The Coalition’s migration plan risks breaching Australia’s free trade agreement with India, signed by the former Morrison government, allowing Indian students to stay and work for up to four years after completing their studies.
asserted
students → risk → studies
Angus Taylor on Tuesday announced plans to cut net overseas migration to 100,000 for the first two years of a Coalition government and up to 160,000 in year four, in a plan which would abolish temporary graduate visas, make major cuts to international student, bridging and temporary protection visas, and halve humanitarian places.
asserted
which → announce → places
Under the plan, temporary graduate visas would be slashed from 271,200 to just 10,000 by 2031-32.
asserted
visas → slash → 2031
The shadow home affairs minister, Jonno Duniam, said any graduate wanting to remain in Australia would have to return home and apply for a separate temporary visa.
asserted
graduate → say → visa
“Universities and other educational institutions have reverted to, sadly, selling a pathway to some form of permanency or perhaps even citizenship rather than education; that’s not what this scheme was set up for,” Duniam said.
asserted
Duniam → revert → what
“Abolishing the temporary graduate visa … means we can focus on skills we need in this country, not just whatever is churned out of our universities.”
asserted
whatever → abolish → universities
Duniam said there would be a four-year transitional phase before the abolition of the temporary graduate visa.
asserted
Duniam → say → visa
Some workers in priority areas such as health, education and in some regional areas would be allowed to remain.
asserted
workers → allow → areas
Phil Honeywood, the chief executive of the International Education Association of Australia (IEAA), said this could breach the India free trade agreement.
uncertain
this → say → agreement
A letter on the agreement, from the then Liberal trade minister Dan Tehan, in April 2022, states: “Australia agrees to maintain the following opportunities for former students to live, study and work in Australia temporarily after finishing their studies.”
asserted
students → state → studies
This includes allowing trade or diploma graduates to stay up to 18 months, bachelor graduates up to two years, bachelor graduates in Stem courses and master’s graduates up to three years, and doctoral degree graduates up to four years.
asserted
graduates → include → courses
Honeywood said it was “ironic” the Coalition was targeting the visa when it had negotiated special conditions with India, the second largest cohort of international students in Australia, behind China.
asserted
it → say → China
He warned Australia would lose skilled workers in critical areas under the Coalition’s changes.
asserted
Australia → warn → changes
He said Australia would take “money off bright young people for their qualifications” before sending them home without having the chance to benefit from their high-demand health, IT and engineering skills.
asserted
Australia → say → skills
Honeywood said the explosion in non-genuine international students coming to Australia was in part due to a post-Covid directive by the then Liberal prime minister Scott Morrison, who increased the number of hours international students could work in key industries.
“[Morrison] opened the floodgates to non-genuine students coming out of Covid without consulting the sector, promising more work rights for international students while they were meant to study full-time,” Honeywood said.
uncertain
Honeywood → say → students
A Coalition spokesperson told Guardian Australia there would be no treaty breach, and the party would look at establishing different visa pathways for some of those graduates.
asserted
party → tell → graduates
“Our treaty commitments are to provide temporary visa pathways for some students to stay post their study for short periods.
asserted
students → provide → periods
Which visas are provided is up to Australia,” the spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → provide → Australia
“When we implement this policy in government we will work through with affected international partners which new visa pathways, including skilled visa pathways, their citizens can access.”
asserted
citizens → implement → pathways
The Coalition’s plan would cut international student commencements to 240,000, below the current planning level of 295,000.
asserted
plan → cut → 295,000
But a spokesperson for the assistant minister for international education, Julian Hill, said the sector was now tracking towards 250,000 commencements for this calendar year.
asserted
sector → say → year
Universities Australia said the changes risked doing “lasting damage” to Australia’s higher education sector and the economy.
asserted
changes → say → sector
In a statement, its chief executive, Luke Sheehy, said removing the temporary graduate program could make Australia less attractive for students.
uncertain
Australia → say → students
“Restricting post-study work rights also risks making Australia less competitive for talented students and graduates at precisely the time we need more skilled people contributing to our economy.”
asserted
people → restrict → economy
Hill said removing the temporary graduate visa would make Australia a less attractive option and deny the country the ability to “select the brightest skilled graduates and would hurt Australian employers and industry”.
asserted
Australia → say → employers
He said all comparable nations had competitive postgraduate work opportunities.
asserted
nations → say → opportunities
“Wiping out temporary graduate visas would mean many of the brightest students will simply never choose Australia, further trashing our fourth biggest export.”
asserted
many → wipe → export
The Aporia
