During the decades I lived in Kingston, Ont., I visited Belleville countless times.
asserted
I → live → Belleville
It’s on the way to Toronto and was a favourite place for a road-trip milkshake.
asserted
It → ’ → milkshake
I often stopped at the imposing St. Michael’s on the hill, where a good friend was the pastor.
asserted
friend → stop → hill
It’s a friendly place.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
I doubt I ever passed the Sons of Jacob Synagogue, where the Yom Kippur shooting took place.
asserted
shooting → doubt → place
It’s not far from the imposing churches nearby, but it is rather modest.
asserted
it → ’ → churches
It’s not a prominent synagogue in a prominent place.
asserted
It → ’ → place
Which made the shooting rather more ominous still.
asserted
shooting → make → ?
The congregation that gathered on Sunday night was small, some 25 pious souls at prayer.
asserted
that → gather → prayer
The congregation does not have a full-time rabbi.
asserted
congregation → have → rabbi
And yet, even here, antisemitic violence has arrived.
asserted
violence → arrive → ?
And if it has arrived at a little synagogue in a quiet city, then the toxin has spread far indeed.
asserted
toxin → arrive → city
Over the past several years, as antisemitic attacks on synagogues — as well as on Jewish schools, community centres and businesses — have spread, the source has usually been radicalized elements of Arab and Muslim diaspora communities.
asserted
source → spread → communities
Indeed, as news of the shooting broke, but before the shooter had been identified, some media sources immediately raised the spectre of immigration as the likely culprit.
asserted
sources → break → culprit
The shooter was Sean Ward, who died on Monday from wounds suffered in his gunfight with Belleville police.
asserted
who → die → police
Ward served for five years in the Canadian Armed Forces; he was discharged in 2022 over his objection to the COVID vaccine mandate.
asserted
he → serve → mandate
He later joined a lawsuit against the CAF in relation to that.
asserted
He → join → that
That is quite a long way from the cultural space of the protesters, agitators and harassers that we have become accustomed to seeing in the Jewish neighbourhoods of our big cities.
asserted
we → become → cities
It is a manifestation that antisemitism is not restricted to the extreme left, as it were, but also the extreme right.
asserted
it → restrict → left
More menacing still, it is seeping in from the extremes toward the mainstream.
asserted
it → seep → mainstream
While other Jewish buildings have been vandalized, shot at, even firebombed, this was an attempt at a mass killing.
asserted
this → vandalize → killing
Ward did not come to vandalize the building when it was empty.
asserted
it → come → building
According to police reports, he had come with weapons sufficient for mass murder.
uncertain
he → accord → murder
That there wasn’t a mass murder was due to the police officer on guard, requested by the synagogue after a suspicious man had been spotted a few days earlier.
asserted
man → be → synagogue
His body was the barrier, in fact, as he took gunfire, has been hospitalized and has a long recovery ahead of him.
asserted
he → take → him
Another officer, quickly responding, was the one who shot and disabled Ward.
asserted
who → respond → Ward
The Belleville shooting proved the prudence of that.
asserted
shooting → prove → that
But if a Belleville synagogue needs protection from an ex-soldier, have we now arrived at the lamentable state that has become, for example, the norm in France, where Jewish institutions are permanently secured by the armed forces?
asserted
institutions → need → forces
No one inside the synagogue was hurt in Belleville, but it was a near-enough thing that it may be that comparable measures are needed in Canada.
uncertain
measures → hurt → Canada
If the violence has reached Belleville, Canada has reached that point.
asserted
Canada → reach → point
Ward’s death likely means that we will not know as much as we should about the specific motives of the attack, and whence came his hatred for Jews.
asserted
hatred → mean → Jews
Defence Minister David McGuinty suggested that he would be enquiring about Ward’s experience in the CAF.
uncertain
he → suggest → CAF
It is hard to imagine that the CAF could have done more on that file.
uncertain
CAF → imagine → file
The depressing reality of antisemitism is that it is often unrelated to anything discernible, or is related to any passable nonsense on offer.
asserted
it → relate → offer
It’s a roving answer searching for any apparent questions, even if they are contradictory.
asserted
they → ’ → questions
The police preparedness and response in Belleville are what Canadian Jews have been requesting for some time.
asserted
Jews → request → time
Yet it seems a defeat, does it not, that it was necessary in Belleville, on Yom Kippur?
asserted
it → seem → Kippur
It has come to this in Canada.
asserted
It → come → Canada
The Aporia
