Alberta Premier Danielle Smith won’t be armed with a strong mandate to challenge the federal government for more powers after her proposals on immigration and constitutional issues were either defeated or received slim majorities in Monday’s referendum.
asserted
proposals → arm → referendum
The results also underline a stark divide between rural and urban voters on her proposals, which could pose political risks for the Premier as she campaigns toward next year’s provincial election.
uncertain
she → underline → election
“Certain areas of Calgary and Edmonton supported some [proposals], and certain areas did not,” Ms. Smith told reporters on Wednesday.
asserted
Smith → support → Wednesday
“So, I take that as, ‘Let’s proceed with caution.’
asserted
’s → take → caution
”
Elections Alberta continued to hand-count ballots on Thursday, surpassing its 48-hour deadline to tally the votes.
asserted
Alberta → continue → votes
The count nevertheless continued as the agency worked toward the finish line of the largest electoral event in Alberta history, with 20 million ballots counted and 99 per cent of voting areas accounted for by Thursday afternoon.
asserted
cent → continue → afternoon
Unofficial results showed that the four referendum questions centred around Alberta taking greater control over immigration were set to earn narrow majorities by Thursday night, ranging between 52 and 55-per-cent support.
asserted
Alberta → show → support
Meanwhile, four proposals focused on pushing for constitutional amendments, such as judicial appointments and abolishing the federal Senate, sat below 50 per cent.
asserted
proposals → focus → cent
Finally, one proposal, to make proof-of-citizenship mandatory at provincial election polls, was receiving 58-per-cent support – the top performer among the nine.
asserted
proof → make → nine
The results leave Ms. Smith without the mandate she explicitly sought from Albertans in the run-up to the referendum, spending $4-million in public money encouraging them to vote Yes on the nine questions.
asserted
she → leave → questions
Over the past month, Ms. Smith has pointed to the proposals as the best way to extract concessions from Ottawa, contrasting separatists who argued that a future secession vote would provide ultimate leverage.
asserted
vote → point → leverage
On Monday night, Albertans rejected the prospect of separation, with roughly 75 per cent of voters preferring to remain in Canada rather than hold a second, binding secession vote.
asserted
cent → reject → vote
Ms. Smith, claiming victory on the immigration proposals, said in the referendum’s immediate aftermath that she would continue her push to give Alberta more autonomy and defend the province’s jurisdiction.
But she hedged the next day when asked how she would proceed on immigration.
asserted
she → claim → immigration
Two of those questions propose charging health and education premiums to some non-permanent residents and limiting their access to social services.
asserted
Two → propose → services
“I take that as a general indication that [voters] want us to work with the federal government on getting this balance right,” Ms. Smith said.
asserted
Smith → take → government
Prime Minister Mark Carney showed openness this week to working with provinces on the issue.
asserted
Carney → show → issue
On the separation question, 41 per cent of rural voters endorsed holding a second, binding vote on leaving Canada, whereas Edmonton and Calgary polled 15 and 18 per cent, respectively.
asserted
Edmonton → endorse → cent
A similar dynamic played out on the other nine questions.
In Edmonton, a majority of voters rejected all nine proposals.
asserted
majority → play → proposals
In Calgary, a majority of electors voted against the nine questions except for the citizenship proposal.
asserted
majority → vote → proposal
In midsize cities such as Red Deer, Lethbridge and Medicine Hat, a majority of voters endorsed seven of the nine questions as of Thursday evening.
asserted
majority → endorse → evening
Two proposals – one on judicial appointments and the other on federal funding – were hovering around 49-per-cent support in midsize cities.
asserted
proposals → hover → cities
In rural Alberta, meanwhile, support for all nine questions surpassed 60-per-cent support.
asserted
support → surpass → support
Varying appetites for the government’s proposals will be a consideration for Ms. Smith’s United Conservative Party heading into next October’s general election, which she described on Wednesday as “the only fight that matters.”
asserted
that → head → fight
Much of that fight will be waged in Calgary.
asserted
Much → wag → Calgary
In the 2023 provincial election, the NDP swept Edmonton while Calgary almost evenly split support for the New Democrats and UCP.
asserted
Calgary → sweep → Democrats
The UCP won the rest of the province, with the exception of two seats.
asserted
UCP → win → seats
Matt Solberg, a political adviser who sat on Ms. Smith’s transition team when she became Premier in 2022, said many of the Calgary ridings up for grabs in the next provincial election rejected the immigration proposals.
asserted
many → sit → proposals
“There is a deep level of electoral math that you can do on these to say, ‘well, this message may resonate in rural Alberta, but it’s not going to resonate in these other ridings,’ ” said Mr. Solberg, partner at New West Public Affairs.
uncertain
Solberg → be → Affairs
Mr. Solberg suggested that the most logical avenue for Ms. Smith will be to strike a deal on immigration with Mr. Carney.
uncertain
avenue → suggest → Carney
Saskatchewan and Newfoundland joined Alberta’s push for more immigration powers this week.
asserted
Saskatchewan → join → powers
Quebec and Ottawa have shared a unique agreement since 1991, allowing the province to exclusively control the selection of incoming economic migrants, which Ms. Smith has frequently pointed to as her desired immigration model.
asserted
Smith → share → model
Melissa Caouette, principal at MC Consulting and former special assistant to Alberta premier Jim Prentice, suggested working with Ottawa toward a similar agreement and potentially punting the other immigration questions.
uncertain
Caouette → suggest → questions
She added that an agreement with Ottawa may address some of the concerns sitting with voters who endorsed the slate of immigration proposals.
uncertain
who → add → proposals
The Aporia
