Angus Taylor has finally found something he wants to cut: immigration.
asserted
he → find → something
Whether he can cut through politically, however, is another question entirely.
asserted
cut → cut → ?
The Coalition's announcement offers a substantial reduction in net overseas migration: 100,000 a year for the first two years, rising to 130,000 and 160,000 in years three and four respectively.
asserted
announcement → offer → years
Taylor claims it's the 'biggest cut to immigration in the history of this country.'
uncertain
it → claim → country
He's also promising to reduce the number of temporary visa holders by around 650,000 over four years.
asserted
He → promise → years
If implemented, it would be a serious change of policy direction for the nation.
asserted
it → implement → nation
Australians struggling to find a rental property, or watching their children abandon hopes of buying a home, are likely to agree with what Taylor is offering.
asserted
Taylor → struggle → what
But do those who have already abandoned the Coalition for One Nation care enough to properly listen, much less shift their votes, as a consequence of this policy shift?
asserted
who → abandon → shift
Australians doing it tough have endured lectures for too long from politicians who talk about the economic benefits of population growth while leaving households to absorb the costs that come with it.
asserted
that → do → it
An economy can get bigger without the people already living in it becoming better off.
asserted
people → get → it
More customers might suit big businesses.
uncertain
customers → suit → businesses
More international students might suit university budgets too.
uncertain
students → suit → budgets
But neither automatically means better living standards for Australians.
asserted
neither → mean → Australians
There's no doubt that the Coalition are the Johnny-come-lately followers on this issue.
asserted
Johnny → be → issue
Clearly it's One Nation that deserves the credit for putting immigration on the agenda in the first place
Housing, transport bottlenecks and wider public services don't expand to cope with population growth simply because Canberra issues another round of visas to prop up the economic growth forecasts.
Taylor is right to insist that immigration policy must reflect the country's capacity to accommodate more people.
asserted
policy → deserve → people
Prioritising construction skills also makes sense, because just cutting migration indiscriminately could remove some of the workers needed to build our way out of the housing shortage.
uncertain
cutting → prioritise → shortage
But a sensible policy direction doesn't absolve the Coalition of its political quagmire.
asserted
direction → absolve → quagmire
Pauline Hanson has been demanding lower immigration for years now.
asserted
Hanson → demand → years
The Coalition are the Johnny-come-lately followers on this issue.
asserted
Johnny → come → issue
Clearly it's One Nation that deserves the credit for putting immigration on the agenda in the first place.
asserted
that → deserve → place
Even Labor is changing its tune, albeit with less significant cuts.
asserted
Labor → change → cuts
Hanson doesn't need to win government to shape what governments and oppositions promise.
asserted
governments → need → what
That's happening already.
asserted
That → happen → ?
In some ways, for Taylor, announcing a tougher number is the easy part.
asserted
announcing → announce → number
Explaining why voters should trust his party to deliver on what's being promised is a different matter entirely.
asserted
what → explain → party
The Coalition spent years in government overseeing an immigration system it now says needs substantial repair.
asserted
it → spend → repair
Taylor and his colleagues can't pretend that every structural problem only began when Albo collected the keys to The Lodge.
asserted
Albo → pretend → Lodge
Labor, meanwhile, should spare us the predictable economic scare campaign that's coming.
asserted
that → spare → campaign
Ministers have already been searching for a microphone today, labelling Taylor's plan 'absolutely catastrophic'.
asserted
Ministers → search → plan
A carefully targeted migration program can recruit nurses and builders without treating every additional arrival as economically indispensable.
asserted
program → target → arrival
To suggest otherwise is rubbish.
asserted
suggest → suggest → ?
Taylor must nevertheless produce credible answers about workforce shortages, university finances and the federal budget.
asserted
Taylor → produce → shortages
Declaring the package budget neutral is a claim that needs to be proven.
uncertain
that → declare → ?
The Coalition may have stopped the boats, but migration via plane continued unfettered
uncertain
migration → stop → plane
Taylor says the Coalition has worked with the Parliamentary Budget Office, but full costings won't be released until closer to the election, which is a little fishy.
asserted
which → say → election
Halving the humanitarian intake was also part of the package announced today, but it's more about political positioning than seriously addressing housing problems as the Coalition is trying to claim.
uncertain
Coalition → halve → problems
Because Albo intervened to overrule Tony Burke's plans to make similar cuts, Taylor is taking advantage of that particular political wedge.
asserted
Taylor → intervene → wedge
For Taylor's plan to have any chance of dragging the Coalition back into the political fight, it will need to be followed up with broader economic policies that distinguish the Opposition from Hanson's insurgent party, to show that only they can viably govern if the increasingly unpopular Albo is kicked to the kerb.
asserted
Albo → have → kerb
The Aporia
