THIS WEEK’S TRILATERAL SUMMIT among Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, China on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation leaders meeting will likely be too short to allow for a substantive exchange.
asserted
SUMMIT → allow → exchange
But I don’t expect the three men will pass up the opportunity to play Masters of the Universe for the cameras.
asserted
men → expect → cameras
For Putin, the event holds a special appeal.
asserted
event → hold → appeal
As expatriate Russian political analyst Alexandra Filipenko pointed out in an interview on Tuesday, the Russian president believes the summit shows he deserves a place “at the big boys’ table,” where he might join in deciding matters of global security.
uncertain
he → point → security
There’s one small problem with that framing: Just two days before the event, the world got a demonstration of Putin’s inability to ensure the security of even a dearly prized geopolitical possession: the Kerch Bridge.
asserted
world → ’ → possession
Built after the 2014 annexation of Crimea to connect the peninsula to the Russian mainland, the 12-mile bridge stands as a symbol of the Russian claim on the stolen peninsula.
uncertain
bridge → build → peninsula
Now, a part of it stands no more.
asserted
part → stand → it
Following weeks of attacks on Russian air defenses that left a gap in protective coverage over the structure, a combined drone and missile attack by Ukraine caused a large part of the span that supports a four-lane roadway to collapse.
asserted
that → follow → roadway
While the partial destruction of the bridge will likely cause logistical problems for Russian operations in Ukraine, Ukrainian reactions to the news have centered on Putin’s humiliation.
asserted
reactions → cause → humiliation
“Ukraine today has essentially publicly castrated Russian Tsar Vladimir Putin,” journalist Ivan Yakovina declared on his YouTube stream.
asserted
Yakovina → castrate → stream
Television host and YouTuber Olena Kurbanova, visibly beaming, showed an undated clip of a middle-aged Russian woman defiantly declaring, perhaps after one of Ukraine’s earlier, far smaller strikes targeting the bridge, “The Crimea bridge still stands and will stand.
asserted
bridge → beam → bridge
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov jauntily assured Izvestia that “there is no doubt that the bridge will be restored and will be even better than before.”
asserted
bridge → assure → Izvestia
As Yakovina noted, this wasn’t even the Kremlin’s only bad news on Tuesday: The Ukrainian military also struck the Salavat petrochemical factory in Bashkortostan, a major oil-processing facility run by the state-controlled Gazprom.
asserted
military → note → Gazprom
The extent of the damage is not yet known.
asserted
extent → know → damage
Understanding what’s happening in Ukraine, Russia, and across Europe takes more than following the headlines.
asserted
what → understand → headlines
At The Bulwark, we’re committed to serious reporting, informed analysis, and clear-eyed arguments about war, diplomacy, military power, and the future of European security.
asserted
we → commit → security
Join our Bulwark+ community today and help us keep asking the hard questions and making sense of a dangerous and changing world together.
asserted
us → join → world
ALL THIS COMES on the heels of yet another round in the so-called U.S.-Russia-Ukraine negotiations pushed by the Trump administration and its Two Stooges, Trump real estate pal Steve Witkoff and clown prince Jared Kushner.
asserted
THIS → come → administration
At those talks in Abu Dhabi last week, the Russian team, led by Putin court historian Vladimir Medinsky, turned the conversation to Europe’s overall “security infrastructure” and advanced a set of demands so bold, one might think Russian troops had already steamrolled over Kyiv and Warsaw and were powering their way toward Berlin.1
uncertain
troops → lead → Berlin.1
In addition to a drastic downsizing of the Ukrainian military and a categorical prohibition on foreign military aid to Ukraine going forward, the Russians also demanded an end to all NATO presence in countries that joined the alliance after 1997, a transformation of the country of Moldova intended to prevent its integration with the EU and keep it within Russia’s “sphere of influence,” and a curtailment of the U.K.-France nuclear protection for other European countries, intended to partly replace weakened security guarantees from the United States.
asserted
that → go → States
For people familiar with twentieth-century Russian classics, this wish list evokes the 1928 satirical novel The Twelve Chairs—specifically, a catchphrase from its con-artist antihero: “Would you also like the keys to the apartment where the money is stashed?”
asserted
money → evoke → apartment
It’s possible that these bizarre Kremlin demands are simply a dramatic opening position meant to be negotiated down.
asserted
demands → ’ → ?
Or maybe Putin and his henchmen are genuinely delusional, suggests Tufts University international politics professor Daniel Drezner—and perhaps the delusions are being cultivated by Trump’s dumb-and-dumber envoys, who have sought to appease the Russians from the start.
uncertain
who → suggest → start
Exiled Russian writer and astute commentator Dmitry Bykov has a similar idea: Noting parallels to Nabokov’s play The Waltz Invention, Bykov suggests that the people around Putin have “started humoring him, and as a result he’s started going crazy.
uncertain
he → have → result
The horrible part is that he quite seriously believes that his conditions will be met.”
Or else the Russian dictator is simply stalling for time, believing that by next spring his strategy of causing blackouts in Ukrainian cities during the cold months will finally break Ukraine’s resistance.
asserted
strategy → believe → resistance
In the meantime, U.S. negotiators are reportedly proposing brilliant ideas like redrawing the borders of the Donetsk and Luhansk provinces—which Russia claimed to annex in 2022 and listed in its constitution in 2022 as Russian territory—to match the extent of Russia’s occupied holdings, which would in turn make it possible for Putin to claim his forces had achieved full control over them.
uncertain
forces → propose → them
(The Ukrainians refused the suggestion.)
asserted
Ukrainians → refuse → suggestion
Obviously, none of this is serious; Trump might as well, as one witty Russian speaker suggested in a YouTube comment, offer to rename Alaska “the Donetsk province” and give it to Putin to make him happy.
uncertain
him → suggest → Putin
After the talks in Abu Dhabi concluded on November 11, the Two Stooges flew to Moscow for another sitdown with Putin himself.
asserted
Stooges → conclude → Putin
Reports that they received matching puffer jackets with “Russia” insignia as a gift from Putin adviser Kirill Dmitriev have been disputed.
asserted
they → receive → Dmitriev
What we do know, from Kremlin-released footage, is that they listened politely while Putin rambled through a Soviet-era joke about a crook and an investigator—the apparent purpose of which, ironically, was to illustrate the concept of a conversation going in pointless circles.
asserted
purpose → know → circles
This embarrassing moment was made even more uncomfortable by the interpreter’s long and painful struggles to translate Putin’s wit for the table.
asserted
moment → make → table
Putin did propose something ostensibly practical: a five-day ceasefire in the town of Kostyantynivka to allow the evacuation of an unknown number of remaining residents, similar to the one recently arranged in Oleshky, a town near Kherson.
asserted
Putin → propose → Kherson
(While the administration has touted Melania Trump’s role in brokering the truce, it was mostly coordinated by Russian and Ukrainian human rights commissioners.)
asserted
it → tout → commissioners
Kostyantynivka, despite repeated claims by the Russian military to have taken the town, is a complicated patchwork of Russian and Ukrainian posts and drone-controlled “kill zones.”
uncertain
Kostyantynivka → repeat → posts
Not only would a truce be virtually unenforceable; analysts believe that the proposal is most likely a Trojan-horse ploy to allow Russian forces to reinforce their positions in Kostyantynivka, or even expand their control over the town with a view to completing its capture after nearly a year of very costly fighting—and this in turn would make it possible for Russian forces to launch new attacks against other nearby fortified Ukrainian cities.
Just like Putin’s tedious joke, these negotiations aren’t going anywhere.
asserted
negotiations → believe → joke
The basic features of the situation remain the same: Russia’s delusional intransigence, Ukraine’s staunch resistance, the American president’s pathetic excuse-making for Putin, and Trump administration officials’ disgraceful criticisms of Ukraine’s strikes against targets deep within Russian territory.
asserted
features → remain → territory
What happens next depends on whether Ukraine will be able to get the weapons—and, crucially, the air defense interceptors—it needs.
asserted
it → happen → weapons
The new Congress must act to provide more aid, prevent any further interruptions in satellite communications and intelligence-sharing, and do what it can to make Trump irrelevant.
asserted
Trump → act → communications
Trump goes to Shenzhen as humiliated by the GOP’s collapse in the midterms as Putin is by the Kerch Bridge collapse under Ukrainian fire.
asserted
Putin → go → fire
…and 1 more, not listed.