On Monday, Albertans voted in a provincewide referendum that could have important consequences for Canada’s future.
uncertain
that → vote → future
But the question attracting the most attention may not be the one that matters most.
uncertain
that → attract → attention
The tenth question asked Albertans whether they want to remain in Canada or take the next step toward separation.
asserted
they → ask → separation
As of the time of writing, only a quarter of Alberta voters opted for another referendum.
asserted
quarter → opt → referendum
Three-quarters opted against another referendum and said they wanted to remain in Canada.
asserted
they → opt → Canada
But results from the other nine questions may tell a more interesting story.
uncertain
results → tell → story
All but Question 10 garnered majority support.
asserted
All → garner → support
Ipsos polling for Global News also found that Canadians outside Alberta supported eight of the nine proposals by majority.
asserted
Canadians → find → majority
Albertans may have rejected separation for now, but they also endorsed an agenda for changing Canada that has considerable support elsewhere in the country.
uncertain
that → reject → country
Prime Minister Mark Carney seems to understand the message he received.
asserted
he → seem → message
At a rally in Calgary on October 15, he urged Albertans to reject the other nine questions with the slogan “No to the Nine.”
asserted
he → urge → Nine
Carney wasn’t simply campaigning against separation.
asserted
Carney → campaign → separation
He was taking a position against proposals that could reshape our country.
uncertain
that → take → country
The remaining nine questions cover two broad areas.
asserted
questions → remain → areas
The first five concern immigration and access to public services.
asserted
five → concern → services
They propose greater provincial control over immigration, lower immigration levels, employment preferences and restrictions on access to publicly funded services for temporary residents.
asserted
They → propose → residents
They also address proof of citizenship for provincial voting.
asserted
They → address → voting
Get daily National news
The other four concern the federal system itself.
asserted
four → get → system
They propose provincial control over appointments to superior courts, abolition of the Senate, the right to opt out of federal programs without losing funding and provincial laws taking precedence over federal laws in areas of provincial or shared jurisdiction.
asserted
They → propose → jurisdiction
Some proposals would require constitutional changes.
asserted
proposals → require → changes
Others could be addressed through existing legislation.
uncertain
Others → address → legislation
None automatically becomes law even though Albertans voted for them.
asserted
Albertans → become → them
But majority support has given Premier Danielle Smith justification to pursue them.
asserted
support → give → them
Quebec’s recent election adds another layer.
asserted
election → add → layer
Voters there have just elected a sovereigntist Parti Québécois government.
asserted
Voters → elect → government
Alberta and Quebec have different objectives, but both could find common cause in demanding greater provincial autonomy.
uncertain
both → have → autonomy
Ottawa could soon face demands from two provinces with very different motivations seeking fundamental changes to Confederation.
uncertain
Ottawa → face → Confederation
For the past year, Donald Trump’s trade war against Canada has dominated Canadian politics.
asserted
war → dominate → politics
The threat from Washington has encouraged Canadians to rally around the flag.
asserted
threat → encourage → flag
But national unity in the face of an external threat hasn’t eliminated the disagreements within Canada.
asserted
unity → eliminate → Canada
It intensified during the Trudeau years, particularly over energy and environmental policy.
asserted
It → intensify → policy
For many Albertans, the dispute became a question of whether Ottawa was treating their province fairly.
asserted
Ottawa → become → province
Carney has tried to change that relationship.
asserted
Carney → try → relationship
His support for a new pipeline to tidewater represents a significant departure from the direction many Albertans associated with the previous Liberal government.
asserted
Albertans → represent → government
But a pipeline remains a promise until it is built.
asserted
it → remain → ?
Alberta’s demands for greater provincial autonomy extend well beyond energy.
asserted
demands → extend → energy
A poll can show support for a proposal, but it doesn’t reflect support for the negotiations required to make it happen.
asserted
it → show → negotiations
Canadians may like abolishing the Senate without agreeing on what should replace it.
uncertain
what → like → it
They may favour greater provincial autonomy without wanting to reopen the Constitution.
uncertain
They → favour → Constitution
But dismissing these results would miss the point.
asserted
dismissing → dismiss → point
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
