Even for the world’s premiere celebrity entrepreneur, Elon Musk is having something of a moment.
asserted
Musk → have → moment
He was on the cover The Economist’s special summer issue over the headline, “Should you be afraid of Elon Musk?”
When U.S. President Donald Trump invited the would-be, perhaps-already-are, gods of artificial intelligence to the White House, Musk was seated directly at the president’s side.
asserted
Musk → invite → side
The convened tech titans signed a “morally binding” declaration to use, more or less, AI for good things, not bad.
asserted
titans → convene → things
To have Trump preside over the making of moral commitments showed something of a sense of humour.
asserted
Trump → preside → humour
To rely on the moral commitments of the same people who have devoted impressive ingenuity and massive marketing into products that intentionally seek to addict their customers, including children, is less funny.
asserted
that → rely → children
Days had barely passed before Musk was appointed by Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth to a three-person panel to advise on autonomous weapons.
asserted
Musk → pass → weapons
Perhaps the moral commitment to use AI for good includes permitting AI agents to choose and destroy targets — to kill on their own.
asserted
commitment → use → own
Then Musk offered his views on Canadian Confederation, namely that there should be much less of it.
asserted
Musk → offer → it
Quebec, Alberta and Saskatchewan were advised to separate.
asserted
Quebec → advise → ?
That would leave an odd-looking Canada, but perhaps then Ontario would separate from it, too.
asserted
Ontario → leave → it
Musk, it should be noted, knows something about Ontario, having lived in Kingston for two years.
asserted
it → note → years
A decade or so ago, Queen’s University was rather more bullish on promoting its quondam student than it is now.
asserted
it → promote → student
I learned recently from an old alumni magazine that Musk and I arrived on campus together in September 1989 as undergraduates.
asserted
Musk → learn → undergraduates
We apparently lived in the same residence, Victoria Hall.
asserted
We → live → residence
I don’t recall ever meeting him.
asserted
I → recall → him
He may continue to pay attention to Canada, as a good number of the 14 children he has fathered with several women are Canadian citizens.
uncertain
he → continue → women
Their names alone — X Æ A-Xii, Techno Mechanicus, Seldon Lycurgus — suggest grounds for questioning his non-engineering, non-entrepreneurial judgment.
asserted
names → suggest → judgment
It is well established that he sees what other do not, and makes happen what others cannot.
asserted
others → establish → what
The adjective “unique” is rarely employed accurately; Musk may well be just that.
uncertain
Musk → employ → ?
At least he managed to convince his board of directors that he is exactly such, unique in that he is utterly irreplaceable.
asserted
he → manage → directors
For him, they crafted a trillion-dollar compensation package, making him unique in that regard, too — the world’s only trillionaire.
asserted
him → craft → regard
His worth is so great that it now measures half of the annual deficit of the American federal government.
asserted
it → measure → government
Which is relevant, in that before signing on to Trump’s moral pact, and advising the Pentagon, Musk did a few months of government service last year at the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE).
asserted
Musk → sign → Efficiency
He promised to find some $2 trillion in savings; after a few months his service wrapped up with estimates that DOGE achieved something on the order of $60 billion to $160 billion in savings.
asserted
DOGE → promise → savings
Not nothing — the Pentagon may need that much just to rebuild the military bases it lost during the Iran war.
uncertain
it → need → war
There is much debate over what DOGE achieved, and Trump administration claims are worth whatever credibility the Trump administration has.
uncertain
administration → be → credibility
What is not in dispute is that Musk and DOGE had one singular so-called success: the shuttering of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID).
asserted
Musk → have → Development
It was the main co-ordinating agency for the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR), the flagship 2003 program credited with saving millions of lives from HIV/AIDS, mostly in Africa.
asserted
It → co → Africa
When Musk cast his careful eye over the vast array of American government programs, he thought it best to start by cutting programs for the poor, the sick and the suffering.
asserted
it → cast → poor
DOGE shut down USAID and merged its programs into the State Department, significantly cutting USAID grants, including for PEPFAR.
asserted
DOGE → shut → PEPFAR
Thousands of experts in providing practical assistance to the poorest parts of the globe were let go.
asserted
Thousands → provide → globe
How many preventable deaths were not prevented is hard to measure, but
asserted
prevented → prevent → ?
the scale is sobering, measured in hundreds of thousands, if not millions.
asserted
scale → measure → thousands
Musk’s moral judgment was to start first with the most vulnerable and move on from there.
asserted
judgment → start → vulnerable
Actually, there was no moving on, as Musk lost interest and DOGE was wound down.
asserted
DOGE → be → interest
The most powerful government in the world enabled the richest man in the world to cut aid to the poorest people in the world.
asserted
government → enable → world
Rather, be afraid of what Musk betrays of our moment, when the powerful and the rich combine forces to further immiserate the weak and the poor.
asserted
powerful → betray → weak
The Aporia
