comprehensive action plan is currently being developed.”
asserted
plan → seem → website
On Sept. 14, West Neighbourhood House held a “community check-in” meeting.
asserted
House → hold → meeting
While Malik is said to have made a brief appearance, several attendees told me there was no update from her on her plans.
asserted
attendees → say → plans
On Cunningham’s campaign website, “Recovery, Housing & Safer Communities” are listed together as his top priority.
asserted
Recovery → list → priority
A volunteer of Cunningham’s told me that drug addiction has consistently been the No. 1 concern voiced by residents and businesses during their canvassing of the ward.
asserted
addiction → tell → ward
In the nearby ward of Parkdale—High Park, there is a heated race to fill the gap left when Gord Perks, who represented the ward for two decades, announced his retirement earlier this year.
asserted
who → be → retirement
Perks’ parting words on his final day in city council in July didn’t come as a total surprise, given his political leanings.
asserted
words → come → leanings
“Capitalism is trash,” declared Perks, a sentiment applauded by many of his fellow councillors and agreed to by one of the candidates vying to succeed him, Diana Chan McNally.
asserted
Perks → declare → him
Chan McNally, who describes herself as a “front-line community worker, arts worker and advocate,” has been a vocal activist when it comes to her support for injection sites and the rights of homeless people to build encampments in public parks.
asserted
it → describe → parks
When a group in her ward called Residents for a Safe Parkdale began sending officials photographic evidence of violence, needles and disorder outside of an injection site in the summer of 2025, it prompted the Ontario government to defund the site a few months later.
asserted
it → call → site
In December, the group released a subsequent email citing a social media post they claimed had been written by Chan McNally calling Residents for a Safe Parkdale “opponents,” whose emails about community safety concerns were “reactionary fodder.
asserted
emails → release → concerns
The group’s chief grievance about this post, however, was that Chan McNally allegedly claimed to have obtained “all of their names and emails.”
uncertain
McNally → claim → names
I reached out to Chan McNally to give her an opportunity to respond to the group’s complaints about this post, specifically their desire to know how she had come to possess their names and email addresses, which they saw as a privacy violation.
asserted
they → reach → violation
Chan McNally did not respond prior to my deadline.
asserted
McNally → respond → deadline
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
