LOUISVILLE, Colo. (AP) — Less than an hour after the first warning that a wildfire was headed for her suburban street, Tawnya Somauroo’s Colorado home was in ashes.
asserted
home → head → ashes
She has worked tirelessly for nearly five years to rebuild her house and help ensure her neighborhood can withstand the next blaze.
asserted
neighborhood → work → blaze
But as climate change contributes to more frequent wildfires, she worries that the careful landscaping, metal fencing and flame-resistant siding are not enough.
asserted
landscaping → contribute → wildfires
“We lost our homes and they left us to figure out for ourselves how to make our neighborhoods safe again,” Somauroo said.
asserted
Somauroo → lose → ourselves
“At the end of the day, it comes out of our pockets, you know?
asserted
you → come → pockets
And it does feel like maybe the oil and gas industry should have a part in this.”
asserted
industry → feel → this
She lives in Boulder County, one of dozens of jurisdictions across the United States suing oil and gas companies to help pay for damage from disasters linked to climate change.
asserted
She → live → change
On Monday, the first day of the Supreme Court’s new term, the justices will hear the Boulder case that could decide the fate of others like it.
uncertain
that → hear → it
The city and county of Boulder first sued two oil companies in 2018, years before the fire.
asserted
city → sue → fire
They argued that Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil had violated state law by deceiving the public about their contributions to climate change and sought unspecified damages to help cover the cost of worsening disasters.
asserted
Energy → argue → disasters
The companies say that a flood of lawsuits in state courts is not the way to deal with the global issue.
asserted
flood → say → issue
“The problem is that climate change is caused by pretty much everybody living on earth,” said Phil Goldberg, special counsel for the Manufacturers’ Accountability Project, an industry group.
asserted
Goldberg → cause → Project
“We need to figure out how to address that.
asserted
We → need → that
We need to address it in a very meaningful way.
asserted
We → need → way
This litigation doesn’t do that.”
asserted
litigation → do → that
The companies have the backing of the Trump administration.
asserted
companies → have → administration
Federal government attorneys say the lawsuits are a backdoor way to regulate heat-trapping greenhouse gas emissions and amount to an unconstitutional power grab.
asserted
lawsuits → say → grab
“No one state can superimpose its own regulatory preferences on the rest — least of all to address a global problem that exists almost entirely outside its borders and affects the world at large,” they wrote.
asserted
they → superimpose → world
The Clean Air Act, they say, allows the federal government, rather than states, to regulate emissions.
asserted
government → say → emissions
The Republican administration has largely used that power to roll back environmental regulations.
asserted
administration → use → regulations
Last month, the Environmental Protection Agency ceded some of its climate authority by repealing rules that limit planet-warming greenhouse gas emissions from power plants fueled by coal and natural gas.
asserted
that → cede → coal
The move could complicate its argument.
uncertain
move → complicate → argument
Boulder says it is not trying to regulate emissions beyond its borders, only holding companies accountable for local costs.
asserted
companies → say → costs
“Boulder County and city aren’t trying to change what’s happening in Texas or New York, they’re trying to get compensation for things happening now in Colorado,” said Sam Sankar, senior vice president at Earthjustice, which filed an amicus brief in the case.
asserted
which → try → case
Climate change was considered a factor in the 2021 Marshall Fire that destroyed Somauroo’s home, after the county’s suit was originally filed.
asserted
suit → consider → home
The total damage was estimated at $2 billion.
asserted
damage → estimate → billion
“Local county municipal governments play a very important role in helping front line communities adapt to climate change.
asserted
communities → play → change
This case could very well set a precedent,” said Chris Winter, executive director of the Getches-Wilkinson Center, an environmental research group in Colorado.
uncertain
Winter → set → Colorado
The case will come before a conservative-majority Supreme Court where environmental regulations have not always fared well, including a 2022 decision that limited the EPA’s authority to regulate carbon dioxide emissions from power plants.
asserted
that → come → plants
Justice Samuel Alito recused himself just a week before arguments after facing calls to step aside because he owns stock in oil companies.
asserted
he → recuse → companies
That creates the possibility of a tie vote in the case, though it’s unclear how likely that might be.
uncertain
that → create → case
The court is also weighing a question that experts say is a potential “off-ramp”: whether the justices have jurisdiction to hear the case at this stage.
asserted
justices → weigh → stage
Whitehurst reported from Washington.
asserted
Whitehurst → report → Washington
The Aporia
