The leader of the Parti Québécois says he will break with the monarchy in Quebec if he becomes premier, invoking the spectre of a constitutional battle that critics say could help him drum up support for an unpopular referendum on independence.
uncertain
him → say → independence
Paul St-Pierre Plamondon said this week that it’s “unacceptable” for a representative of the British Crown to have a role in Quebec’s Parliament.
asserted
representative → say → Parliament
If the PQ wins the provincial election on Oct. 5, he said his government will pass a law eliminating the role of lieutenant-governor.
asserted
government → win → governor
Quebec has for decades taken steps to reduce the visibility of the monarchy in its legislature, including when the Coalition Avenir Québec government scrapped a mandatory oath of allegiance to the Crown four years ago – a change that was also driven by the PQ Leader.
asserted
that → take → Leader
But experts say a move to unilaterally abolish the function of lieutenant- governor is transparently unconstitutional and would inevitably wind up in court.
asserted
move → say → court
“It’s almost being done intentionally just to cause a constitutional crisis that then bolsters the impetus for a referendum,” said Lawrence David, who teaches constitutional law at the University of Ottawa.
asserted
who → do → Ottawa
The PQ is widely expected to win Monday’s election and could claim a majority of the seats in the province’s National Assembly.
uncertain
PQ → expect → Assembly
Mr. St-Pierre Plamondon has promised to hold the province’s third sovereignty referendum by 2030, even though support for independence in Quebec is currently below 30 per cent.
asserted
support → promise → cent
On Tuesday, the PQ Leader said that it’s “not normal” for a representative of King Charles III to “tell us what to do
asserted
representative → tell → what
Lieutenant-governors swear in premiers and cabinet ministers, open legislative sessions and grant royal assent to bills passed by provincial legislatures.
asserted
governors → swear → legislatures
“There is nothing preventing the National Assembly from acting as a sovereign legislature and passing a law that abolishes the lieutenant-governor’s duties and stops allocating funds to this charade, which wastes money that could be put to better use,” he told reporters.
uncertain
he → be → reporters
He said he would redirect the provincial government’s contribution to the lieutenant-governor’s office – about $1.3-million in the 2026-27 fiscal year – to fighting homelessness.
asserted
he → say → homelessness
The lieutenant-governor’s salary and pension are paid by the federal government, while the province covers a portion of office expenses.
asserted
province → pay → expenses
But Mr. David said any such constitutional amendment would require the unanimous consent of the federal Parliament and every provincial legislature, and cannot be carried out unilaterally.
asserted
amendment → say → Parliament
“Mr. St-Pierre Plamondon knows that there is no way to argue that it’s not manifestly unconstitutional,” he said.
asserted
he → know → ?
If a court struck down the Quebec law, he added, Mr. St-Pierre Plamondon could argue that the only way to rid Quebec of the monarchy is through separation.
uncertain
way → strike → separation
Speaking to reporters Thursday, the PQ Leader denied that he’s spoiling for a fight with Ottawa ahead of a referendum, which he has said would not take place until U.S. President Donald Trump leaves the White House in 2029.
asserted
Trump → speak → 2029
“I am preparing Quebeckers for three years of true democracy, with my sole loyalty being to the interests of Quebeckers,” he said.
asserted
he → prepare → Quebeckers
Patrick Taillon, a professor of constitutional law at Laval University, said Quebec has a long history of taking steps to make the monarchy “invisible” in the province without abolishing it outright.
asserted
monarchy → say → it
In Ottawa, the governor-general typically delivers the Speech from the Throne to open sessions of Parliament.
asserted
general → deliver → Parliament
After Mark Carney became Prime Minister last year, the King delivered the speech himself during a visit to Canada.
asserted
King → become → Canada
But in Quebec, the lieutenant-governor since 1973 has given only a short inaugural address.
asserted
governor → give → address
The opening speech is then delivered by the Premier.
asserted
speech → deliver → Premier
Prof. Taillon pointed out that Quebec has also replaced the word “Crown” with “state” in provincial laws, and earlier this year announced that it would remove the British crown from the province’s official coat of arms.
asserted
it → point → arms
On Tuesday, Mr. St-Pierre Plamondon said he would ask the province’s lieutenant-governor, Manon Jeannotte, not to attend the opening speech at the National Assembly if the PQ forms government.
asserted
PQ → say → government
His caucus has previously boycotted the lieutenant-governor’s address.
asserted
caucus → boycott → address
Such cosmetic changes have a low chance of provoking constitutional challenges, Prof. Taillon said.
asserted
Taillon → have → challenges
But scrapping the role entirely would have a “high risk of being challenged.”
asserted
scrapping → scrap → risk
Mr. St-Pierre Plamondon has for years called for the monarchy to be excised from Quebec.
asserted
monarchy → call → Quebec
In 2021, the new PQ Leader published a sardonic video in which he listed several reasons to “love the monarchy,” including that it “reminds us of our colonial heritage.”
asserted
it → publish → heritage
He then called on the legislature to abolish the office of lieutenant-governor.
asserted
He → call → governor
After he was elected to the National Assembly in 2022, he and his caucus members were denied entry to the legislature after they refused to swear allegiance to the King.
asserted
they → elect → King
The move propelled the CAQ government to pass a law stating that only an oath of allegiance to the Quebec people would henceforth be required.
asserted
oath → propel → people
Mr. David is now challenging that law in court.
asserted
David → challenge → court
The Aporia
