Carney secures another China trade deal — but at what cost?
asserted
Carney → secure → cost
China hawks urge PM to be wary of country he once called the 'biggest security threat'
asserted
he → urge → country
Prime Minister Mark Carney has brokered another trade deal with China that will deliver meaningful relief to Canadian sectors long stymied by tariffs and red tape.
But Ottawa is also making concessions of its own, which has some China hawks feeling squeamish.
asserted
hawks → broker → own
China imprisoned Canadians amid the Meng Wanzhou affair — the Huawei executive was placed on house arrest at the Americans' request due to fraud charges — and the 2024 foreign interference inquiry singled out China as "the most active perpetrator of foreign interference" in Canada.
Carney himself said last year during a leaders' debate that China is the "biggest security threat" to Canada.
asserted
China → imprison → Canada
His government created a new foreign influence registry to try to tamp down meddling by China and others.
asserted
government → create → China
But, with the U.S. relationship on shaky ground as the Trump administration pummels Canadian products with potentially industry-destroying tariffs, Carney has taken what he describes as a more "pragmatic" and "constructive" approach to China while maintaining "guardrails" that prevent the two countries from becoming too intertwined.
asserted
that → pummel → countries
After meeting Chinese President Xi Jinping on Tuesday, the Prime Minister's Office said in a readout that Carney agreed to "further elevate this partnership" with China.
asserted
Carney → meet → China
"The leaders agreed that the peoples of both countries are benefiting from these renewed ties between Canada and China," according to the PMO.
uncertain
peoples → agree → PMO
The Carney-Xi meeting took place on the sidelines of the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China.
asserted
meeting → take → Shenzhen
Michael Kovrig, a former diplomat who was one of the two men taken into custody in China after Meng's arrest, said he is watching the improving relations with "a great deal of concern" and is urging Carney to tread carefully.
asserted
he → take → Carney
In an interview with CBC News, Kovrig said relations with China have undoubtedly thawed but "they're not back to normal and they shouldn't be.
asserted
they → say → China
The challenge is to make sure that the benefits don't come with bigger and more problematic downsides," he said.
asserted
he → make → downsides
Kovrig noted that China has weaponized tariffs in the past to punish Canadian farmers and can do so again.
"
asserted
China → note → farmers
The readout doesn't say anything about national security or transnational repression or human rights issues or about Canadian detainees in China.
asserted
readout → say → China
They should also be a priority along with market access," he said.
asserted
he → say → access
Kovrig said drawing closer to the Chinese, and allowing new imports like EVs and steel products, also has the potential to anger the Americans, jeopardizing what he describes as Canada's single most important economic relationship.
asserted
he → say → relationship
"You have to put Washington first.
asserted
You → have → Washington
I know that's not a popular idea in Canada right now," he said.
asserted
he → know → Canada
Trump himself has brokered trade deals with China — he praised Xi as a "great leader" — and his administration is currently embroiled in the fallout from the former Nvidia CEO's affair with an alleged Chinese spy.
asserted
administration → broker → spy
Trump's commerce secretary, Howard Lutnick, has also been accused of pushing to weaken U.S. chip export rules to benefit Asian AI data centres that do business with China.
asserted
that → accuse → China
Despite that baggage, Peter Navarro, a Trump trade adviser and frequent Canada critic, said Carney's dealings with China are "offensive in the extreme."
"China is going to eat Canada alive," he said.
asserted
he → say → Canada
Still, the early results suggest that looking past bad Chinese behaviour is paying dividends for Canadian businesses and the people they employ.
asserted
they → suggest → businesses
Xi agreed to drop his country's "anti-discriminatory tariffs," worth up to 25 per cent on some $400 million worth of Canadian pork and seafood products — a manoeuvre that delivers immediate benefits to those sectors by unlocking access to China's vast market for foodstuffs.
asserted
that → agree → foodstuffs
In addition to a commitment to take more lentils, fava beans, "wild aquatic products" and pet food, among other agri-food items, Xi is extending the tariff pause Carney secured in January for Canadian canola meal, peas, lobster and crab, which has been an economic boon.
asserted
which → take → meal
Indeed, since Carney's first meeting with Xi, and what the government says is 35 other ministerial visits and engagements to smooth over bilateral irritants, Canadian exports to China have surged.
asserted
exports → say → China
Statistics Canada data and figures from the University of Alberta's China Institute show that Canadian trade with China hit a record $12.7 billion last quarter.
asserted
trade → show → billion
The dollar value of Canadian products sent to the Asian economic powerhouse has surged by 60 per cent over the last two years, a byproduct of Carney's move to restore relations with Beijing.
asserted
value → send → Beijing
Kyle Larkin, president and CEO of the Canadian Meat Council, said pork producers have suffered under the Chinese restrictions and Carney's deal to eliminate many of them is "a great step in the right direction.
asserted
deal → say → direction
"
"We're very happy," he told reporters in China.
asserted
he → tell → China
Vina Nadjibulla, the co-founder and CEO of the Centre for Strategic Statecraft, said U.S. trade actions necessitate Canada looking elsewhere for business — even if there are lingering concerns about cozying up to a country like China.
asserted
Canada → say → China
"China's behaviour hasn't changed, but Canada's strategic circumstance has," Nadjibulla said in an interview.
asserted
Nadjibulla → change → interview
"We are now living in a world in which we do have to diversify and we do have to economically engage with China in certain areas.
asserted
we → live → areas
But I hope that we remain smart and strategic and do not forget the lessons of the past.
asserted
we → hope → past
"
In return for all this new access, Carney is opening the door wider to Chinese steel and aluminum imports by extending and expanding remission measures for products that cannot be found in sufficient quantities in this country.
asserted
that → open → country
And Carney will continue to allow tens of thousands of Chinese electric vehicles to enter Canada annually at a reduced tariff rate — although the number imported so far is significantly below this year's quota of 49,000.
asserted
number → continue → 49,000
A backgrounder on the Carney-Xi deal distributed to reporters states that, after past BYD approvals, a second, unnamed Chinese company has just secured the necessary Transport Canada permissions to import its foreign-made cars.
asserted
company → distribute → cars
A government spokesperson confirmed that Geely, an automotive conglomerate with stakes in brands like Zeekr, Polestar and Lotus, now has the green light.
asserted
Geely → confirm → light
Much of Canada's auto industry has fiercely opposed giving Chinese firms access, fearing a flood of cheaply made, state-subsidized vehicles will sink remaining Canadian auto and parts production.
asserted
flood → oppose → production
While the Carney government previously expected significant manufacturing investment from Chinese EV makers in Canada, nothing has materialized — and the backgrounder released to reporters suggests none is coming soon.
uncertain
none → expect → reporters
Flavio Volpe, the president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers' Association (APMA), told CBC News that Ottawa must resist any temptation to allow Chinese firms to ship "knock-down" car kits into Canada for assembly.
asserted
firms → tell → assembly
…and 7 more, not listed.